Curiosity killed the Max

As dangerous as you knew it was, the temptation became too great for you to resist. It would be almost impossible to explain the situation if she woke up and all the earlier goodwill you had accumulated over the past day would vanish in an instant but… you still found yourself getting closer to her as if her bare stomach was enticing you in.

You reached the side of her bed and slowly sat down on the edge to give yourself easier access to look at her. Plus it would be a lot creepier if she did catch you and you were just menacingly stood over her so sitting down was probably for the best. The movement of the bed didn’t seem to wake her and she showed no signs of stirring as you contemplated your next move.

The tank top she was wearing had pretty loose straps so you could potentially pull it down past her cleavage but you just decided to do what you originally planned and go from the bottom. The bottom of her top was already scrunched up, so you carefully held the hem between your fingers, grabbing both sides of the top and rolling it up as gently as possible, trying to keep it even as you revealed more of her skin until you could her underboob peeking out through the gap you left.

Now at the final stage, you hooked your thumbs just below her cleavage and attempted to pull the top up and over her tits. The tank top she was wearing was loose enough to get you most of the way and with a little bit of stretching, you managed to just about free her tits from the top before the back of your thumbs brushed against her nipples. The unexpected contact made you freeze and tense up as you waited to see if she reacted. You had been listening to the steady rhythm of her breathing and although she started to breathe heavier for a short while, she eventually settled down back to normal.

You now pulled your hands away slowly in relief and stared at the breasts you had released from the confines of her top. As always you couldn’t help but compared them to Mom’s and unlike Sarah, Lucy was similar if not identical to Mom’s size. Obviously age made it seem like Lucy was a bit perkier than Mom, if only slightly, and now that the colder air in the room was starting to affect her, her nipples started to harden right in front of you.

With your vision solely focused on her tits, you couldn’t help but wonder how they would feel in your hands. You doubted that you would be able to cup them without Lucy noticing but a light caress wouldn’t be too bad right? You’d already gone this far so there wasn’t much stopping you from just taking it a little bit further.

You took a nervous gulp and started to reach out towards your prize, getting almost inches away when you heard someone quietly clear their throat right next to you. With a bit of panic, you quickly turned your head to the side to see Sarah, eyes wide open from where you thought she was asleep, sporting a huge grin on her face at the fact that she had caught you red-handed.

“I’d probably stop if I were you” she whispered, tilting her head towards Lucy’s chest before continuing.

“I’m surprised you even made it this far without somehow waking her up”

“How long have you been watching?” you asked, withdrawing your hands with a guilty look, almost as if you had been caught stealing from a cookie jar.

“Since about the time you stood up from the bed” she replied with the grin still plastered on her face.

“So everything then” you sighed dejectedly, realising you had never had a chance at getting away with your plan.

Sarah carefully got up from where she had been lying and got up to stand next to you before whispering in your ear.

“I didn’t say you had to stop but if you really want to get your hands on some tits that badly then I’m always available” she teased, turning away from you and out the door before you could even think of a response. You stared back down to look at Lucy before switching back and forth between her and the door. As much as you wanted to chase after your sister, given the proposal she had just presented, you needed to extract yourself from the position you had now put yourself in.

Leaving Lucy with her top still rolled up was probably a bad idea but again, you decided to take the chance to risk it and follow after Sarah. You slowly got up from where you were sat and crept backwards towards the door before rushing into the dark hallway to look for Sarah. You couldn’t hear any noise from downstairs and with the only light coming from Sarah’s door, it felt safe for you to assume that you and Sarah were the only two people still awake. It seemed like she knew which option you were going to pick as you could see her waiting in front of her bedroom door for you to catch up.

She led you into her room and locked the door firmly behind her before she started stripping down. She knew you were watching her every move and turned to give you the best angle whenever she took off a piece of her outfit. The first was her pajama top that she slowly pulled up, showing off her chest and her hardened nipples that easily gave away that she was enjoying this as much as you. Next, she turned away from you, slowly pulling down her leggings and revealing that she had forgone wearing panties just like she had with her bra.

She stretched out her back as she lowered them, emphasizing her ass as she did so before looking back to see your reaction. You were hard as a rock as she finished undressing and she was clearly pleased to have put you in that state. With your head blank, all you could do was stare at the beautiful display she was putting on and when you went to tell her as much, her expression lit up as if a lightbulb went off in her head.

“Ooh I have an idea!” she announced before rushing to her dresser and started routing through her clothes, while completely nude. You couldn’t help but be curious at what she was doing, so you got close behind her and reached around to freely play with her tits while she carried on searching, making sure she was aware of your erection that was also pressed up against her ass.

“Why are you trying to put more clothes on when you're plenty dressed already?” you asked, getting no complaints from her as you continued to caress her body.

“Trust me you’ll love this” she replied, not willing to reveal what she was doing quite yet.

After pulling out various different tops, she finally found the one she was looking for and you were **** to remove your hands while she put it on. At first, you didn’t realise what was so special about the top and it took you a little while for the connection to be made in your head.

“That's the same one Lucy’s wearing at the moment right?” you asked, double-checking you were right considering your limited knowledge of fashion.

“Yeah! I’m surprised you figured that out so quickly” she teased, happily swaying side to side as she showed off the top she was wearing.

“Me and Lucy got matching ones before she left and I forgot I even still had it until I saw her wearing hers. We were surprised they actually stocked something for the both of us when sizes are … different but anyway, what do you think?” She questioned, giving you a spin as she modelled in front of you.

“It's great. I preferred you out of it but I like the top” you replied, giving your honest opinion.

“No that wasn’t what I meant” she said before staring at you, expecting you to say something that you had no clue what she was referring to. Your look of confusion must have tipped her off as she carried on speaking.

“You have no idea what I’m talking about do you? Geez and I thought you were the smart one in the family “ she jokingly said, giving you no further hints at what she was trying to do.