Snoop Through Her Stuff

You collect yourself and decide to look through some of Sam's stuff before she comes back. Obviously the unlabeled boxes or the box labeled "Nothing Special" are the boxes that are something special. The unlabeled boxes only contain stuff related to the boxes they are near: kitchen tools, shower accoutrements, clothes. You turn to the "Nothing Special" box. The very first thing on top is a bottle of lube so you know you've hit the jackpot. Underneath is a photo album and what looks like a baseball bat wrapped in tissue paper.