Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 32 by ShimoDragon ShimoDragon

What does Alex choose as she waits?

Handsy Handful

Alex giggled at the sight of Handsy Handful. What a deliciously naughty option! She smiled as she picked the punishment and put away her phone. Looking up she saw a car pulling in which Jacob stood to greet. Out came a girl with a punk aesthetic and a guy with a much more mainstream sense of fashion.

"Hey, good to see you two!" Jacob pulled the both of them into a hug, "Let me introduce you to our guest for tonight. This is Alex, she's Ryker's new girlfriend."

"Nice to meet you!" Alex approached to shake the man's hand but accidently brushed her own hand against his groin as she raised it.

"N-nice to meet you too," No one else had noticed and Alex didn't even register it herself but he was certainly affected by it, "I'm Dennis and this is my girlfriend Izzy. I play bass and she's our vocalist."

"Yo," Izzy waved from behind him, "Looks like Ryker finally caught herself a big tittied bimbo huh?" Her tone was casual with a hint of distain.

"Hey, watch it Izzy," Ryker called from inside the garage, "Just because she's hotter than you doesn't mean you can be a bitch about it."

"Fuck you, Ryker," Izzy flipped the bird.

"Alright, cool it ladies. Let's just start playing before a cat fight starts," Jacob interjected.

Before the four of them started playing Ryker spoke to Alex under her breath, "Don't mind Izzy, the two of us usually get along great but she can't stand my taste in girls. She might be a little bitchy at times but don't let it get to you, as long as you don't engage she'll lay off eventually. She's actually a bit of a softy so if she realizes you're nice then she'll back off with the remarks."

With introductions competed the garage door was closed and the band began running through their songs. Alex sat from the sidelines in a sort of aw. It wasn't like they were on the level of a major artist but they were still pretty damn good. However, as they continued practicing some problems began to arise. Both of the boys were having trouble focusing with Alex lingering in the corner of their vision. She was unintentionally lifting up her sizeable chest with her arms which drew the boys attention directly to her tempting cleavage.

Dennis was doing a decent job of hiding his arousal, only misplaying a note here or there, but Jacob was fumbling much more blatantly. He was constantly falling out of tempo, which was particularly bad as the drummer, and he missed multiple tempo changes as well. Izzy was getting pissed and Ryker was starting to get horny herself. All in all, the session was quickly deteriorating into a disaster.

"What the hell guys?! This is supposed to be a serious band, not some kind of hobby!" Izzy yelled out, "If you clowns are going to keep fucking around, and I'm looking at you Jacob, then I'm going home!"

With that she stormed out and drove off.

"Yeesh," Jacob broke the silence, "Gotta be her time of the month or something, right?"

Dennis fired a glare at him, "Don't be an ass, dude. You know how serious she is about the band. Damn it... looks like I'm taking a cab home."

Dennis stayed in the garage and pulled out his phone while Alex, Ryker, and Jacob went inside to wind down a bit before the couple left. Ryker excused herself to go to the washroom and Alex took a seat next to Jacob. She decided she might as well get to know some of her girlfriends friends a bit better while she was here.

"So," Alex started, "What do you do outside of playing drums Jacob?"

Jacob tensed up a bit as he replied but Alex couldn't tell why, "O-oh. I- ah- I'm a recent graduate and I currently work as a mechanic. I- urgh- usually help Ryker with her bike if she has any problems..." He bit his lip.

"Oh that super interesting! I'm still in school, I'm studying in fashion with a minor in business," Alex casually continued the conversation.

While Alex remained clueless to Jacob's behavior, the man was in heaven. Alex was rubbing Jacob's groin through his pants as they spoke and she was completely unaware of it. Jacob was admittedly kind of a dick but even he wouldn't typically try to steal a friend's girl. The way Alex was coming on to him so blatantly was making him reconsider this stance, however. He decided to make his move as he replied.

"Fashion huh? That seems fitting for a hottie like you," Jacob reached up and slipped a hand under Alex's crop top to fondle her tits. He was please to find that she wasn't wearing a bra.

A girly gasp escaped Alex's plump lips, "Oh, thank you," As far as she was concerned there was nothing strange about someone she just met pawing at her boobies.

Jacob was clearly no longer interested in chatting as he silenced Alex by locking lips with her. Alex couldn't believe how friendly Jacob was being! He was such a nice guy! The pair exchanged a long, wet kiss as they continued feeling each other up. Jacob intentionally, and Alex unknowingly.

Jacob was about to take things to the next level when Dennis entered through the garage. Jacob's eyes went wide as he prepared to give an explanation but something entirely unexpected happened. Dennis unbuckled his pants and let them drop to the floor, his demeanor completely different than it had been earlier. Unbeknownst to anyone, Dennis had been affected by one of Alex's punishments.

"Alex, princess, let me give you my cock. You deserve to be pampered and pleasured, and I'm completely willing to treat you right!" Dennis exclaimed almost desperately.

Alex went slack jawed staring at Dennis' exposed member. She couldn't believe that he would pull it out in the middle of such casual chit-chat but she was even more surprised that he seemed to think that she was interested in men. She wondered what it was she possibly could have done to make Dennis believe that she like men, as she absent mindedly continued to stroke Jacob's cock through his pants and he squeezed her girls again. Alex was about to speak up and let Dennis know that she was only interested in women but she hesitated for too long and Jacob spoke first.

"I'm not sure what's going on with you Dennis but it looks like Alex's brain has already gone fuzzy with how turned on she's gotten. The poor thing can't even think straight from how horny she is, let alone form a reply! Isn't that right, beautiful?" He chuckled as he leaned in to suck on Alex's neck.

At Jacob's words a fog settled on Alex's mind. She could barely register what was going on anymore thanks to her burning need for stimulation, a massive hard on growing in the hidden confines of her false nethers. She moaned as Jacob got a little more forceful with his groping, "Yeeesssss! I'm so flipping horny!"

"We can help with that, don't worry," Dennis helped Alex to her feet where he and Jacob led her to the bedroom.

Alex briefly wondered if Ryker was waiting in the bedroom but the fondling from the two men holding onto her while they walked was enough to wash that thought from her mind. As they moved through the house Dennis removed their own clothes as well as peeled off Alex's. Once the three of them reached the bed, fully nude, they fell into it on their sides. Alex was in the center facing Jacob with a man on either side. She opened her mouth to speak but all that came out was a guttural moan as Dennis rammed into her from behind without warning. Jacob didn't waste anymore time on words either and he plunged into Alex's soaking pussy.

Her brain momentarily short circuited from the abrupt stimulation and by the time she had any sense about her again Jacob had already locked his lips onto hers once more. Her mind was melting. Every thrust from either boy pushed her deeper onto the others shaft. She was completely trapped between the two of them, she would have no chance of worming out even if she wanted to. She was a dainty, curvaceous prisoner pinned between two masculine wardens. Dennis roughly grabbed Alex's melons to give his thrusts more leverage as Jacob wrapped his arms around her tiny waist.

The boys continued plowing both of Alex's bottom holes as her tongue wrestled with Jacob's until suddenly a voice came from the door way, "If the two of you are going to fuck my girlfriend silly while I'm still in the house then the least you could do is invite me!"

Jacob paused for moment to look at Ryker who had just finished stripping out of her boyshort panties. Having been caught in the act he felt like he should stop but she didn't actually seem to care as long as she got in on the action. Noticing that Dennis hadn't paid Ryker's entrance any mind Alex herself didn't even seem to know what planet she was on, he decided to bury the last of his concerns and just keep fucking.

Ryker climbed into bed near the trio's heads, "Outta the way, drummer boy. Her tongue is about to pay me back for our movie date."

Jacob complied and lowered his head as Ryker wrapped her legs around Alex's face. With his own face now buried in Alex's humongous honkers he took the opportunity to remove one of Dennis' hands and start sucking on her nipple, flicking his tongue back and forth across the perky peak. Meanwhile Alex was almost on autopilot as she started eating out Ryker. The moment her girlfriend's snatch had engulfed her she was exploring the depths with her tongue. All the while Dennis and Jacob were still rhythmically pumping into her.

If she was a prisoner before, now it was more like she was a buried treasure. An absolute sexpot locked beneath an inescapable pile of desire, with every single one of her erogenous zones being stimulated in some way. And it was inside this pile, where every sense was either blocked or numbed excluding the sexual bliss of touch, that Alex went from being a she to returning to being a he. Restored to his (mostly) normal mental state, Alex was instantly disoriented. He was unsure of where he was or how he had gotten there but, frankly, that barely mattered. Sexual gratification was all that was on his mind.

He was rocking between two sources of pleasure. One in front and one behind. He quickly found that the stimulation was much greater the deeper the rocking penetrated so he started rhythmically thrusting against the flow of the rocking. He'd slam into something as it pushed into him from behind, sending waves of pleasure up his spine, and then he'd slam into the something in front, rocketing orgasmic energy straight to his core. Keeping this rhythm, Alex was able to not only derive even greater thrill from the rocking but he was also in a constant buzz of euphoria. Not a fraction of a moment passed without Alex being stimulated in some way.

"Hey, slut! I didn't tell you to stop! Keep that tongue moving!" Ryker's muffled voice found its way to Alex's ears through her powerful thighs.

He voice brought with it a realization for Alex. He felt so blissful because he was having sex with his girlfriend! It all made sense now. Of course Alex didn't realize that his flawed logic didn't explain the double penetrative ramming he was experiencing below nor the wonderfully massaging of his plump puppies, but his sex driven mind wasn't in a state for logical thinking. Hoping to give back even a fraction of the ecstasy he was feeling Alex started going to town on Ryker's dripping pussy. All his remaining focus, outside of maintaining the rocking rhythm, was dedicated to intricate and precise movements of his tongue. Ryker had complimented Alex on his cunnilingus before but now he was starting to learn what Ryker liked specifically so he was getting even better.

All of these factors combined caused quite the miracle to happen. All four members of the mini orgy climaxed at exactly the same time. The last thing Alex felt before blacking out in the aftermath of the intense, orgasmic pleasure was both Dennis and Jacob firing off their hot sticky loads deep within him.

(Author's Note: As any of you who have been following this series will know, I have been very infrequent in updating this branch. This is partially because I lack the motivation to write at times but more often it is because I get burnt out by the daunting length of each chapter. These chapters would become so long because I felt the need to continue the trend of posting a punishment decision at the end of each chapter yet I also wanted multiple events to happen between each punishment. So in an attempt to stave off my burn out so that I might be inclined to post more often I am no longer going to end each chapter with a punishment selection. Here's to hoping it helps!)

(TLDR: No more punishment decisions at the end of each chapter, sorry.)

What does morning bring?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)