Investigate the girls

As much as you would have liked to catch up more with Jill and Max, the behavior of the two young women in the tub had piqued your interest. They weren’t being directly influenced by you, yet they still got naked. You could only conclude that this was their legitimate reaction to the situation. They looked uneasy in the water, sinking their bodies under the waterline with only their heads poking out.

“So…” you addressed the pair. “Skinny dip often?”

The brunette turned to her redheaded friend and then looked back at you with a nervous grin and chuckled, “Not really…”

“Ah, I bet we’re such interesting company that they couldn’t resist joining us!” Max suggested with a chuckle of his own.

“Oh, be easy on them, Max,” Jill scorned. “There’s nothing wrong with being adventurous with your body.”

“Yeah, I mean, everyone else was already naked…” the redhead added. “What’s wrong with us getting naked too?” She seemed more nervous about her nudity than her friend.

“Well we do all sorts of things together,” you told her. “Like makeout.” You raised an eyebrow at Max and Jill and they could perceive your intent. They looked at each other and started to kiss. You chose your words carefully so the girls wouldn’t be influenced by them and hoped to see if they would naturally respond to the things you were doing with Jill and Max. You watched their reactions intently, but they didn’t seem fazed or appear raring to join in.

You could come up with a couple of explanations. First would be that they saw the office coworkers as an actual couple and this wouldn’t seem out of the ordinary. The other would be that they were under the gym’s influence and accepted all sexual acts you instigated as perfectly normal. You needed to raise the stakes a bit to see which was the case.

You didn’t want to invite them to make out either because then your gym privileges would kick in and they would automatically obey. You wanted to see what you could get the girls to do without invoking your abilities. Having Max and Jill do sex acts wasn’t going to answer your question either. Anything you had people do sexually in the gym would be accepted by everyone who saw it.

As you contemplated the ways you could go about it, there was a commotion at the entrance to the pool. The door slammed open and a group of guys came strutting in like they owned the place. They looked to be college kids with cocky attitudes and musclehead physiques. They used their imposing bodies to intimidate the other gym goers. As they spread out around the pool area, one of the guys gave a threatening look at a swimmer climbing out of the pool . It spooked the guy into falling back in with a splash! The boys laughed at the reaction and slapped high fives. Another member of their group picked up a towel that had been laid out and tossed it into the pool as well.

The two girls in the hot tub looked over and their eyes widened in recognition. They turned back around in unison with the look of dread on their faces.

“Oh shit..” the brunette muttered as they both slunk deeper into the water in an attempt to hide. It was too late though, the lead musclehead of the fivesome spotted the pair.

“Yo! Meryl!” He called out before marching over to your tub area. He was a blonde haired, blue eyed pretty boy with a smug grin on his face. He was topless like the rest of his posse, showing off his cut body. “I see you there…” he said, not fooled by their attempts to hide. “...and mousy Niki too!”

Meryl was apparently the brunette because she sat up and turned her head to look at the leader. “What do you want, Brandon?” she asked in an unamused tone. She discreetly covered up with her arms so that he couldn’t tell she was naked.

“Hey baby, I just want to keep you company! I see you’ve already warmed up without me… because you’re in a hot tub! Haha!” Brandon replied, laughing at his own joke. “I… woah! What’s this?” He walked over and picked up the two discarded swimsuits and held them up with shock and glee. You could see Meryl mouth ‘Fuck’ as she realized what he’d found.

“Do my eyes deceive me?” Brandon laughed, gazing at the women’s clothing. “Hey guys! Check this out!”

The others gathered around Brandon and started to jeer. They whistled and catcalled and teased the girls while they played with the speedos.

“Woooah!” said the Asian guy. “Does this mean Mer and Niki are completely naked in there?!”

“Holy shit, come on out, girls!” the tallest guy among them urged.

“Yeah, don’t be shy… don’t you want your swimmies back?” teased the long, straight haired brunette. He waved one of the suits like a matador would a red cape. You noticed that they paid Jill no mind even though she was sitting wide open before them with her nudity plain to see. This further cemented the notion that Meryl and Niki had stripped of their own volition and it looked like they were suffering the consequences for it.

“Give those back!” Niki protested. This only encouraged the guys. They goaded her and laughed.

“Hey, alright, alright…” the tall guy said, calming his bros down before holding a suit out for Niki to grab. “Niki, you can have this back,” he offered. She reached out to take it, but, at the last second, he pulled it up just out of reach. All the guys cheered as Niki’s reaching exposed her breasts to them, giving each other high fives. Realizing that she’d been tricked, Niki clasped her breasts and sank back into the tub.

“Jerk!” she spat at the tall guy.

“Hey guys, why don’t we make them chase us for it?” said the final guy, grabbing the swimsuit from his buddy and waving it at Niki. He had a weasley face with a long nose and slick black hair.

“Hey, why don’t you guys lay off the girls and act like gentlemen?” Max suggested, looking hot under his collar.

“Ooh… what are you going to do about it, gramps?” asked the tall guy.

“Probably have a heart attack!” laughed the Asian. He clutched his heart and faked a seizure to more laughter from his crew. He already looked ridiculous, wearing the other swimsuit over his shorts.

“Actually, I got a better idea,” said the weasel. “How about we take some pictures?” He pulled out his phone from his back pocket and started to snap photos.

“Yo, Eddie, get one of me!” the Asian insisted, flaunting the swimsuit and posing like a beach bunny.

Max had sat through enough. He stood up and looked ready to get physical with these kids half his age. You knew that would not end well for him and you didn’t like the way they were treating Meryl and Niki either, so you decided to step in.