You get a referral

The next day, you get a call from an unknown number. "Hello, this is Ashley". You think for a while, but don't remember anyone by that name. "I heard you got Caitlin pregnant. I'm a friend of hers and was wondering if you'd... you know... donate some for me as well..."

"Well... I don't know... I...", you stammer.

"You don't need to ask Dana, she said it's fine", Ashley continues. "How about I come over right away? Now would be a perfect time for me to receive your... um, donation"

"Yeah, sure, why not", you hear yourself say, not sure if this is a good idea.

Soon enough, your doorbell rings. It must be Ashley, now.