Of course you take her

Let's see. Leave a pretty girl in an abusive relationship when she wants to fuck your brains out or not? It isn't even close. If your other girls get jealous, well, that's just something you'll have to deal with... or adjust while you're fixing the rest of the universe.

"Come on, Charlotte."

She flies into your arms. "Really."

"You can't take my daughter." With Charles backing out, it looks like dad wants a piece of the action.

"Here's the thing, dad," you say. "I'm not taking anyone. Charlotte is coming with me because she wants to.

"But--"

"I'm not going back to Michigan with you, dad," Charlotte says. "You sold my virginity to Charles and I'm not going to let you sell me again."

Dad blusters for a bit and you hear him out but eventually you and Charlotte make your way back to the cabin.

Time to face the girls.