Epilogue: happy birthday, David

[I couldn't just leave the story at "harem is complete, bye", so I'm back in the "main" story for an epilogue.]

Amy had filled a gap in his harem that David had barely even realized was there. Sarah just seemed more alive than she ever had. She had never seemed unhappy before, but now she was positively vibrant.

David was slouched on a couch pondering this when Sarah bounced up and announced, "your birthday is coming up."

He looked at her, unsure why he was being informed of this fact.

She continued, "well, what do you want?" She hopped onto the couch and straddled him, holding her pussy just above his cock. She looked down, straight into his eyes, "you know you can have anything you want."

His cock was instantly rock hard, straining toward her. He managed to ignore it for a moment to kiss her and respond, "I already have everything I want."

She lowered herself slightly, letting her pussy just brush his cock, "there must be something you want."

He smiled, "with Amy here now, I can't imagine anything else I could ever want besides all of you. Don't get me anything," he said firmly.

She smiled back, "let me think about it. I'll come up with something."

He had experienced Sarah's surprises before and was both excited and frightened. He smiled up at her before grabbing her hips and guiding her down onto his shaft.

A few mornings later, the apartment seemed quiet.

That didn't bother David. He was happy to be spending the time with Chloe, who was enthusiastically rubbing her clit while he fucked her doggy style. He listened to her cum for as long as he could before pushing deep into her and filling her pussy.

As the two of them caught their breath, Chloe licked his cock clean, loving the taste of both of them together.

When she decided she was done, she uncharacteristically suggested, "let's go out to the living room."

David followed her out, curious at her unexpected direction.

As she guided him around a corner, he realized the apartment wasn't as quiet as he had thought. He was greeted by the sight of his whole harem, all waiting expectantly.

He turned to Chloe who shrugged and answered the question he hadn't yet asked, "I don't know, I was just supposed to distract you for her."

David chuckled, "well done," before turning his attention to the person who was clearly "her" in that sentence.

Sarah looked back with mischief in her eyes before turning the the group, "thanks everybody for being here. Sorry I was so secretive about why." She turned back to David, "it's surprisingly hard to get everybody here all at once."

"Sure," David agreed. It seemed like the safest response. He noticed that even Grace and Alyssa were present and gave them a smile.

Sarah continued, "David's birthday is coming up, and he said he didn't want anything besides 'all of us'." A collective "aww" came from the group.

Sarah emphasized, "I didn't think that was a good enough answer." She walked over to a shelf and picked up a small trophy that looked like it had come from a dollar store. A sticker that was almost on straight said "winner".

Her speech continued, "but I couldn't think of the perfect gift either. So," she handed the trophy to David, "whoever gives him the best birthday present wins." She wrapped her hand around his cock and assured him, "none of us is going to buy you socks."

She turned back to the girls, and in a business-like tone, added, "group entries allowed," she looked at David, "and probably encouraged," she turned back to the girls, "you can each only make him cum once. Contest starts after dinner." She walked back into the group while smiling at Amy and high-fived her.

Excitement rose as the girls started to form alliances. David saw Julia and Maria whispering confidently.

He raised his voice above the din, "wait, wait, wait... it's not fair having couples together. New rule: couples have to split up."

Sarah looked at him in shock. He had obviously ruined whatever winning plan she had involving Amy.

The excitement level behind her increased as alliances were re-formed. Sarah quickly turned to join the discussions. As the girls chattered, David saw Vicky look around. She raised her voice above the crowd, looking at Sarah, "I can film it, right?"

Sarah smiled, "yeah, that would be hot."

Cynthia piped up, "hey wait... she's going to steal our ideas!"

Vicky offered, "how about I go first then?"

That seemed to satisfy the group. The women quickly formed agreements and scurried off.

David found himself suddenly alone. He turned on the WNBA game and waited.