One on one.

It’s always reassuring when a girl shows you with actions that she’s just as into it as you are, and more so when it’s two girls.

When we moved to the bed, Alice and Noelle actually pushed me down on it, crawling on top of me as they laughed and rubbed their bodies on me. Their hands roamed, touching me everywhere they pleased. We made out, groped each other and relished in the feeling of hot skin on skin.

As I was making out with Noelle, however, she pulled away, looked me in the eyes and spoke. “Oliver? I… I want to ask something.” I nodded for her to continue. “It’s… It’s our first time. I don’t mind if Alice goes first or if she watches us, but I’d like to… you know, do it… one on one.”

Oh. That made a lot of sense. Shit, I was so horny that, if things had continued without Noelle saying anything, I would’ve done it with the two at the same time.

“Y-Yes, of course,” I answered.

Alice chuckled. “Thanks for that,” she told Noelle. “I was going to ask the same, but… I was so turned on it almost slipped my mind. And who says I have to go first? You go.”

Noelle frowned and pursed her lips. {Always putting others before her…} “Rock, paper, scissors?”

“Very well. Two out of three?”

Noelle nodded.

First round winner: Noelle.

Second round winner: Alice.

Third round winner: Noelle.

Alice smiled. “Good. You asked first so you should go first.”

“I suppose…”

“And… you really don’t mind if I watch?”

“Eh? I mean…” Noelle blushed and fidgeted. “Getting embarrassed now would be pretty stupid, right?”

Alice laughed and gave Noelle a tight hug. “Seriously. How much cuter can you get?”

“That’s…!”

I couldn’t help the chuckle that escaped me. It was impossible to look at them without the biggest grin on my face. They looked adorable, so it was a little disappointing when they noticed me staring and got all bashful again. Actually, scratch that. They looked just as adorable being bashful.

“Now… I’ll just sit over there,” Alice said, getting off the bed and going over to the sofa. Noelle’s eyes followed her only while Alice had her back to us. Then, the redhead hugged me, kissed my neck and whispered in my ear.

“Make her crazy when it’s her turn, okay?”

I smiled. “That’s the plan. But for now…” I cupped her tits and pecked her lips. “It’s just you and me.”

Noelle grinned excitedly and mashed her lips with mine. I held her close, enjoying how her bosom pressed and rubbed against my chest. I fondled her butt and tasted her tongue, and when my dick brushed against her leg, I remembered something very important.

Holding Noelle, I turned us around and pushed her down on the bed. I kissed down her neck, her cleavage and her stomach. Her pussy was ready, already overflowing, but I wasn’t.

Quickly, I reached for the drawer in the nightstand next to the bed. There were condoms in there. A complementary box, like the free drinks. The girls and I… Well, we never used them, but we knew they were there.

“You’re not on the pill, right?” I asked Noelle.

Her eyes widened. She pursed her lips and shook her head.

{I almost let him do me raw! What was I thinking!?}

I let out a soft, restrained chuckle. That was flattering, but dangerous. Good thing I remembered.

Now… I’ve been having plenty of sex for the past three months. This is the first time I had to put a condom on. The first time I did it, with Mila at Thomas’ party, we did it without one because we didn’t have one that would fit. Even if I was able to pull out, that had been dangerous. Better not run that risk.

I got the condom out and tried to put it on. I had no experience with this, but we did have a few sex-ed classes. I remember how they explained one should put it on because the whole class was laughing. Place the condom on the tip of the penis, pinch the air out of the tip of the rubber and then unroll it all the way to the base. It was a perfect fit.

Noelle swallowed, yet she looked at me with an excited smile. She spread her legs and called to me. “Fuck me,” she whispered seductively.

I slid inside her slowly, but her drenched walls seemed to suck me in. It was easy to push in, but she got a lot tighter if I tried to pull out even a bit. Noelle stared at the place where we joined, her mouth half-open and her breathing growing heavier. Once I reached a certain depth, she flinched and closed her eyes.

“Are you okay?” I asked her.

In response, she laughed. “That didn’t hurt at all! Okay, it did a little bit, but I barely felt it.” She gingerly moved her hips, testing how it felt. She closed her eyes and moaned softly. “Mmm… Oh… Yes, it feels good. You can move.”

Again, her pussy fought me as I tried to pull out. It became tighter and sucked me in. It felt… really good. Undeniably good. I admit, the condom made it different, and it was like there was a voice in the back of my mind that was annoyed by it.

I ignored it.

I was sharing a bed with Noelle, my cock was inside her and she was squirming from pleasure as I moved in and out. The strange sensation of having a rubber on couldn’t outweigh the pleasure of having Noelle in my arms.

I leaned down to get closer to her. I captured her lips and her hand. Our tongues and fingers intertwined. With my free hand, I fondled her tits and played with her nipples, now knowing she liked it as much as Grace did.

Only about half of my dick was going inside her, trying to let her get used to it little by little. Remember the glass of water. Fill it drop by drop. By now, though, Noelle’s glass was more than half-filled. She bucked her hips against mine, kissed me fiercely with her arms around my neck, expressed her pleasure in muffled moans against my lips and in the involuntary writhing of her body.

I pushed in a little deeper. Noelle tensed and pulled away for a second, only to gasp and say, “Yess! Deeper!”

I went all the way in. The head of my cock reached her cervix, making Noelle flinch and yelp from surprise. Yet she had the biggest, cutest and most aroused smile in the world.

I couldn’t help myself. “You like it?”

“I love it!” She gasped. “Fuck me, Oliver! Fuck me hard!”

I smacked my hips against hers, bringing them down over and over at a fast pace. Her pussy was gripping me for dear life, her back arched, her jaw dropped and she closed her eyes.

And I couldn’t forget that, while I fucked this gorgeous, petite redhead, Alice was watching us. The blonde was sitting on the sofa, squeezing one of her breasts and with two fingers deep in her pussy. I gave her a firm, hungry look while I pounded Noelle and licked her neck, Alice shivered, smirked and licked her lips.

I turned my full attention back to Noelle. Her glass was about to overflow, and so was mine. “I’m… I’m coming…!” she muttered breathlessly. “Haaah… I’m gonna…!”

We climaxed at the same time. My second load filled the condom and made it swell inside Noelle’s pussy. My lover, meanwhile, went as stiff as a board. Her face was unforgettable. She had her eyes shut and a wide, lip chewing smile of pure ecstasy. Her body trembled in my arms, assaulted by aftershocks even after relaxing a bit. I remained close to her, embracing her, planting kisses on her, enjoying both my own afterglow and hers.

I’d just fucked Noelle… I really just had sex with a new girl.

I felt an overwhelming catharsis wash over me, and it was bliss.

Author's Note: I'll be taking a break next week, meaning no new chapters. I hope you'll understand.

The Patreon is up to 8 chapters ahead of what I publish here. Just in case you'd like to support the story and read ahead. I'll also be running a poll there soon.

As always, thank you very much for reading.