More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 37 by Anonstorywriter Anonstorywriter

What should I do?

Wait for the last story of the day

I stayed in the living room for a few minutes, hoping their “talk” would be fast. I knew I should go back to my room and just wait. But that was also not what I wanted to do.

I battled with myself alone in the living room for almost 10 minutes before the battle was finally lost. I got up, knowing exactly where I was going. I still held her thong in my hand as I walked to her door. I had no intention of being noticed, but I had to hear for myself.

A few seconds later I found myself standing outside Kayla’s door, hand cupped against the door trying to hear whatever was going on inside. I didn’t hear anything for almost a minute. I was on the verge when it came through loud and clear. She moaned, full out moaned.

Fuck, I almost orgasmed just hearing her. Fuck me. My boyfriend was in there, probably bringing her to orgasm right now. I had to put one hand over my mouth to ensure I didn’t make any noise. She moaned again and I knew I had to leave. Not because I wanted to, I just didn’t want to get caught listening to my Christopher pleasure Kayla.

I snuck back to my room, quickly closing the door and pulling my clothes off. I jumped on the bed and pulled her thong to my nose. I don’t know what made me do it, but it made me feel like I was somehow a part of what they were doing. The even more surprising part is how fast I came! I don’t think I’ve ever had an orgasm in less than 2 minutes of masturbating before, but not anymore.

I was still laying there naked on my bed with her thong in my hand when Christopher opened the door 5 minutes later. He was still fully clothed, but he started taking his clothes off as soon as the door closed.

“Wow, she was right about you. She said you would love if I keep giving you her panties, and clearly you love it. I’m guessing you want to hear what happened?”

“Yes, please tell me, Christopher.”

“Good, cause I’m happy to tell you. Well, as soon as she closed the door, I turned to look at her and she was already starting to pull her shirt up, showing me her naked pussy and stomach. She’s so sexy, Maddison.”

Please log in to view the image

“She was like ‘do you love pulling my panties off and giving them to your girlfriend? You know she loves knowing we keep playing like this. It only makes sense that you love it too.’ And she was so right about how much you love this. I have to admit, getting to see her naked is a great perk for me too.”

It’s like my pussy was eternally wet these days. Hearing him say he loved seeing her naked, hearing her moaning, hearing about how she was talking to him, I needed his dick so bad again.

“So, I couldn’t stop myself from stepping to her and embracing her. My lips fond hers immediately. She’s so good at kissing, and feeling her naked stomach against my body made it even hotter! I moved my hands down towards her naked ass, but she stopped me before I could get there.”

“Wait, why did she stop you?”

“She stepped back, and said ‘slow down, I actually did have some stuff to talk to you about. I talked to Maddison, and she asked me to play along at being your second girlfriend, your cuckcake. She said she wanted us to keep the game going. But, I don’t think I can be considered your second girlfriend yet.’”

“What?! I’m confused. Why?”

“Haha patience! I’m getting there. She said ‘I can’t be your girlfriend until you officially ask me out. So, if you want me to be your girlfriend, then I need you to ask me out. If you want to keep playing with this body, then you need to ask me to be your girlfriend.’ She then pulled her shirt up and hooked it over her head, revealing her entire beautiful body to my greedy eyes.”

Please log in to view the image

Wow, she was really taking this more serious than I initially was. Somehow she knows how to play her role in this perfectly. Or at least I hope she’s just playing a role. Well, I think I hope…I don’t know…

“I knew how much you would want me to do it, and I honestly really wanted to do it too. So I did exactly what she wanted. I asked her out, I asked if she would be my girlfriend. She accepted, quite enthusiastically, I might add. She was all over me after that. She pushed me down on her bed and was straddling my body, still basically completely naked as me continued to make out. She was so fucking sexy, pressing her naked tits against my chest as she started pulling at my clothes, trying to get me naked with her.”

Oh shit, maybe he’s getting to the part where I overheard them. I could feel an orgasm building again. I’ve never orgasmed this many times in a day, yet my pussy didn’t seem to be done yet.

“I broke our kiss to get up and take my clothes off. I was ready to get even in our game, since I was still two steps behind you. But we weren’t done talking yet. She sat up on the bed as I started unbuttoning my shirt, ready to bring something else up.”

What else does she need to talk about?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)