Game Night (Day 1, Part 9)

Zack texted back quickly.

‘Game night sounds fun.’

‘Great! We’re all in the downstairs living room.’

He glanced at Chloe and apologetically nudged her.

“What is it?” she asked in a hushed voice, blinked up at him.

“I’m going to head out. My mom invited me to some kind of game night or something.” Zack shrugged.

“Do you want me to come, too?” Chloe whispered back.

“Nah, enjoy the movie. I’ll see you later.” Zack smiled, and slid out of the row of seats and left the dark theater, heading downstairs to the living room, where it seemed everybody who wasn’t in there watching a movie had amassed.

Monica and Mallory sat near-ish to each other, with a space between them.

Kurt sat on Monica’s other side, with Vanessa sitting on his other side.

Then down the line it went Diane, Audrey, Charlotte, Damon, Sarah, Gabriella, Daniel, Leah, and Robert.

Zack came down and sat between his mother and his aunt, carefully avoiding Leah’s intense eyes.

“I’m glad you decided to join us, Zack. Do you think we should extend an invite to some of the others?” Robert wondered.

“Nah, too many little kids would ruin the game.” Kurt said, grinning.

“I’m like, two years younger than you.” Zack pointed out.

“So, what are we playing?” Audrey asked.

“Truth or Dare!” Gabriella said eagerly.

“What? No!” Sarah tried to protest, but Charlotte raised her hand.

“Seconded.” Charlotte said just as eagerly.

“That’s two votes.” Robert said apprehensively.

“Three.” Kurt said, lifting a hand.

“Four.” Leah said, raising her own.

“Alright, alright. Truth or Dare it is.” Robert sighed.

Monica shot Zack a look he couldn’t decipher, and Zack looked away from his mother, his eyes unintentionally landing on his aunt.

Mallory gave him a small half-smile, which he returned, if a bit warmer than the initial smile.

“I’ll go first.” Robert sighed, “Damon, truth or dare?”

“Truth.” Damon said, to which Gabriella and Leah started booing. Kurt snickered, and Charlotte looked very amused, leaning back to-.

Zack had to mentally scold himself not to check out Chloe’s mom. That was something he should definitely not be doing.

“Hmm… favorite holiday?” Robert asked. Gabriella spluttered.

“Favorite holiday? What the hell, Robert? There’s no G rated questions for Truth or Dare. Here’s your real question, Damon. Best sex you’ve ever had?” Gabriella cocked an eyebrow.

Now it was Monica’s turn to splutter, lifting one arm as if it might shield Zack from Gabriella’s sinful aura.

“Oh, come on, Gabs. I’m keeping things PG because of Kurt and Zack.” Robert said.

“Well, screw that. They’re adults.” Gabriella said.

“Uh… best sex I ever had was my third time with Sarah. She did this thing-“ Damon began, but Sarah quickly shushed her husband.

“Don’t encourage her.” Sarah said simply.

“Fine. Sarah, truth or dare?” Gabriella questioned her best friend.

“Uh, it is not your turn.” Robert spoke up.

“I suggested the game, I can go whenever I want.” Gabriella smirked, then looked back at Sarah.

“Truth.” Sarah rolled her eyes.

“Your husband excluded, who do you think is the hottest man in this room?” Gabriella wondered.

Sarah cast a gaze around the room, and Zack snorted when he saw Kurt lean forwards and flex his muscles.

Sarah’s gaze settled on Zack.

“Zack, probably.” Sarah shrugged. Monica looked stunned, her face showing everything Zack currently felt inside him.

Sarah Woodsen had just called him the hottest guy in the room (excluding her husband). He was stunned.

“Zack’s eighteen, Sarah!” Monica chastised her friend.

“Eighteen’s legal!” Leah said defensively, and Zack felt his cheeks warm a little bit at the sound of the redhead’s voice. It reminded him of their encounter in the kitchen a few hours earlier.

“Can we just move on?” Sarah grumbled.

“Well, it’s your ask.” Gabriella invited.

“Fine. Monica, truth or dare?” Sarah asked.

“Dare.” Monica said firmly.

Gabriella picked up the bowl sitting on the table and handed it to Monica.

“Did you plan this?” Monica gaped, looking down at the bowl of pre-prepared dares.

“Of course! Just pick one at random and do it.” Gabriella invited.

“Ok. The dare says ‘write a number down on this paper, and have everybody in the room write down a number as well. Share a kiss with whoever’s closest.’” Monica read aloud.

“This is why I hate group parties with these people.” Zack heard Mallory grumble, and he couldn’t resist a chuckle.

Gabriella gave Monica a pen, and Monica quickly wrote down a number, and Gabriella took the paper from Monica.

“Alright. You first Kurt.” Gabriella said.

“27.” Kurt said instantly.

“19.” Vanessa said.

“37.” Diane guessed.

“I dunno. Um, 13?” Audrey shrugged.

“69.” said Charlotte.

“22.” Damon guessed.

“49.” Sarah said randomly.

“2.” Daniel said.

“34.” Leah said.

“90.” Robert said.

“43.” Mallory shrugged.

“61?” Zack guessed. He wasn’t entirely sure what the hopeful feeling in his gut was all about, but he realized abruptly he didn’t want to lose this random number draw.

“Well, Monica wrote 41.” Gabriella revealed, “Which means Mallory was closest. How kinky.”

Monica and Mallory exchanged slightly revolted looks.

“You want me to kiss my sister?” Monica gaped.

“Hey, it was a fair randomizer.” Gabriella stuck up for her bowl of dares.

The two Campbell women (now Bishop and Minotti, though, technically), stood up and awkwardly moved closer.

“Just make it quick.” sighed a resigned Mallory.

Zack could feel his cock stiffening as his mother drew close to her elder sister, and their lips brushed.

“That’s not a kiss!” Gabriella jumped in, and Zack found himself painfully hard as the two sisters started kissing much more forcefully, but Monica quickly drew back, and they hastily sat back down on either side of Zack.

Zack glanced sideways at Mallory to reveal slightly red cheeks, and a glance the other way revealed Monica was a little breathless.

“Alright, Monica, ask someone.” Gabriella invited.

“Ok, uh, Leah, truth or dare?” Monica asked.

“Dare.” Leah said eagerly. Gabriella offered the redhead the bowl of dares, and now Zack had an excuse to look at Leah.

Leah picked out a dare and grinned broadly.

“Sit in the lap of the youngest player.” Leah said, her eyes finding Zack’s, and his pulse skyrocketed.

“No way it says that.” Monica said in disbelief, swinging her head to look at Gabriella, who did look a little sheepish.

“I didn’t know Zack would be playing when I made these dares!” Gabriella defended herself.

Leah rose to her feet and walked forwards with a bit of a sashay. Zack felt his mouth go dry as Leah sat down on his lap, right onto his painfully hard cock.

“Your turn, Leah.” Robert said, sounding completely unfazed by his girlfriend in Zack’s lap. Maybe he understood more than Zack how impersonal this game was, and the way they played, it was all chance as to who ended up doing what.

“Ok, uh, Diane, truth or dare?” Leah questioned.

“Dare?” Diane blinked, looking surprised to be called on.

Diane took a date from the bowl, and her cheeks flamed red. Vanessa leaned over and laughed.

“Take your top off.” Vanessa read aloud.

“Cover his eyes, Leah.” Monica implored the redhead in Zack’s lap, but Leah just laughed and moved so Zack had a better view as Gavin’s mom reached down and grabbed the hem of her shirt, then lifted it up and over her head, letting those large breasts in their plain black cotton bra be revealed.

“This game’s crazy!” Kurt exclaimed, his eyes firmly on Diane’s rack, and Zack couldn’t say he was doing much better. Diane had very large breasts, and they tantalized Zack.

“You like seeing your best friend’s mom’s tits?” Leah purred in Zack’s ear, and Zack’s cock twitched, prompting Leah to let out a breathy sigh that got a strange look from both Monica and Mallory.

Leah set a hand down on Zack’s knee, and scooted back against him a little bit more.

“Charlotte, truth or dare?” Leah asked.

“Dare.” Charlotte smirked, and took a dare from the bowl, “Oh, look at that. My dare is to fondle the bustiest woman present.”

Sarah glared at Gabriella.

“What? You need some more fun in your life!” Gabriella protested.

Charlotte walked forwards and grabbed handfuls of Sarah’s massive tits, and started kneading them.

Leah let out a quiet content sigh as Zack’s raging hard cock strained against his shorts.

“Jealous?” Leah breathed.

Was it even worth denying it? Leah could feel his reaction to the scene playing out in front of him. It was better than any polygraph.

After what was probably longer than necessary, Charlotte drew back from Sarah, and Zack saw the blond woman was flushed darkly. Sarah looped an arm around Charlotte’s neck and pulled her in close to whisper something.

Charlotte kissed Sarah’s cheek, and then returned to her spot.

“My turn next, right?” Kurt asked eagerly.

“Huh? Fine. Kurt, truth or dare?” Sarah asked.

“Dare.” Kurt said, almost before Sarah had finished. He grabbed a dare out of the bowl, filled with visible anticipation, only to just as visibly deflate.

“Go make the group a snack in the kitchen.” Kurt said grumpily, and stood up to head into the kitchen.

“Yeah, they’re not all fun dares. Some are just food and drink orders.” Gabriella confessed.

Vanessa laughed at that one, as did Leah, which put a little bit too much bounce on Zack’s cock.

He sucked in a breath, fighting hard to not cum. That would be horrible, but Zack had very limited sexual experience, and to have a hot woman sitting in his lap and having witnessed two acts of fiery lesbian arousal and seeing his best friend’s busty mother in just a bra and pajama shorts, Zack was about ready to burst.

But to his surprise, it was Leah who saved him from cumming in his pants. She gripped his knee tightly. The pressure of it took Zack’s mind off of the sexy things that had been going on, and he looked down at his knee, then up to meet Leah’s eyes.

The older girl gave him a knowing smile dripping suggestion, but she didn’t speak, as Kurt came back then, carrying a tray of messily poured pretzels.

Damon and Daniel descended down on the plate of pretzels hungrily, much to Audrey’s amusement, it seemed.

“Alright. Zack, truth or dare?” Kurt asked.

“Dare.” Zack said, hoping he didn’t get one of the food or drink order dares.

Zack picked up a dare from the bowl, and Leah read eagerly as Zack read the dare. Once, then twice, then three times.

“Spend ten minutes in a small closet with the person of your choosing. The caveat? Both of you will be naked.” Leah read out loud.

Gabriella laughed.

“That’s the dare Zack got?” she laughed.

“Well, who do you choose?” Charlotte asked, eyes twinkling with interest.

Zack glanced around the room. He noticed how surly Kurt looked, and had to grin because of that.

But now he had a difficult choice to make, and this choice couldn’t be explained away as chance. This would be a conscious choice fully recognized as such.