Yes, but things start changing quickly

“Yes.”

“Yes what?”

“Yes, please play along with this. I don’t know why it does this to me. But I don’t want it to stop yet. At least I don’t think so.”

She watched me for a few seconds, as if deciding whether she would follow through or not.

“Ok, I’ll do it. It’s been so much fun so far, so I’ll play along since it’s what you want. I also think I’m pretty good at this role, at being a cuckcake, and for some reason it gets me going to think I’m hot enough to take another girl’s boyfriend, even if it is just pretend. But I have a couple ideas that are non-negotiable. This is the last time you and I will talk about whether the game continues. I think it will be better and easier to play along for both of us if it feels like you don’t have any control over what I’m doing. If you want me to stop, you have to tell Chris to stop. Sound ok?”

“Uh. Yea. I can go with that, if you insist.”

“Oh, I do insist. I think one of the hottest parts about doing it this way is that from now on you will have to decide on your own if you think I’m being serious or just playing along with your game. You’ll watch me cuddle with him and wonder if I’m really trying to be his girlfriend or if I’m just doing it to get both of us hot. You’ll watch me make out with him wondering if I really do want to fuck him or if it is just for the game. And that starts right now.”

Wow, she had put a lot more thought into this than I had realized! But damnit her words were getting to me already. I could feel my panties getting damp, though that might just be Christopher’s cum leaking out of me.

“You’ll have to decide for yourself if you think I’m being serious when I say that I want to be his girlfriend instead of the cuckcake, I want everyone to know me as his girlfriend, I want to be his main girlfriend, and I don’t want to share him. I know I’m going to be his second girlfriend at first, but I don’t want to share him forever. I want him all to myself. I want to be the only girlfriend he has.”

Her eyes were piercing to my soul as she walked straight up to me, pulling my ear to her mouth to whisper her next statement.

“You’ll never know if that is true or if I’m just playing your game.”

She locked eyes with me, which was super intense since our eyes were only an inch apart. Then she walked past me and out of the room.

Fuck. Me. Was she serious?!?! Was she really going to try to steal Christopher from me? Maybe I shouldn’t have asked her to play along. Fuck, my pussy was definitely wet though, and it wasn’t just Christopher’s cum, I was sure of that.

I shocked myself one more time, picking up Kayla’s panties and putting them in my bedside table drawer. I don’t know why I put them there, but I also knew I wanted them handy, just incase I…needed them. I walked out of my room and back into the main area, finding Kayla looking sexy, eyes on Christopher. Damnit, why did she have to be so beautiful?

Christopher and I made a simple pasta dinner for everyone. We were in public so we didn’t get to talk much about everything, but the break was kind of nice. While we were cooking Britney walked out, looking absolutely stunning in a new dress. She told us she had a date and wouldn’t be home until late. We all teased her and wished her luck. Her luck with men hadn’t been very good the last few years, so hopefully this one goes better.

Dinner was straight forward, but Kayla made sure to sit next to Christopher, forcing me to sit across the table from my own boyfriend. Megan sat next to me and kept shooting me knowing looks throughout the meal.

We decided to watch a movie again. Megan was sitting in the big chair, looking super comfortable, and Christopher took a seat on one end of the couch I started walking toward the couch to sit next to him, but Megan stopped me.

“Hey, you know the rule Maddy. Dogs aren’t allowed to sit on the couch. You can sit here on the floor next to me though.” She had this evil looking smirk as she watched me.

“Ha ha, that was last time when we were playing a game.”

“Sure, Sure, but it seems like a fun tradition. Plus, it was fun pretending you were our pet. Plus, we all know you want to sit here with me so Kayla and Christopher can sit together.”

That was the first time it had been said in front of everyone. Everyone already knew, just like she said, but it was still different to say it like that. Christopher smiled at me, knowing I was going to sit on the floor. Kayla didn’t say anything as she walked over with a blanket, sitting down right next to Christopher and draping the blanket over their laps and legs.

We watched the movie (princess diaries 2 for those curious), and I felt myself trying to glance backwards at the couch often. Almost halfway through the movie I looked back and saw Kayla’s eyes closed but a look of arousal on her face. Christopher’s arm was behind her back, but I couldn’t see exactly where.

Megan caught me staring one too many times, so she decided to intervene. She put her hand on my head, turning me to face the tv. She started lightly petting my head as she said “eyes forward, Maddy, stop staring.”

She kept her hand on my head for the rest of the movie, making sure I didn’t look backwards even once. I couldn’t turn around and see what was happening when I heard a feminine gasp from the couch, or when I heard light talking, unable to hear the specific words they were saying.

I barely paid attention for the rest of the movie, glad when it was over so we could go back to my room. Megan pet me one more time before getting up to head to her room. Then Christopher and Kayla got up, the blanket sliding to the ground at their feet. Their clothes were still on, so that was at least good.

Kayla walked towards the kitchen while Christopher walked over to give me a hug. He then whispered in my ear.

“Hey, Kayla said she needed to talk to me. She said you two talked already and you were ok with it. I’ll be in your room soon.”

“Oh, uh. Ok. I’ll wait for you then.”

Now she was taking him to her room to be alone for a minute?! She’s almost spent as much time alone with him today as I have.

“Sounds great. I’ll let you know all about whatever we talk about, or whatever happens. Also, she said you could add these to the ones you already have.”

He winked at me as he stealthily slipped something into my pants. And I don’t mean my pocket, he skipped them down my pants into my panties! I looked over and Kayla was watching us with a smile.

Christopher gave me a kiss and then turned to walk towards Kayla’s room. She turned to follow him down the short hall, but then she paused and looked back at me. She smiled and sexily lifted up her shirt, showing me her naked ass.

She winked at me and followed Christopher. My hand immediately shot down into my panties to grab whatever it was Christopher gave me. It was a black thong. For the second time today she had given him her panties to give to me. And for the second time today, I came with them in my hands. It wasn’t nearly as big as earlier, but my knees still buckled, causing me to almost fall to the ground as I lost control of my legs.

She was going to be alone in her room with him and she wasn’t wearing any panties! Fuck, and he had already said mouths and orgasms were on the table. Fuck, what had I gotten myself into? And why was just the realization that she gave her panties to Christopher to give to me again enough to make me orgasm. This cuckquean kink, which had clearly been buried for most of my life, was really coming out strong all of the sudden.