Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 41 by syncmaster69 syncmaster69

What else is going on in the Cabin tonight?

Even the Orc has his Reasons

Even the Orc has his Reasons

Ashley and the girls washed and dried the dishes, with Gavin and Peter helping them clear the table and put away the dishes. The wide grin on Madison's face made Ashley think her time helping Zack with the barbeque was a success, and even Meagan's flirting with Madison could not erase it. Ashley wondered what else she could do to distract Brandon and keep him away from Madison so she could have another chance to get closer to Zack.

The problem was that the football game Brandon and Trent were watching was almost over and she had to do something before Brandon could notice Madison slipping away and looking for Zack. An idea came to her mind and she decide that getting Brandon away from the cabin and everyone else would make it easier for Madison. 'he can't interfere if he's not there' Ashley mused as she sat on Brandon's lap and whispered into his ear "let's go to the lake."

Brandon's eyes lit up and his mood shifted from the losing game he was watching to his smiling Ashley. They silently left Trent watching the game and hurried off to the beach right next to the short pier that had been built to bring in supplies when the cabin had been renovated and was still used on occasion.

Ashley hoped that being this far from the others would give Madison another opportunity to spend time with Zack without having to worry about Brandon showing up to interrupt her and scare off Zack.

Ashley and Brandon started walking across the shore and splashing each other as they fooled around next to the pier. Brandon kept playfully groping at Ashley while she pretended to squeal and barely jump out of reach once in a while till Brandon picked her up and swung her around pretending to through her into the lake.

"NO!" Ashley laughed and squealed. "I'll get my clothes wet!"

"Then take them off" Brandon laughed and smirked at Ashley.

"Yea you wish!" Ashley laughed back at her boyfriend while splashing him back. Brandon's strong arms swung the light blonde girl around and tossed her up in the air before catching her again. Ashley squealed and laughed again "Stop!" she cried out playfully.

But Brandon laughed again "Take it off!" and tossed Ashley up in the air again and caught her just before she splashed into the lake.

"Okay! Okay!" Ashley squealed.

"Really?" Bradon asked hopefully.

"Nooo" Ashley mocked her boyfriend.

Brandon tossed her up again and each time Ashley laughed and squealed. On the third throw, Ashley squealed "Okay! Okay! I'll do it!"

"Really?" Brandon asked again hopefully and Ashley smiled and nodded.

Brandon kept Ashley off her feet and his arms as he kissed her while Ashley wrapped her legs around his waist. "You'll do it?" he asked and tilted his head to the lake. Ashley grinned, giggled, and nodded mischievously.

They both quickly stripped and left their clothes on the beach as they moved into deeper water next to the pier. Brandon couldn't take his eyes off her round well toned ass wondering if she would ever give him her last cherry. The thought turned him on so that even the cool water of the lake couldn't calm down his raging erection as he walked behind Ashley. He grinned as he noticed how the cool water made her nipples stand out.

Reaching the deeper water Brandon turned Ashley around and wrapped her arms around his neck and her legs around Brandon's waist, trapping his stiff cock between them as they kissed. Brandon soon shifted his grip from her thighs to ass checks, spreading them apart as he guided Ashley's hips, grinding and rubbing her pussy lips against his stiff cock.

As she wrapped her arms and legs around her boyfriend she quickly glanced over at the cabin. She could see a few figures moving across the area and wondered if anyone at the cabin could see them next to the pier. The thought of being caught sent a thrill of excitement through her petite body

Ashley's stiff nipples brushed against her boyfriend's hard chest sending tendrils of pleasure radiating into her breast and to the rest of her body, blending with the waves coming from where Brandon's dick rubbed against her pussy lips and clit. Even the cool water from the lake couldn't seem to quelch the heat she starting to feel coming from Brandon's cock. Just as Ashley shifted her hips up to try and line up his dick with her pussy they heard a voice call out from the start of the pier.

"Hey Brandon!" they heard someone call and the couple broke their kiss with a groan of frustration.

"What the fuck Trent!" Brandon yelled as he turned around to face his best friend. Trent paused for a moment before he continued to walk down the pier to get closer to the couple.

"Sorry dude," Trent apologized as he got closer to the couple and sat down on the pier, "Just trying to find Maddie,"

'Oh Shit!!' Ashley gasped in silence. she couldn't let Trent go after Maddison. If he found her with Zack and then told Brandon all hell would break out. She couldn't let Trent find Madison and ruin her matchmaking plans.

"Where is she?" Brandon's worried tone made Ashley fearful that Brandon would send Trent to look for Madison or worse look for her himself. Ashley saw Trent shrug and did the only thing she could think of to keep Trent from walking off. "She better not-"

Ashley raised herself till her breast floated off the water, the cool air making her nipples hard and aching for attention, and interrupted Brandon. "-Relax babe." Ashley interrupted her boyfriend, "She's probably with Heather and Vicky in her room," she said to Brandon while she caught the surprised look on Trent's face when he saw her bare tits floating out of the water.

Trent couldn't believe Ashley just flashed him her tits but there they were, shining wetly under the moonlight. He gulped and wondered when Brandon would go ballistic but it seemed that he hadn't noticed that Ashley's tits were proudly on display for the two of them and wondered what was happening.

"But!... Yeah your probably right." Brandon conceded as he suddenly felt Ashley grab his dick underwater and slowly start to stroke it while she felt Brandon's hand cup her ass underwater.

"So how do you like the cabin?" Ashley asked Trent hoping to keep him away from Madison.

"Place is great," Trent said in awe, his eyes fixed on her bare tits, "And the view here is ... Fantastic." Ashley blushed knowing he was talking about her tits and was pleased with the reaction and attention. She had always had smaller breasts than her sister and mother and had worried about it. But being on the cheer squad and the attention she had gotten on the field, and also right now, went a long way to making her feel proud of the attention they gave her.

Ashley kept up some small chat with Brandon and Trent while she continued to stroke Brandon's dick underwater and the lustful admiration on Trent's face made her legs weak. At one point she almost asked Trent to join them in the water but stopped herself afraid of what Brandon might say. Still, the thought of being in the water between both naked boys turned her on more than anything before. Ashley started to imagine letting their hands roam all over her body, squeezing her ass, rolling her breast, and... 'STOP IT!' she berated herself, 'you've been listening too much to Hannah,' But she couldn't deny how horny and aroused she felt nor the empty feeling in her pussy begging to be filled with a cock, or more than one.

Trent finally managed to excuse himself from the couple and walked away with his hard-on tenting in his shorts. Has he left he was a bit confused about Brandon's reaction, or rather his lack of reaction, to Ashley's exhibition and wondered if Ashley had been trying to invite him to join them. For the moment he had decided to play it safe. He had already fucked Hannah and she had hinted at a repeat. He didn't want to ruin his chances at another go with the blonde beauty by making a move on her sister without a clearer invitation and he still had to find Madison and see if their moment this afternoon meant something.

****

After Trent turned to leave Brandon watched his friend walk away and muttered under his breath "He'd better not try anything or-"

"-What's wrong Bran?" Ashley asked worried about her boyfriend's simmering anger that seemed to flare up once in a while.

"I was just hoping he doesn't try anything with Maddie." Brandon huffed.

"But why not?" Ashley asked in surprise. "He seems like a nice guy."

"Trent's a great guy but..." Brandon tried to explain himself, "Look Ash. I got to protect Maddie. There're a lot of creeps out there, Like A LOT! I mean... they're always talking about her and looking at her."

Ashley found his comments a little weird after what had just happened. "You didn't seem to mind when guys look at me," she said.

"That's different," Brandon said

"What? How?" Ashley asked confused.

"Cause you're my girlfriend," Brandon said as if that was really all there was to say. Watching the confused look on Ashley's he decided to say more. "Guys can look at you all they want but you're MY Girlfriend, and they all know it. They can eat their hearts out cause they know at the end of the day you're with me and not with them. I mean, they can look all they want, like Trent just did," Ashley gasped and blushed in surprise that Brandon had noticed her flaunting her tits at Trent but Brandon just chuckled and winked at Ashley, "Don't worry, I didn't realize we were naked either until you grabbed my cock." Ashley signed in relief that her boyfriend thought she hadn't noticed that she was naked in front of Trent.

"Anyway," Brandon continued, "they can look all they want and they can dream all the fantasies they want because that's all they can ever do. They all know I got the sweatiest, kindest, more beautiful, and sexy girl. I got the best girlfriend in the Whole World and they don't." Ashley's face lit up at the unexpected praise from her boyfriend.

It was true. Brandon felt proud at being the only football player in school to officially date a cheerleader his own age in years. All the other cheerleaders had boyfriends older than themselves (Narrator: Hannah and Peter were the exception but nobody was surprised that those two lifelong friends had eventually hooked up.) The guys on the team all envied Brandon for hooking up with Ashley and even more for popping her cherry. Yes, Tanya got around a bit, Sharon's blowjobs were legendary, and Heather was the goddess everyone jacked off to but Ashley was real girlfriend material, every single one of them would have cut their left balls to be in Brandon's place and he knew it.

"But I got to keep them away from Maddie," Brandon said softly. "Maddie's got to have a nice good boyfriend not any of those sick weirdos, sneaking around, spying on girls, just trying to get into their panties to fuck them and then dump them like an old rag. I mean... Just look at Zack! stalking around poor Vicky."

"Zack's not a creep!" Ashley protested.

"Of course he is!" Brandon scoffed, "Didn't you see how he's been looking at all the girls!? Damm, they're all creeps!"

"BRANON COLE!" Ashley smacked him in the arm. "Zack is not a creep or a weirdo! He's a great guy!"

"Yeah right!" Brandon scoffed. "He ain't getting nowhere near my sister."

"He's not a creep!" Ashley shot back defending her childhood friend as she yelled into her boyfriend's face. "Do you think my parents would let me come here with him if they thought he was a weirdo? Do you think my Dad wouldn't recognize one? My family has known him all my life, you think they wouldn't have noticed him doing any stuff like that? My mom and my sister have been trying to make us hook up all this time. You think they'd do that if he was a creepy weirdo?"

Brandon was taken aback by Ashley's fiery spirit and tried to defend himself "Okay okay!" he said holding up his hands "Sorry! Jeez!" Why is everyone on his side after what he did?"

"Bran," Ashley said sternly "Yeah, Zack had a crush on Vicky. Everyone has a crush on someone, Even I used to have a crush on Peter before he started dating Hannah,"

"You did?" Brandon said a bit surprised

"Yeah but that doesn't matter. Brandon, last night Vicky looked like she was happy dancing with Zack and he thought she liked him and made a move. He's a nice guy not a weirdo." Ashley lectured Brandon. "He's never done anything wrong with me or any other girl. Why do you think he's my friend? And he's Chloe's friend? And none of the girl's soccer team seem to mind when he goes to watch their game."

"But..." Brandon tried to protest. the way Ashley described him it looked like he might be a good guy but he couldn´t forget what Dylan and Shawn had said about Gavin and Zack.

"If you're looking for a creep that's Dylan and his friends." Ashley kept talking, "They're the real weirdos."

"No they're not!" Brandon tried to defend his sometimes friend.

"OH really!" Ashley scolded him "Then what was he doing trying to sneak into the girls' bathroom with a spy camera? Huh? Tell me? Go ahead explain that!"

"I... I..." Brandon stumbled with his words.

Ashley ignored Brandon and continued scolding Brandon, "And that weekend my Dad sent the police to the school. They found hidden cameras everywhere, even in the School Principal's Office!!"

Brandon was stunned hearing the last part. His mind instantly dug up the old memories of Dylan showing him the video of Wessterhof, the old school principal, fucking Diane, Gavin's mom. Still, his mind refused to accept it.

"See! There ARE creeps in school!" Brandon said grasping at straws, "Can't you see Ashley. I got to protect Madison!"

Ashley cupped Brandon's face in her palms. "Babe. It's nice that you want to protect Maddie, really nice of you, I really like that in you, but you got it all wrong."

Ashley signed and turned away. she walked back to the beach and put her clothes on and then went to her room. Brandon followed after her. He didn't understand why she would defend Zack like that or why she thought so poorly of Dylan.

Back at the cabin the couple silently changed into their pajamas and got into bed. Ashley spent the next hour half-heartedly sending out messages while she fumed over her boyfriend's thick-headed refusal to see the light.

Brandon sat in bed next to Ashley doing the same while he repeated his argument with Ashley. He felt terrible at having their first fight, especially over other people. He loved his girlfriend and felt terrible at seeing Ashley upset with him. It was something that churned inside like a knife. He had thought Ashley would take his side but she hadn't. She had taken Zack's side just like his mother had taken Gavin's and Madison's side a few years ago. Brandon knew there were creeps and weirdos in school because his father had told him he had overheard some guys talking about going after the girls in school and how easy it would be to get in their panties.

He loved Ashley and couldn't ever think about breaking up with her over this and so he tried to see things from her point of view going over each point she had made. It was something their coach had taught them, 'Your opponent has a plan. look at the field from his point of view and you will see it' he had said. Some he discarded, like Chloe being his friend, she could easily be his sidekick, and maybe just as perverted as Zack was. Others made some sense, Zack saw a chance and made his move, and struck out. It had happened to him and his friends, he just never got called a pervert.

But her father was the state DA, so he must have met a lot of weird and creepy people. Sarah Woodsen had always greeted him warmly but Damon had always been a bit cold. He was ok with that since he knew he had to 'prove' himself to Ashley's father. Yet Damon had always greeted Zack and Gavin warmly, talking and joking warmly with them while being a bit on the formal side with Brandon. He wouldn't do that if he thought they were perverts would he? 'I guess not' he admitted to himself. There was also Carlos Rivera whom he respected a lot, and he always doted on Gavin and even seemed to like Zack until Zack and Lisa broke up which he had to admit was understandable.

And then there was the spycam Dylan had been caught trying to install in the girl's locker room, and Brandon remembered the video from the Principal's Office. Where had Dylan gotten the video? It finally started to dawn on Brandon that maybe, just maybe Ashley and everyone else were right about Zack and Gavin and the rest. Maybe his mother was right and Dylan had dupped him. Maybe....

"Ashley?" Brandon asked softly and heard Ashley grunt softly. "You... You sure about Dylan?" Brandon asked, "I mean, you're not just saying it cause you don't like him? You Sure? I mean...?"

"Dylan's a creepy guy Bran," Ashley said "None of the girls like him. They all try to get away from him, even for school projects."

"And the spycam? How do you know?" Brandon asked

"I overheard my dad talking to my mom after they caught Dylan," Ashley explained, still annoyed at her boyfriend, "My dad said the police had searched the school that weekend and found a lot of spycams but that he couldn't charge or even investigate Dylan because he was a minor."

Brandon nodded again silently, thinking. "You think I got it all wrong?" Now it was Ashley's turn to nod silently as she looked at the troubled expression on Brandon's face, she realized he was struggling with something important inside him. He took a deep breath and sighed "What about Zack?" Brandon asked.

"Brandon" Ashley said annoyed. "He's a good guy. That's why he's my friend. You got to relax."

"Ok" Brandon nodded thoughtfully "I believe you." he paused for a moment.

"Is that why you're always on Madison's case?" Ashley asked.

"I have got to protect Madison, you know that!" Brandon said.

"I know. I like that about you. But how will she meet a nice boy if you scare them all away?" Ashley asked him softly. "If you scare all the good ones away... Then the only ones she will get to know are creepy guys that go behind your back."

Ashley saw Brandon nod in agreement and decided to take a chance and maybe get him to go along with the idea of Madison hooking up with Zack. "Of the guys here, who do you think might be someone for Madison to go out on a date? I mean just a date not a boyfriend."

"Gavin?" Brandon offered.

"I think you already scared him away." Ashley said, "he's terrified of you."

Brandon shook his head "Sorry about that, it's just that-"

"-Shh!" Ashley interrupted him not wanting to sidetrack him by digging up the past. "Who else?"

"Well then Kurt!" Brandon said with conviction. "He likes football, he's pretty friendly, funny, seems like a cool guy and..." his voice trailed off when he saw Ashley shake her head.

"Kurt's a player" Ashley said dryly. "Heather warned us that he's like that." They sat in silence for a few moments until Ashley tried again "What about Trent or Zack or Peter?" Brandon stiffened and breathed loudly through his nose. "Trent's your best friend right? He would treat her right?"

"I... I guess... I'd kick his ass if he didn't" Brandon said and Ashley smiled

"I think Zack would treat her well," Ashley said and raised her hand to stop his protest. "After last night I think he'll be extra careful before making a move. Don't you think?" Brandon thought about it and begrudgingly nodded in agreement.

"Why don't you give Madison some space and... you know... let her spend some time talking with them? Just talk! You know without you breathing down her neck." Ashley asked tentatively.

"But what if they try to... you know try to get in her pants?" Brandon said nervously. He definitely did not want to know about anything that his sister could be doing but he was definitely sure she shouldn't be handsy with a boy.

"You think they could do anything with everyone else around?" Ashley asked. "I mean there's nowhere to sneak off. And... You can't watch over her every single thing she does. She's going to get a boyfriend someday. You know that? If you let her meet someone you can help her choose the right one. I can help you." Ashley added softly tracing her fingers over his chest.

Brandon's face was contorted with worry. He looked like was eating a shit sandwich and expected to like it. He didn't like it but Ashley was right. Someday Madison would get a boyfriend. But he also didn't want Ashley mad at him.

"But they just talk. No kissing!" Brandon insisted, "And if they try to grope her I promise I'll kill them!"

Ashley looked at Brandon as if he were a child. "You got to let them hold hands at least, maybe a small kiss.." Brandon took a deep breath but Ashley cut him off. "I could talk to her" Ashley offered "and see what happens, let her know to be careful not to go too far. I don't think she would. You know she's not going to spread her legs just like that." Ashley saw an opening to help Madison get closer to Zack without having to worry too much about Brandon breathing down her neck.

Brandon just looked down at his phone not wanting to say anything just barely nodded.

Ashley leaned over and kissed Brandon. "If you give her some space... I promise I'll make it up to you," she said with a sultry voice, "Anything you want."

What's next?

Comments

      Want to support CHYOA?
      Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)