The cum spills from Chrissy's mouth

The first time, just the sight of Nancy Wheeler wrapping her lips around his cock had almost made Eddie cum. As it was, he had tried to pull out as quickly as possible but the blonde cheerleader had not been ready for him to cum in her mouth. Eddie ejaculated prematurely, spattering Robin and Chrissie’s faces with his cum. They had to start from the beginning, waiting until Steve had cum (straight into Nancy’s mouth) before going with their original pairings.

The second time, they had almost managed it. Nancy had given Eddie another amazing blowjob, sucking from the tip to the root of his cock and licking at the underside of his balls until he had been ready to cum. Chrissie had been ready for him this time, catching all of his load in her mouth until a white puddle was sloshing behind her teeth.

Robin and Nancy had both teamed up on Steve’s cock until he too had cum in Chrissie’s mouth. But then had come the tricky part. The instructions stated that Chrissie had to get all the semen from her mouth into Robin’s, then Robin had to pass it on to Nancy.

After quickly discussing (with two loads still in her mouth, Chrissie had to communicate with nods and shakes of her head), the two girls manoeuvred themselves into a line. Looking as unexcited as possible, Robin sat herself down and Chrissie leaned over her to let the sloppy cum drip from her mouth into Robin’s.

But they misjudged it and the white stream fell all over the bottom half of Robin’s face. A note informed Nancy that she had to lick it all off of Buckley, then, after Nancy had swallowed the two loads, they had all realised they would have to try again.

Eddie tried to look as glum as the others but if this had been any other occasion, he would have been ecstatic. Three blowjobs from Nancy Wheeler, in less than two hours! If he had actually shown how the experience had made him feel, he think both Nancy and Steve would have punched him.

As it was, he sat back and occasionally helped jerk himself off as Nancy, Chrissie and even Robin did everything they could to revive him and Steve’s cocks. It took all three girl’s mouths on his cock, a tit-job from Robin and Chrissie and Nancy sucking one of Eddie’s testicles each, but they managed it.

Again, two loads were safely secured in Chrissie’s mouth. Again, she leaned over Robin but this time both girls had learned from their mistakes. The feeling of yet more cum filling her mouth must have made Robin gag, but she managed to hold it all in until Nancy was lying underneath her, ready to have the semen deposited down her own tonsils.

They all held their breath as Robin lay herself over the smaller girl, pressing their lips together as both girls worked together to get all the strings of semen out of Robin’s mouth and down Nancy’s throat. It was the most intimate and **** french-kiss that Eddie had ever seen. But it worked.

They all watched Nancy’s throat as it bobbed up and down, then she broke off her kiss from Robin. Eddie’s breath caught in his throat as Nancy opened her mouth… and revealed she had swallowed every drop of semen.

Her face was bright red but Wheeler stuck her tongue out at the old grandfather clock in the wall and they all cheered, ecstatic.

But then the bell tolled and Eddie remembered what Vecna had said: there could only be one winner. For going off-script and making out, he and Chrissie had forfeited their chance to win. Which just left Steve, Nancy and Robin.