Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 8 by OnTheMind OnTheMind

What's Ashley's next move?

Make your bully pay. (CW orgasam denial)

Ashley stood and stretched. Her room was positively rank with the smell of sex. Not wanting to marinate too much she walked over to her window and opened it, letting in some fresh air. When she did her eyes were drawn to the backyard across the street where Annabell Chamberly was sunning herself. Ashley hated Annabell, and Annabell hated her. The two always fought like cats in a bag when they had to interact, which was often thanks to their mothers being old friends. Annabell always teased Ashley for being a futa, even twisting her cock so hard one time that Ashley couldn't jerk off for a week. Thankfully Annabell was a year ahead in school so they never had to deal with each other outside of the house. Though, now was a perfect chance for Ashley to get some payback.

"I just finished showering, eating, and have put on my nice sky blue summer dress," Ashley said aloud. Suddenly she was clothed, full, and her hair was slightly damp. Turning to look at Lindy sleeping on her bed she said: "Lindy will wake up in a few hours feeling refreshed. She'll clean up and head home. Nothing about what happened will seem odd and she'll always agree to fuck me if I ask."

With that settled she practically raced out of the house, barely taking the time to throw on her sandals before heading outside. She had to restrain herself from sprinting across the lawn to reach Annabell's fence line. Ashley opened the gate and came inside the backyard. Annabell didn't even look up from her poolside deck chair, likely she was dozing in the early sunshine. Ashley smiled while she raked her eyes over her old bully. She was an interesting contrast to Lindy. Annabell was tall and had a soft curviness to her frame. Her hips were wide and full, her tits were massive D-cups that were straining against her bikini. Ashley knew from experience that her ass was full as well, and the girl's dark black hair looked soft as a feather. Ready to get the show on the road Ashley cleared her throat.

"Huh," Annabell mumbled before turning to face her. "Oh, it's you. What do you want you freak?"

"Well," Ashley chucked. "I was just getting done fucking Lindy Adams like a cheap whore and figured I'd come over and fuck you for a bit."

"You figured that huh? And why exactly would I let you do that to me?"

"Because that was the deal you, me, and your mom all worked out when you confessed to everything you did to me. I get to use your body however I want, whenever I want, and you have to just accept it."

"It's a shitty deal," she complained as she sat up in the deck chair. "So you're here to make good on the deal."

"Uh-huh," Ashley told her as she slid her summer dress down. Her new tits and extra length had enough of an impression that Annabell's eyes widened as she watched. "So ditch the bikini and lie back, because it's time for you to make good. Oh, but before I forget this is a punishment, so you're done cumming, forever. No matter how hot you get you're not going to tumble over that cliff again, so I hope the last time you played with mister Buzzy was fun."

Annabell let out a strangled gasp, whether from the news she'd never climax again or from her vibrator being called mister Buzzy. Ashley didn't care. Twisting the knife was nearly as hot as watching the girl strip down. Even as she got in position she couldn't help but drive the metaphorical blade just a little deeper. "It's a real shame too. I'm the best lay you'll ever have and no matter how close you get it just won't happen for you."

If Annabell had anything to say it was lost in a gasp as Ashley slid her cock into the second girl of the day. Her bully's pussy was a totally different feeling from Lindy's. While they were both tight Annabell was much wetter and didn't cling as much as she was fucked into submission by Ashley. The futa for her part was only half focused on the pussy gripping her cock and split her attention between feeling her bully's massive tits up and watching her face as it went through a range of emotions. The lust and shame in Annabell's eyes were amazing, but they didn't compare to what happened when Ashley picked up the pace. She was pounding into her so hard her tits were bouncing like mad, Annabell's eyes got crossed as she got nearer and nearer to that promised land until suddenly she let out a gasp and a groan. Ashley could practically feel it in her cock as the cunt around her trembled and shook but didn't seem to really clench as Lindy's did over and over again. Ashley couldn't help but chuckle as she leaned down and captured one of her bully's nipples in her mouth. She suckled and even bit her hardened nip like a starving baby. Meanwhile, Annabell continued to whine.

"So...close," Annabell whined, even as her pussy once again let a pitiful little tremor. "I need it."

"Well, you should have thought about that before you called me a freak."

"Unfair..." the bully groaned.

"Well tough, life isn't fair," Ashley could feel her own orgasm approaching like a freight train. She was close too, but she wanted to give that knife one final twist before she blew her whole load. "It's...sucks..._oh God..._because I...ugh...know you have a massive libido...Ohhhh...and you are always so horny."

"Yeah, oh fuck, yeah."

"So the fact you're done cumming is going to drive you crazy."

Instead of answering Annabell simply let out a choked-off sob and shuddered at the thought of always wanting to cum and never being able to do so. Ashley licked her lips and kissed each cheek where the tears of frustration were starting to form. Thrusting deep one last time she came as hard as she had all day. Annabell sucked in a shuddering breath as she felt the warm cum fill her, likely once more feeling the wave crest and break without washing over her.

"Oh, hello neighbor," Annabell's mom and sister were standing in the doorway groceries in hand. The girl's sister, Chloe was just out of college and looked much like her sister, a little thicker in the waist, but hardly what could be considered fat. She also somehow had even bigger tits, not that you'd know given the girl was always covered in thick hoodies and sweatpants. Their mother couldn't have looked less like her children. Where they were tall and curvy, Mrs. Chamberly was short and skinny. She owned a gym in town and was all corded muscle, with tits so small she likely could have worn a training bra. Still, a lifetime of working out gave her an ass to die for, and a six-pack that Ashley once had a dream about cumming on to watch her seed drip down each defined contour. Seeing them stand there, smiling slightly as she pulled out of Annabell as if she was just stopping over to use the pool gave Ashley a new idea. Fucking Annabell had been hot. Fucking with Annabell was even hotter. Time to take that up a notch, and make her play nanny too. But who to choose?

Does Ashley make Annabell an aunt or a big sister?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)