Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 59 by Paul77 Paul77

Why do Jasmine need to talk to Spencer.

Jasmine have Spencer over for a talk.

The telephone rings. It’s Thursday around noon and Spencer sees that it is Jasmine calling. He starts smiling. Are Amber and Jasmine back in town and horny again he hopes?

“Hi Jazzy. He tells Jasmine as he answers the phone. How are you? Back home already? Hope that you and Amber had a good trip. “

“ Yeah Spence we are home. Jasmine tells Spencer. The trip was perfect. We both needed it. Lot of good sex at new places are always fun. “

“Any unusual places that is worth mentioning?” Spencer asks her.

Jasmine giggles a little and then tells him. “Well on the gras in a park was really hot. Many people in the park that day but I don’t think anyone saw us even if we where just hiding behind a tree.

But then with a totally different voice she tells him. “But Spencer we need to talk. Can you come over around 5 o’clock? This is not a telephone conversation.”

Spencer can’t really figure out what this is about but he has the time so.

“Sure Jasmine. He tells her. I will bee there at 5. But what is wrong?.

“Spencer nothing is wrong with us and you.” Jazzy tells him. “Amber and I love to have you over soon. This is a complete different issue that I need to discuss with you. So see you at 5 Spence.”

He then checks his telephone. He sees that Cindy has called him again today. She has called everyday since the breakup and also sent some text messages but he has not responded to anything from her. So utterly disappointed that things didn’t work out with Cindy. He remembers some sweet moments and of course the sex was mind blowing. Well to bad no more of that. But since then he has met Anna and perhaps she can fill some of the void.

It’s 5 o’clock and Spencer is at the door of the house where Amber and Jasmine lives. He rings the door bell. Jasmine greets him at the door with a sweet kiss. Spencer enters the house and immediately Jasmine stops walking and starts talking while they still are in the hall.

“Spencer you know how much I like you. The sex we have is amazing. I also know what a honest and caring man you are. You takes care of Amy so good. Such a reliable and respectful man and a gentleman. So please please for me be that awesome man now.” She looks at Spencer with affection but also makes it clear to him that he must be at his best now.

Without any other explanation they walk into the kitchen. Spencer starts thinking that this must be very serious and he gives himself a mental note to be at his best for Jasmine now. Whatever it is he will be fine and considering what meeting Amber and Jasmine has meant to him surely he can do that.

In the kitchen sitting at the table he sees Cindy. He gets many many different emotions in a blink of an eye. One emotion is how beautiful she is. Just blue jeans and a white shirt today. Nothing revealing or sexy but she still looks so gorgeous and hot. Cindy smiles at Spencer. She looks nervous but also confident. A strange combination considering the circumstances. She has a cup of coffee in one hand and takes a sip a somewhat nervous expression.

“So now finally you two must talk. Jasmines tells both of them. “Cindy called me yesterday and told me what happened on Saturday night. And that you Spencer refused to hear her tell you exactly what happened.” She looks at Spencer like she strongly disapproves of his behavior. “ I will leave now and leave you two alone. There is coffee, tea or soda in the fridge if you need anything Spencer. “ With that Jasmine leaves and goes upstairs.

Spencer goes to the fridge to get a bottle of water. He will drink the water but needs time to collect himself. This was a bit of a shock. Jasmine obviously has listen to what happened and decided that she thought Spencer needed to hear it. She also was disappointed. Well so was he with Cindy. Well now that he is here let’s try to be open minded and listen to what Cindy has to say. A part of him is very glad that this is happening perhaps there is a twist to it all. He sits down opposite Cindy and tells her.

“Cindy I am ready to listen to what happened. Please tell me everything. But tell the truth. If I later find out that you lied now that is unacceptable. “

Cindy is not pleased. She tells him in a stern and angry voice.

“Spencer you idiot. Of course I will tell you the truth. My god I been trying to do that for days now but you don’t want to talk to me. “

After a short break Cindy start telling the story.

“So on Saturday night I went to McClarens. Bought a beer and started chatting to some friends. Then this guy comes over and starts flirting with me. He brought me a beer and we started shooting pool. We hit it off. We grab a little at the table before we go dancing. We dance and we grind a little. He grabs my ass you get the picture. I am very horny now and tells him I want him to take me home to his place and fuck me.

Spencer is a bit shocked that Cindy tells him this. Why does she wants to tell him this. To hurt him? To get back at him. He doesn’t really understand but he tells himself ton stay calm and just listen. Cindy continues.

“Unfortunately he was married and we couldn’t go to his place.” Cindy actually smiles when she tells Spencer this. “ I told him we could not go to my home because I didn’t want neighbors and especially Sarah to see me so you could find out. He was too cheap to get a room so I sad goodbye to him.”

Cindy stops talking. Drinks some coffee it is probably cold now but it looks like she needed a break. Ok so far it was not exactly horrible news. Not nice to hear but not completely devastating either. If it is true it is basically exactly what the Math teacher told him the other day. But what about the rumor kissing outside and driving away together. Cindy looks at Spencer and asks him.

“So anything that you want to comment so far Spencer.”

“No Cindy not really. Spencer tells her. “ I heard almost exactly the same story from another person and I can tell you I am very glad that you tell me the truth. As for your actions so far. I don’t like them don’t like them at all. But if this is everything that happened that night that would not been that bad. But there is more to this story isn’t it?”

Cindy looks at Spencer and he is surprised by her reaction considering his answer and question. She almost looks pleased. Strange. Cindy starts talking again.

“Spencer I am glad that you finally gave me a chance to tell my story to you. Frankly I am also glad that you haven’t stormed out by now.”

“ But you are right now comes part 2 of the night. So another guy starts hitting on me. Actually he tried hitting on me before when I was shooting pool with the first guy.When I left the table to buy a beer he leaned over and whispered to me that I was the sexiest woman in the bar and that he would fuck me at the pool table if I gave him the chance. “

Cindy takes a pause here. Looks at Spencer. She waits for a strong reaction. When he doesn’t react that much she continues to tell.

“Well guy no 2 was actually hotter than the first guy. We talked just a little before we started dancing. We danced a lot. We had better chemistry on the dance floor and soon I got horny again. I told him to take me home to his place and fuck me. He immediately got us outside where we kissed. We got into my car and was off.”

“Just for your information. I wasn’t drunk. I didn’t do this wasted. I had three small beers and a small whisky for the night. It’s not that much for me for so many hours. I thought I was sober enough to drive. “

Spencer is again surprised by how Cindy choses to tells the story. Why does she emphasize that she was sober. Why not blame everything on ****. He can’t figure out why but he must admit he is a bit impressed with her honesty even though she tells hurtful things. Cindy goes on and finish her story.

“ So during the 10 minutes ride to his place I started to think that this was not what I really wanted. So when we arrived at his place I told him a lie. Told him I was very sorry and kissed him on the cheek as a farewell. I drove back home. Stayed up a little that night thinking about my night but then got into bed and got some sleep. Woke up on Sunday morning and spent most of that day in the garden fixing everything. Nothing exciting happened that they. And then I saw you early at school on Monday morning. “

Cindy looks relieved now when she has told Spencer everything. Spencer is very perplexed he doesn’t know what to think or say. Is it the truth really? Why did she change her mind. He thinks he wants more answers. Can he ask her for more explanations? Before Spencer has a chance to speak Cindy tells him her feelings about this meeting. Cindy tells him.

“That’s the truth Spencer. The complete truth. So now you know. This is what I wanted so desperately to tell you. So glad I got the opportunity. I will be ever grateful to Jasmine for her support and her help in fixing this meeting with you. Also grateful for you Spencer for listening to the hole story. At least I got some kind of closure from the fact that now you know everything.”

Cindy even exhales and now looks completely calm and relaxed. Spencer drinks some water. 1000 different thoughts goes through his mind. But when he thinks it over isn’t it just one big question that matters. Why? Why did she feel this way on Saturday night and why did she stop. Spencer got to ask her.

“Cindy I have only one question.” Spencer asks her as gently as he can. “Why?”

Cindy doesn’t look surprised. In fact she probably was expecting it. She thinks about it and then answers Spencer.

“It is complicated Spencer. It not just one thing. But even if I tell you Spencer does it matter?

Spencer thinks about this for a long time. He feels this is an important decision and he must get it right. Can he forgive her? His gut feeling is that he can. If he just could understand why and if she gives him an honest answer. He also feels that he might regret this moment forever if he didn’t try to work things out with Cindy.

“Cindy it matters. Spencer tells her. “Nothing you told me is unforgivable. Far from it even if it hurts. However I think I need to know why. So please tell me.”Spencer wants to tell her more but he better be quiet now.

“ Okey I will try to explain my actions. Cindy tells him. “ The hole Saturday morning and noon I was a bit frustrated. Perhaps that is not the right expression but I felt uncomfortable. I go to the club and I feel very happy and also comfortable. This is my playground. I love the reaction I get from men and I feel a rush of excitement. That might seem strange but that’s me.”

Cindy stops talking. She looks at Spencer waiting for him to reply.

“Cindy that isn’t that strange.” Spencer tells her. “ It’s the next step that bothers me. Hooking up with two guys on the same night with the intention of sleeping with them. That’s the part I don’t get.

“Tell me what you want Cindy? If you tell me exactly what you want and need maybe we can work something out.” Cindy answers the question.

“Obviously I want to fuck you Spencer. I am ok with our arrangement with Amber and Cindy that’s fine. With them and you I really enjoy those nights. But I don’t think a can promise you that I don’t sleep with other men. Right now I can’t make that commitment. “

Spencer wants a bit stronger commitment from Cindy. But on the other hand he also has an interest of not being faithful. Sleeping with Anna is something he really wants to do again. He needs to be clever now but how?

“Cindy this is an unorthodox arrangement we are trying to make. Just the fact that we agree to sleep with Amber and Jasmine is bizarre. I can’t accept that you can sleep with any other guy whenever you want to. That is not okey for me. But how about we limit ourselves to either seeing just one other person or something like that so we have some freedom but not all the freedom to do what ever we want. Can that work Cindy? I am trying to get this to work. Please tell me exactly what you need and what you want from me.”

Cindy thinks about it. Then she has a suggestion.

“Spencer I need a certain freedom. I can fell that you want me in a different way than I want you. You are so sweet to me and the sex is the best I ever had. But it is a bit suffocating. Right now I am not ready to be your girlfriend. In the future who knows. So I need to be free to do whatever I want once a week. I don’t think that I will do anything at all some weeks. But that feeling of total independence and the possibility to do what I need is what I must have.”

Spencer is so glad Cindy told him exactly how she feel. It hurts a little that she feels trapped but he realizes that he already had guessed that. But her suggestion he can certainly live with. The possibility to see Anna opens up for him. This could actually be great. He feels a bit guilty but he likes this deal.

“Cindy so glad you told me exactly what you need.” Spencer tells her.” I will be less clingy when we meet. I agree the sex is the best I have ever had. But this deal I can accept. But I will also change my needs and would like freedom to. Haven’t decided yet but I think I will be seeing the same woman each week. So I need you to tell me that you’re fine with me sleeping with her.”

Cindy looks surprised at the news. She immediately blurs out.

“Have you already meet someone new Spencer. Or is it just Amber and Jasmine in private you will fuck?”

“I might have meet someone new Cindy.” Spencer tells her. “ Not sure yet but perhaps. But if not her I will try to find another woman that I can sleep with on a regular basis. I don’t need the chase but given the chance I would like to sleep with two women regularly.”

Cindy laughs a little. She shakes her head. She then tells Spencer.

“Didn’t see that one coming. But that’s fair. So that’s a deal the. You and me most of the time. Jazzy and Amber with both of us together is fine. You and a regular lady. I am free to do whatever I want once a week. Deal”

“Definitely a deal Cindy. Spencer tells her. I wonderful deal if I might say so. So very glad we worked everything out. I missed you Cindy. I missed you desperately. I hope we can catch up sometime this weekend. “

Cindy moves fast over to Spencer and kisses him. The embrace a long time. The tension is over and they can relax in each others arms.

“ I can spend the night on Saturday if you like Spencer. Cindy tells him. “ Perhaps we visit the dungeon again. I am so horny. Haven’t fucked for so long that I can promise you an exciting night. “

“Wonderful news Cindy.” Spencer tells her. “Saturday it is and I am already looking so much forward to it. “

Cindy goes upstairs. Spencer hear that she is talking to Jasmine. He can’t hear what they talk about but they talk for quite a while. Then it gets quiet upstairs. He waits and waits nothing happens. Strange that Jasmine don’t come down and say hello. Still disappointed with Spencer perhaps. But what is taking Cindy so long. Even a toilet visit should be done by now. He start to get a bit annoyed with the long wait.

Spencer can hear Cindy walking down the stairs. She moves very slow but makes a lot of noise. He can tell that she now has changed to high heels. Then he sees her. She is completely naked except for the red high heels. She just stops when she sees that Spencer can see her. She smiles and looks so happy. She doesn’t say a word just looks at him.

Spencer slowly gets up. Goes to Cindy and gives her a kiss and then takes her in his strong arms and starts carrying her upstairs.

“Is the guest room available for us Cindy?” Spencer asks her. Cindy then answers Spencer.

“Yes Spencer. Jasmine told me that we are always welcome to use that room.”

Is everything good then?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)