Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 18

Another chapter, another punishment. What'll it be?

The Snowball Effect

Cindi Summers blew the hair out from in front of her face, and sighed. Decisions, decisions, decisions. In the end, the description's convinced her of nothing, but the cool sounding snowball definitely made an impact. She loved snow. Snowballs too! Sitting in the passenger seat, she squeezed her hand, mimicking a snowball amidst its grip, just imagining it physically touching her.....

"Gum!" Cindi could heard Katy chewing, and her driver giggled and opened up the centre console, giving Cindi access to some.

The choice was made with Cindi's free hand as she began to blissfully chew on the gum - The Snowball Effect.


"Dad, don't be such a creep; Mommmmmmm, stop it, you know I hate when you try to go through my phone." Katy moaned in mock pain.

Cindi's time in the mall hadn't been an adventure or journey like she'd imagined. They'd parked, rushed from the car, and gone to a smaller part of the mall, really just an addition, labeled simply 'Boutique'.

If Cindi had imagined a wild shopping trip, this wasn't it, seeing as Cindi's parents owned the chain they were shopping at, and apparently, were more than happy to stop by to see their daughter.

"Sorry, sorry dear." Katy's dad apologized on behalf of both parents. The two looked happy to talked, and Cindi fidgeted, walking around the store in her heels, feeling the fabric, loving its sensation on her skin, and enjoying just walking around.

"Mom, dad, stop creeping on me, and let Cindi and I shop!" Katy whined.

Both parents smiled and nodded. Katy's mom spoke up. "Okay dear. Make sure you put the charges on your dad's card."

After the initial conversation about the fact that Katy's parents owned a successful retail enterprise, Katy smiled, looking a bit devious.

"You know Cindi, for the two days I've known you, I've noticed you haven't worn a bra. Do you hate bra's?" Katy asked with a joking voice.

"Yeah, I de-..." Cindi began to speak with venom, before Katy cut her off.

"Just kidding, I know you didn't wear a bra because Will was there. But like seriously, you should get some bra's. Let's get you measured." Katy spoke up. Cindi's brain short circuited. Right, that's why she hadn't worn a bra, not because she hated them! She loved her sweater puppies!


"34B." The bores sales associate said with the band around Cindi's chest.

"Damnit, I knew it!" Katy said. She'd been a bit annoyed, this sales associate was super lame, and Cindi looked super squirmy and was silently quiet. Whatever.

Meanwhile, Cindi was enjoying the rubbing of the band against her nipples, with it's tight grip. Another part of her brain was also starting to fire up, seeing as it was the afternoon, and she hadn't been sexually sated at all today.

"Too big. Too small." Katy threw another top over the dressing room divider. What had been Cindi's shopping trip had now shifted to both's shopping trip. She wasn't complaining, however, especially not after Cindi had told her to smile more.

6 bags full. One bag for pants, one bag for shorts, another for tops, another for dresses, and two more with whatever remained. Cindi tried to remember the key moments from their outing at her parents boutique, but her head was pained, especially as the curses affect to keep her as Cindi waned.

"Okay Cindi, you and Will have a special moment tonight, and my parents don't sell lingerie, so let's get you a good set." Katy said nonchalantly.

Cindi's head cleared and she agreed with Katy.

"Definitely. You know me so well. It's like you're reading a book titled 'Cindi's Mind'." Cindi said as she giggled. "I like it."

Katy looked briefly thrown off her feet, and the two stopped walking as Cindi groaned in pain. For a brief moment, excitement had been on Cindi's face, and she felt pretty great that Will's sister liked her so much.

"Do you need help with the bags?" Katy asked.

"Ugh. Um, just a bit." Cindi said, and Katy took three of the bags, realizing they weren't even heavy. Weird.


"Oh my gosh. These are freaking perfect! You would look amazing in these Cindi!" Katy said as she approached the ass-only mannequin.

"They're missing some fabric?" Cindi asked, the truth dawning on her. Oh. Assless panties. Advertised in a little corner of this store.

"You need to try these on now! God, these will look freaking perfect!" Katy said, and once Cindi had figured out how to get the complicated pink set on, she actually was really surprised. They looked amazing. Not fashionable, maybe, but super sexy.

The heavier fabric in the front was being swallowed up by her pussy, and she had to tie the set a bit tighter due to her shrunk waist, but it was completely undeniable. With her juicy ass and B-cup beanbags, Cindi felt like a model. Posing in the mirror, she only stopped when Katy knocked on the door.

"Lemme see!" Katy said with a bit of impatience.

Cindi hesitated. She shouldn't let her see, should she? She slightly peaked out of the door, and Katy yanked her out, loving what was in front of.

"Perfect!!!!" Katy said. "You should take a picture for Will."

They got ready for that, and then Katy waited. "Actually, when you get changed, just take a picture of the set, and send him a pic of the set. That'll get him riled up for tonight."

Cindi changed back into her sweater dress and heels, and the two left the store after snapping a picture of just the purchased lingerie set, shooting it off to Will.

Cindi: Might've bought something ;-)

Will: I'm agree to see my favorite sorority sister in that

As Cindi began to type her reply, her phone began to buzz, and Ethan, the guy she'd seen yesterday, rung her. Oh right, she had given him her phone number, right?

"Alex? Hey bro, just checking in, haven't seen you in a few days." Ethan said with genuine concern.

"Alex? This is Cindi!" Cindi said with annoyance. She needed to find Alex! Why the hell had Alex told Ethan that this was his number!

"_I know this is your number Alex. _Cindi, if that's actually you, could you put Alex on the phone?" Ethan asked impatiently.

Alex blinked. He was here. "Hey Ethan, what's up?"

Ethan sighed in relief. "God damnit bro, you had me worried; was that actually Cindi?"

"Yeah, why?" Cindi had been here a second or two ago, right? Someone with a name like that? Alex thought something like that had just happened.

"Not funny dude, that girl is hot as fuck, I see why you disappeared. Everything else all good?" Ethan asked.

The two chatted as Alex waltzed around the mall, clicking in his heels, swaying his hips. Eventually the phone call ended, and he hung up, feeling a bit bad Ethan had been so worried. Where had he been these past few da-.....

His phone buzzed.

"Gloria? You still coming to work today?" Dan, her manager from bikini n' Barista's asked.

Shit! Alex had a shift at work? Wait, this guy was asking about Gloria, not Alex.

"Uh...uhm..." Alex choked over the phone, unable to answer.

"Gloria, you can't come in, that's fine. Just try to make it in tomorrow." Dan said, and Gloria found Katy again, sitting on her phone in a coffee shop. She felt shitty for having missed work like that! Katy could tell something was amiss, and while she might not relate to having work, she felt bad for the cute sight in front of her.

"Cindi, girlfriend, you're okay. You need to smile. You're boss wasn't angry. Just go in tomorrow!" Katy said, as her words worked, and Cindi began to smile. "Oh right, before we forget, the girls wanted a photo of you with your tiara, sash, and new clothes! For our social media!"

Katy has tagged you in a post for Theta Theta Theta, titled: New Pledge Princess, out of season!!!

Meanwhile, Katy talked Cindi into posting a new photo on her own page, just a simple report of the earlier Pledge Princess photo-op. Her followers now sat at 2300, small compared to Katy's 7k own following.


"You can unpack later Cindi! Now's partying time!" Katy said to Cindi, who's mind was racing. She was really, really, really, desperately horny. Like, after the drive back, some pregaming, and talking with all the girls (sans Vanessa, who had disappeared), Cindi was super horny.

"Al-alright. Sorry." Cindi said with a smile, and throwing herself into the slowly growing party that was being hosted on the first floor of their sorority house.

It wasn't as wild as the drinking she had done a few nights prior, out at the bar with her other girlfriends, but it was quite fun. And she was adoring the attention she was getting.

Cindi, congrats for your great win. Cindi, you're cool for having pledged out of season. Cindi, this, Cindi that. All of it made Cindi feel great, and for some reason, she loved it. After all, she was Cindi! But, for all the praise, she was a bit annoyed! Will hadn't shown up to the party yet, and even Katy was a bit bugged, seeing as she had hyped it up so much.

Stumbling a bit into the bathroom, Cindi played around on her, giggling as she pulled up Gem Ladies. She was a bit too drunk to be playing a game right now, but it was fun, especially as she waited for Will.

Her sloppy drunk fingers nearly clicked through the punishment screen, but she hesitated. Ooo, one of the colors was green for the punishments!

Backdoor Boys - User is now **** to prefer and have anal sex whenever sexual encounters occur, with a feeling of discomfort at vaginal sex.

Rug Munching on The Mind - User will begin to slowly fantasize about oral sex with vaginas, and this desire only resets after doing said act.

Sweet Tooth - Girl has an oral compulsion for all things candy. Must have something sweet (lollipop, hard candy, bubblegum, etc) in her mouth at all times. Lack of sweet leads to mental slowness and insatiable cravings.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)