Tie Breaking

Tie Breaking

"We got a four-way tie. What do we do for a tie-breaker?" Logan heard someone say.

Logan watched as Scarlett beckoned the girls closer and they huddled together near the bow of the boat. He wished he could get a closer look to see if their tits pressed against each other or not, but the view of Sharon readjusting her bikini bottom to make the fabric sink into her butt cheeks like it was a thong sent a pulse throbbing through his cock.

"Looks like it's going to get wild," Charlie said as he nudged Logan's shoulder, "which one do you to try out?"

"You think?" Logan asked. He had guessed things would get wild the moment the girls went topless. A part of him hoped that it would and as the games went on he was convinced that it would, it was just a question of how and with whom. At the same time, he felt a little nagging voice telling him this was more like his uncle's adventures than his father's adventures.

"Dude! This is the perfect time to try out a new girl, no strings attached. Which one do you want to try out? Scarlett? Alice? You want to give Deli a tryout?" Charlie added with a wink. Logan looked at him in surprise, he never thought Charlie would say that? He was basically offering him his girl. Logan had been thinking about Sharon and maybe fooling around with Scarlett since she was the only unattached girl. It was a shame Sharon was so adamantly opposed to doing anything with another girl, so that possibility was out.

"I'm up for trying a new girl, you know, make a move on Scarlett or Alice, she could be fun," Charlie added as they watched the girls talk among themselves

****

Alice was super nervous as the girls gathered around each other at the bow boat. She had wanted to talk to Jake about last night but there hadn't been a chance to do so. And then Sharon and Delilah had gone topless, and then Scarlett too when she went to the front of the boat. She had taken her bikini off as well because she didn't want to be the odd girl out, not to mention that she felt she had to do so to keep up with the other girls and keep Jake's attention on her. Now the girls had this idea and she wasn't sure about it. It wasn't something she had expected when she agreed to come on this trip and things were starting to get out of hand, still, she hadn't expected last night either.

The other girls had basically agreed to make the final test an even sexier one, blindfold the guys and make them guess who was sitting on their laps by letting them touch their tits. They set a 1-minute time limit. Since they were all about the same size it would prove a bit of a challenge, 'Or a handful' Alice thought looking down at her breast, comparing it to the other and grateful that they were all more or less the same size.

"So we start with our boyfriends right?" Alice offered hopefully still unsure of where things were going and even more of publicly repeating what had happened last night.

"No." Scarlett said flatly "I'm not going with Duncan." Scarlett was more convinced now than she was last night that the friends-with-benefits relationship she had with him was too much of a one-way street and had run its course. She wanted to have fun with someone and not just be an escape valve for them, which was what she was starting to feel with Duncan.

"Even better. We switch it up, make it random, they won't guess we did that," Sharon said with a shit-eating grin, "Then we go another round till we got a winner... got to see what we got to play with first, right?"

***

Logan sat blindfolded as he waited. He guessed Sharon would be sitting on his lap as he didn't believe Alice or Delilah would sit on someone other than their boyfriends' which just left Sharon or Scarlett. And he surprised himself hoping it might be Scarlett after all the teasing she had done last night.

Being blindfolded seemed to heighten his expectations and arousal as Logan heard the girls giggle and move around a bit until he felt a girl sit on his right leg sideways. He instinctively wrapped one arm around the slim waist and started to caress the smooth legs under his hand. "tsk tsk" he heard from the girl but he couldn't make out the voice as she took one of his fingers and brought his hand up to her breast.

Logan gently cupped and squeeze the handful of tit-flesh in his hands. he tried to guess who it could be. His fingers moved to gently tug at her nipples and roll them between his fingers. He gently tweaked and pinched her nipple hoping to make her say something that would give him a clue while his other hand grabbed and squeezed her round butt. The girl just squirmed on his lap and tried to rub her thigh over his hard-on poking at her but she still remained silent under all the attention he was able to give her. She then grabbed his hand pressing it against her tit as he gave it a firm squeeze. His other hand had dipped in to trace her butt crack before following the fabric of her bikini bottom, Logan felt a stab of disappointment when he couldn't find the brass ring on her hips that would have told him it was Scarlett.

From the sounds of panting and soft gasps, he heard from the girls he guessed the others boys were trying to do the same. Still, he couldn't guess who was sitting on his lap. After a minute the girl stood up and each boy made his guess. Logan guessed it was Sharon. And each boy got it wrong.

**

Narrator: Just for those who are curious. Alice sat on Logan's lap.

Scarlett sat on Charlie with her back to him. Charlie quickly wrapped his hands around her and grabbed her tits with both hands. He immediately started roughly squeezing and tugging her tits which started to turn her on while she rubbed his cock with her ass. While his hand snaked down to her crotch Charlie started to pinch her nipple, almost painfully which brought Scarlett back to the situation at hand. Scarlett ground her teeth in frustration as she stopped his hand and pulled it back to her tits and let him maul them as she liked it.

Sharon sat on Jake's lap just like Scarlett. She let Jake fondle and play with her tits while he left a soft trail of kisses on her back thinking she was Alice. Sharon watched Alice's passive attitude on Logan's lap and decided to play dumb and just sit on Jake's lap and let him believe she was Alice. She guessed Jake was about average in size judging from the bulge pressing up into her ass but she did admire the way his long fingers worked their magic on her tits.

And finally, Delilah sat on Duncan's lap facing him. Duncan started resting his hands on her lap and sliding them up to her tits. Delilah started taking deep breaths and almost shivered in anticipation as Duncan's slow, gentle touch was a stark contrast to Charlie's. Duncan finally cupped and squeezed her tits as he whispered his admiration. He gently tugged and pulled her closer to him as Delilah let out soft whimpers as she closed her eyes and enjoyed the sensation till she suddenly felt Duncan's tongue flicker over her hard nipple and she gasped in surprise just before the time was up.

**

"Gonna have to do better" Scarlett laughed. "Let's see who can guess this time"

Again Logan felt one of the girls sit on his lap, but this time she straddled his legs with her back towards him. He grabbed her hips and the girl rotated her ass over his cock till it lined up between her butt cheeks and she started rocking back and forth over his cock. Logan groaned in frustration as his hand went up to her breast and pulled her back to him.

The girl stretched out across his chest as she reached back and pulled his head to her neck. He knew this had to be Sharon as he kissed her neck and licked her earlobe. She let out a content hum as he played with her breast and dropped his hand to her crotch and started rubbing her pussy through the thin fabric of her bikini bottom.

"Better if it goes under," Sharon whispered as she lifted the fabric so his hand could slip straight to her wet pussy. "MMm that's much better," Sharon moaned as she undid her string bikini to make it easier for his finger to circle her clit.

"Better if you take it off," Sharon said as she stood up dropping her bikini. Reaching between her legs she fished out rock-hard cock and lined it up with her pussy. Sharon slowly lowered herself and let just the tip slip in with a delightful moan. She started to rock and gyrate over Logan with just the head of his cock in her warm wet pussy till Logan couldn't stand it anymore. He grabbed her hips and slammed her down on his lap, his cock spearing into her hot pussy in a single thrust. "AAHH!! You brute!" Sharon said playfully as she rotated her hips over him.

Logan grabbed her by the hips and started bouncing her on his lap as he felt his cock slide in and out of her warm wet pussy. It seemed like the blindfold made every sensation, every stroke more intense than the last. It seemed he could feel every drop of her juices dripping and coating his cock.

"OUCH! STOP! STOP! NOT SO ROUGH!" Logan heard Alice cry out. Her cry pulled Logan out of his lust-fueled daze and ripped off his blindfold and he took in the scene before him.

Charlie had Alice bent over the pilot chair, one hand on her hips and the other on her shoulder as he forcefully rammed his cock into her pussy from behind. Across from them, a naked Delilah got off of Duncan's lap and pulled Charlie off Alice while next to him Logan watched a kneeling Jake's gaze hypnotically at his girlfriend while Scarlett rocked herself back and forth on Jake's dick.

"Knock it off!" Delilah chided Charlie as she slapped his shoulder and pushed him off Alice.

"What!?" Charlie defended himself and looked around befuddled as if he hadn't done anything wrong. "You like it?"

Delilah wrapped her arm around Alice and pulled her to Ducan, "Yeah, but not all girls like to be piledrived." Delilah said while she led Alice back to Duncan and tried to comfort her.

***

Delilah led Alice back to Duncan. He gently drew her into his lap and with Delilah's help, he sank his dick into her pussy as she looked with a mix of lust and apprehension. Delilah knelt next to Alice and peppered her neck and shoulder with a kiss as she fondle one of the brunettes tits while Duncan leaned over and started to gently suck Alice's other nipple before switching to do the same with Delilah and then switched back and forth between the two girl's tits.

Duncan grabbed each girl's ass with his hand as he switched back and forth from kissing and sucking their tits. He was ecstatic about being able to fulfill his dream from last night and wasn't about to ruin it like Charlie just did. He decided to play it safe and let the two girls decide how it was going down.

Alice balanced herself with both hands on Duncan's shoulders as she slowly rode Duncan's dick. Charlie had scared her with his rough handling but the soft gentle caresses from her two lovers quickly won her over. There were so many caresses on her, she moaned as she felt both their hands on her ass and tits while Duncan switch from her tits to Delilah's and back again. Delilah's soft kisses on her neck and shoulder made her shiver with anticipation like last night. The best part came when Delilah bent down and joined Duncan as they both licked and sucked on her tits while she rode Duncan's dick. "Oh this is so good, so good, so good," Alice moaned as she felt her first orgasm roll through her.

Delilah was delighted to finally see what it was like to be with a girl. She marveled at her soft smooth skin as she ran her fingers and lips over the other girl's ass, and tits and tasted her nipples. Duncan had been a lot more gentle than Charlie when he let her ride him and even now as he gently circled her butthole while he let Alice ride him. When Alice came the three of them rearranged themselves on the floor of the boat. Duncan lied down on the floor while Alice closed her eyes and lowered her warm pussy on Duncan's dick as Delilah sat on his face. "Let him do most of the work" Delilah whispered to Alice as she leaned over to kiss the brunette.

Delilah leaned into Alice and brushed her lips against hers. Alice's lips parted to let Delilah's tongue softly explore her mouth. Delilah took Alice's hand and brought them to her own tits and then did the same. Both girls softly moaned and rocked themselves on Duncan as they kissed and kneaded each other's firm breasts.

Beneath them, Duncan enjoyed pleasuring both girls. He thanked the fact that Alice was riding him so slowly that he had managed to stave off his own orgasm. Now he had a closeup of Delilah's soft pink pussy contrasting with her dark chocolate skin as his tongue stabbed into her pussy, spreading her lips and letting her juices drip down to cover his lips and chins. He spread Delilah's ass cheeks and desperately licked her pussy as deep as he could as he drank every drop of her pussy juices. When Delilah moved closer to Alice Duncan took advantage of the new position to brush and probe his tongue over her dark brown crinkled rosebud making Delilah moan into Alice's mouth as she rolled her ass over his face.

Duncan continues to lick Delilah's pussy and butthole until she moaned her own orgasm, flooding Duncan's mouth with her pussy juice triggering Duncan who could no longer hold back and shot his load into Alice's pussy. This in turn finally triggered another orgasm in Alice and the two girls collapsed on top of Duncan.

***

Logan watched Delilah lead Alice back to Duncan and the confused look on Charlie until Sharon beckoned him over. Charlie came over grin on his face and Logan watched how Sharon leaned over and started to suck Charlie's cock as she kept bouncing on Logan's cock.

'Oh fuck' was all Logan could think as he watched Sharon gobble up Charlie's cock in her mouth as she continued to ride his cock without missing a beat. Logan grabbed her hips and started to bounce her back and forth on his cock while Charlie grabbed a fistful of red hair and start to pump his cock into her mouth. Sharon moaned and gagged on his cock while her pussy clenched around his cock.

"Yeah take it!" Charlie hissed as Sharon bounced back and forth between the two boys as they spit roasted her and stuffed her mouth and pussy together. Logan was amazed at how hot the scene all around him had become and how quickly the orgy got started.

The moans seemed to fuel the teens in their lust. Next to the three friends, Scarlett noticed that Jake was frozen still behind her. She looked over her shoulder and saw that his eyes were fixed on the way Duncan and Delilah were fucking his girlfriend. Annoyed by the lack of attention he was giving her she looked over at the others and saw how Charlie and Logan were pounding the redhead in between them, shoving her back and forth as they fucked her body. Jake was so obsessed with watching Alice that he never noticed when Scarlett pulled away from him.

"Turn around, I want to fuck your pussy," Charlie said pulling his cock out of her mouth.

"Hey! Don't hog them all!!" Scarlett said to Sharon as she moved next to the. "Leave some for me!"

Sharon pulled away from Logan and looked at her. "Sure, if you think you can handle him." she said as she stood up and winked at Logan "All yours". Logan watched her kneel in front of Jake and start to suck on his dick while Charlie knelt and started to pound her pussy from behind.

Scarlett sat next to Logan and started stroking his cock in her small hands. "Think you can give me some attention?" she asked coyly.

Logan tore his eyes away from Sharon and looked at her bright eyes. "Sure". he said pulling her into his lap. He let Scarlett aim his cock into her entrance and watched her expression go from playful to surprise as she lowered herself on his cock.

"Mpff!" Scarlett grunted as she closed her eyes and bit her lips. "It sooo big," she moaned as his cock stretched her pussy more than any other before.

"Only halfway there" Logan smirked as he saw the look of pure bliss on her face. Scarlett groaned and dropped her head as she started to slide up and down on the top half of his cock until Logan grabbed her shoulders and shoved her down and buried his cock deep inside her.

"FUUUUUCCCCKKKK!!!" Scarlett screamed as she felt his huge cock fill her pussy in one single, deep thrust. He stayed still, letting her get used to his size while his hands roamed over her back and sides. He finally got to see her pink nipples just inches from his face and Logan dove in to capture it in his mouth.

Logan stayed burring in her pussy while he licked and sucked and mauled both her tits, each new thing making her gasp and moan as she clung to him. Her pussy felt snug like a tight warm glove around his cock, and he felt her spasm around his cock every time he twitched inside her.

Finally, Scarlett started to slide up and down on his cock as she purred blissfully. Logan grabbed her hips and started to bounce her on his fuck pole faster and faster. "God, you're so big! I've never had one so fucking big!" Scarlett groaned,

"You're so fucking tight!" Logan groaned "So tight! I could fuck you all day."

"Fuck me Loggy! C'mon, fuck me!" Scarlett begged him

"You want me to fuck you?" Logan teased her with another hard thrust.

"Yeah," Scarlett said, "Fuck me really good."

"Yeah?"

"Yeah!"

"Yeah?"

"Yeah!"

Logan got up and spun around till he had Scarlett on the edge of the boat with her legs wrapped around his waist. He pulled back and thrust himself balls deep into her pussy.

"FUCK!" Scarlett cried out.

Logan started to pound her pussy with long, deep thrusts that went faster and faster.

"Yeah! That's it! Just like that!" Scarlett urged him on while.

"Your pussy feels so go on my cock" Logan said as he pounded her and watched her tits bounce with each thrust.

"Then fuck it!" Scarlett said.

"FUCK IT! FUCK IT!" Scarlett started to scream over and over like a mantra as he rammed his cock inside her again and again.

"I'm cumming!" Scarlett cried out "Fuck I'm cumming Loggy, I'm fucking cumming!"

"Ung" Logan grunted as he buried himself to the hilt inside her and blasted his load inside her. "Fucking Take it!"

"YES! GIVE IT TO ME! FUUUCCCKKK!!!!!" Scarlett screamed as a second orgasm gripped her body as her legs locked him tight against her as she felt his cock pulse and spurt his hot cum inside her, warming her whole body.

They panted as they held on to each other and look into their eyes. "I think you'll do for the trip." Scarlett teased him.

Logan laughed. "Only if you don't leave me deaf."

"Oh, I hope you make me do that." Scarlett moaned as she reached up and gave Logan their first kiss.