Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 83 by thosearemysecret thosearemysecret

What does Whitney ask Tanya to do?

Lick

"Tell them about you and Maggie," Whitney commands.

Tanya starts talking. "Well, Maggie and I met in kindergarten. In fact, that's where I met most of you, but Maggie and I were both into unicorns, so I think that's why we clicked so much. Every summer my parents would take us to the county fair..."

Whitney scowls down at Tanya, assuming the cursed girl is messing with her. "No, I mean what happened last night with the two of you."

The part of Tanya that has some self-control manages to limit the confession. "I tried on my costume for Anime Comic Con and we had dinner."

"And what else? What did you tell me you did with Maggie's..." Whitney scrunches up her face "...hairy twat?"

There are gasps all around. A couple of 'ew, gross' comments. McKenize stares wide-eyed at her naked friend. "You didn't," she whispers.

"Oh, yeah, that, I totes munched her hairy twat." There's a wave of shame that comes over Tanya as she says it out loud. It was bad enough in front of Whitney but in front of all of her peers, even her love for doing it couldn't overwhelm the embarrassment of admitting something so intimate.

"You're gay?" McKenize blurts out.

"Oh my god!" Another cheerleader says.

"What about Chad?" she hears someone whisper behind her.

Suddenly, Tanya is surprised to feel like maybe she is gay. Her cheeks flush. Her lip trembles. She feels scared realizing this was something that was deep down inside. But what about Maggie's Dad? What about her attraction to Chad? What about all of those boy crushes she's had over the year? Other than wanting to go down on Maggie she'd never ever felt an attraction to girls, but at this moment she felt a powerful desire to check out the other naked girls in the locker room.

"Oh no," Whitney said. "Tanya told me that even though she loves licking pussy she isn't gay. Isn't that right Tanya, you're not a lesbo but you love burying your face in snatch?"

Tanya felt dizzy. Her emotions whiplashed as the curse tugged her from straight to gay and back to straight again. That must have been it, she thought. It wasn't that she was gay, but that she simply enjoyed the tase of pussy. She loved the feeling of having thighs around her head and her tongue exploring those velvety folds. It was that she thought it was only Maggie's hairy twat that was confusing her sexuality. It wasn't simply Maggie's hairy twat - it was pussy in general. "Yes, she says." I'm not gay, but yeah, I guess do kinda, sorta have a thing for...um...licking pussy." Her cheeks burn with shame.

Bethany was oddly silent during all of this. She was, in fact, a closeted lesbian, and much of her anger at Tanya came from her attraction to her classmate. At this moment, she wondered if Tanya was struggling with similar issues. Could there be a chance?

"So here's what we're going to do," Whitney continues. "I'm going to reward you for coming to your senses and you're going to apologize to one of these three by going down on them. Girls, you'll play rock, paper, scissors to decide who gets the pleasure of Tanya's tongue."

Melissa throws up her hands and stands up. "You're all crazy. I'm done," and she makes her way to the shower.

"Guess you're off the squad," Bethany yells.

"Only Ms. Steele can kick me off the squad Beth. For fuck's sake," she yells back as the shower starts.

Fuyoko doesn't know what to believe. She only transferred to this school this year. She looks at McKenzie who's now turned to her with her hand behind her back. McKenize, who has the same curse as Tanya, feels the need to play. Fuyoko, who respected McKenize and Tanya as leaders, feels she knows best. Maybe Whitney could kick her off the squad. Her mom would be so pissed!

McKenzie, on the other hand, was horrified. She never wanted to cross this line with her best friend, Tanya. Yet, she felt compelled to go through with at the least playing rock paper scissors. She was glad when she realized Fuyoko wouldn't back out, but she was also worried about the impressionable new student.

Tanya didn't know what to think. She'd never considered any other women this way, yet, there was a feeling of excitement at the opportunity. It made her ashamed. She almost turns to tell McKenzie and Fuyoko to not go through with it, which would have been great for McKenzie, but she holds her tongue and clenches her thighs together. She wanted them to go through with it. She felt awful.

Who wins?

Comments

      Want to support CHYOA?
      Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)