More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 9 by gmbynight gmbynight

Who's gonna go talk to Lucy in the bathroom?

Catherine checks in on her

Catherine knocked on the bathroom door. She had put on the silver ring on her left pinky. It was weird because she could have sworn it wasn't gonna fit but now it stood there, perfectly placed.

"Lucy, are you ok? Can I come in?"

"No, I'll be out in a minute or two, just don't come in!" Were those sniffs? Was she crying? "Are you crying?"

Lucy opened the bathroom door and looked up at her friend. Cate could see that she was upset. "No, I'm not crying. Listen, can we talk a moment in another room? Away from the others?"

They moved to a more private place, then Lucy started talking fast "I'm sorry, it was a lot... It was fine when we were all flirting and playing and a bit of stripping but then it became a little too much for me... I know you are really attracted to us, and Nadia and Eve make porn for a living and Luke has his naughty drawings, but I'm really not that up there with all of you, and this i really the first time we got together in a long time and we never got this close to-"

"Hey, hey! It's ok. I'm the one that is sorry. The situation got out of hand and I was so focused on enjoying myself that I didn't check if everyone was okay with the situation. It's all right, everyone has their enjoyments, I mean you are a lot more comfortable than most of us showing of your cute little body" She caressed her arm and smile back at her. "We can go back and tell the others to keep it down for the night, okay?"

Lucy was starting to calm down, but at the last request she immediately changed posture, returning to the upset closed off situation of moments earlier "No, I don't want to stop you from having your fun. You can tell the others I'm going to bed for the night" The naked girl picked the post-it from her forehead and crumpled it, passing it to Catherine without reading it. "Tomorrow you will tell me who won."

"And let you all sad and alone? No, I don't think so!" Immediately she felt compelled not to let her by herself, and to cheer her up. "Why don't we find out what are your limits and try to make yourself enjoy the situation a bit more? Come on, what really oils your gears? "

Lucy blushed at those words, but looked up at her friend and smiled "Well I really enjoy people looking at me and my body. I always had a bit of an exhibitionist streak, but after tonight I'm really gonna embrace it. I like being naked. The way the air touches my skin, expecially my pussy. I love cuddling and soft and gentle sex. I like having fun and the thrill of dares."

Catherine could work with that. "Okay, okay. So would you be bothered if I started doing this?" She gently put a hand on one of her boobs and slowly started massaging it. She expected a little resistance from the other girl at the start, but instead she just got a soft moan of appreciation. She took it as a sign and continued, using her other arm she embraced the naked girl cupping her butt and squeezing it gently. She continued like this for a bit, then slowly lowered her head, stroke her chin and went in for a gentle kiss. Lucy recoiled her head at that. "I'm sorry, I'm not into girls, really..." This sent really mixed feelings to Catherine "Should I stop?"

"Keep going please" Said Lucy **** and threw herself at the big woman's face, making out with her. Now Cate was really confused by the situation, but not ready to loose the first conquest of her so goddamn fuckable group of friends she kept going, moving slowly the hand from her ass down to her openings. She found her labias and started massaging them slowly from behind, teasing to enter with one of her large fingers. "Don't stop, please". Lucy was already wet, now she was soaking.

Catherine kept working on the outside of Lucy's pussy for some time, moving to a more comfortable position on her knees in front of the blonde so she could suck on her tits. She slowly entered a finger inside her and started working a bit faster. Lucy at that point exploded, cumming all over her hand. "Yes! Yes, keep going! Don't stop"

Well she wasn't absolutely going to stop now. She moved her face right where Lucy's fluids were trickling down her thighs and lapped away, moving up to her steamy entrance to continue her dutiful job. She knew her friend was enjoying herself, but now she was starting to get a little impatient, having had to first spank Nadia and now this, without having time to enjoy herself. "When I'm done again here you will be a gentle little princess and exchange the favor, deal?"

"Not a dea-ah-l!" moaned Lucy as Catherine penetrated her with her tongue "Keep going! Deeper please!"

"Weren't you the softie that wanted gentle sex? We should be both enjoy ourselves, right?"

Lucy's timid expression of ecstasy changed before Catherine's eyes. She immediately went to grab the brunette's hair and pulled her back towards her cherry, trying to **** her tongue deep inside. "I get to say what I want, and now I want you to make me come again! Get to work! Work hard on my fucking pussy!"

That shift in attitude felt strange. Catherine wasn't complaining though.

Meanwhile...

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)