Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 16 by El-E El-E

What's next?

Preacher's Daughter

The lights above the door still pulse ON AIR in blood-orange neon. The hallway smells faintly of nail polish remover and cum. You stand there a moment longer, sorting through the etched brass tokens until you settle on your next combination:

Redhead.

Gamer.

Churchgirl.

The tokens click into place with a mechanical hiss, and the door slides open. You are pulled forward—not by any hand, but like you’ve stepped into a cutscene you forgot you were in. The air behind the threshold is warm and dusty, thick with the smell of old carpeting, spilled soda, and worn-out Bibles.

Your vision blurs.

You are seated now—no, kneeling. The room is lit with the soft glow of RGB LED strips running behind a white wooden cross. A shelf behind you is crammed with Xbox and PlayStation game cases, but each one has been annotated in glittery pen. Verses of Corinthians, Psalms, and Song of Songs wind their way around game titles.

In your mind the story is clear now: you’re twenty-two and a virgin because your father made sure of it. Pastor at Hope and Truth Evangelical, he’d kept you home-schooled, purity-ringed, and internet-banned for most of your life. You weren’t even allowed to speak during communion unless a man prompted you. You'd never even touched yourself before. You didn't know how. Your father made sure of that—home-schooled, monitored, modest skirts to the ankle, no secular media, no friends without a chaperone. You’d never seen porn, never kissed anyone, never even heard a real swear until the library computer glitch loaded a YouTube clip with comments. Your purity ring still bites your finger where he **** it on you at thirteen.

Then one night, he caught you watching a silent let’s-play—just a boy, pretty, lips parted in concentration as he mashed buttons. Your breath caught watching him. Your thighs pressed together. You weren’t even touching yourself. But when your father saw it, he called you Jezebel and whore and devil-sent. He dragged you to the lawn in your nightgown and locked the door behind you. No phone. No car. Just your GameCube and the Bible he'd thrown out after you.

You slept three nights in the youth group closet, curled under a baptismal robe, still clutching the Bible he threw after you. On the fourth day, **** and trembling, you logged into a church Discord server using the public library’s connection, looking for help. It was an ad pinned in the announcements of a digital youth ministry forum—"Earn While You Serve: Online Testimony Opportunities for Faithful Women." You thought it was remote Bible study tutoring. You filled out the application with trembling hands, quoting scripture in the essay box. Within the hour, a woman called Sister Corinne replied with a link, instructions, and the phrase: "Speak His word and be not ashamed."

The site looked like a livestream page with a devotional overlay. You thought you'd be reading Psalms. You thought you were joining a virtual choir. Your first stream, they told you to smile and read from Song of Songs. When you obeyed, viewers tipped. You didn’t understand what for. You just knew it was the first time obedience paid anything. So you logged in again. And again.

Then, a week in, Sister Corinne messaged you privately: "If you’re ready to be brave, there’s another page we run. For more open witness. Just say yes, and we’ll move you over."

You said yes.

The new site looked the same—chat, tokens, cam—but the title bar said 'intimate testimony' and the tipping goals were... different. You weren’t even sure what counted as sin anymore.

But one night, after a particularly generous stream, you looked down at the payout notification and realized: this was your money. No one else’s. Not your father’s. Not Corinne’s. Not the church’s.

And then it hit you: if no one could tell you what to do—what did you want to do?

You didn’t know.

So you signed up for the 'unrestricted' show and got back on camera. You sat there cross-legged in the glow of the cross LEDs, breath shaky, thighs trembling—not from excitement, but from not knowing what came next. You weren’t being told anymore. You weren’t obeying anyone now.

You stared at the chat window, hands folded nervously, and typed:

"Hi. Um. What should I do?"

It wasn’t some act. It wasn’t performance. You truly didn’t know. All your life you'd been told exactly how to be good. Now you had a login, a payout account, and an audience. You were still a virgin. Still a churchgirl. But now you were earning for it.

NaughtyNun69: "Start by breathing slow, sugar. Say 'I wanna be good for you.' And touch your thighs."

You read it twice before obeying. "I... I wanna be good for you," you whispered.

NaughtyNun69: "Now lift your skirt. Just a little. Show them how innocent you still are."

You’d never even looked at yourself down there, never with the lights on. You hesitated—then slowly lifted the hem. Just enough.

NaughtyNun69: "Press your fingers. Over the tights. Don’t go under yet. Just let it tingle."

So you did. Pressed, soft and clumsy, and your whole body jolted. The first moan came on accident. Not pain. Not sin. Just heat. Just release.

"Is this okay?" you whispered, blinking at the chat.

NaughtyNun69: "Good girls ask. Holy girls obey."

The tips started rolling in.

Sister Corinne said sinners needed you—your sweetness, your scripture, your shame. And they’d pay to watch you fall. But no one told you what to do now. So you asked. And now you know.

That was weeks ago, and now it is just what you do to make money each day. And easy because you can play video games while reciting bible verses and the cash flows in. Sometimes people type rude comments but usually NaughtyNun69 is there as your mod.

Your wrists are tied in front of you with a lilac GameCube controller cord, and your red hair is in tight bouncy curls, pinned with matching bows. You wear a pastel crop-top that says "PWNED BY CHRIST" in glitter puff print. Beneath that: a peach corduroy miniskirt, white tights, and soft Mary Janes. Your lips taste like cherry Lip Smackers. Your ass aches like you’ve already knelt too long.

The webcam light is already on.

[STREAMING LIVE: CHERRY.CHOIRGIRL | Viewers: 213 | Tokens: 0014 / 10000]

You lean forward, lips parted, and a jingle plays automatically:

"Blessed are the meek, for they shall nut most hard."

holyteabag34: OMFG she live

360noscopepsalm: say the prayer baby say the prayer

crossthighs213 tipped 69: “Call me brother and say you were bad”

You fold your hands over the controller cable.

"Forgive me, brother," you whisper, eyes wide and glassy. "I was bad. I put the headset on and started moaning into voice chat again. I know I wasn’t supposed to. But the boys in my lobby called me a slut and I got so wet. I wanted them to teabag me for Jesus."

You glance up at the lens. The reflection in your glasses shows a pair of Joy-Cons wedged into your tights.

piety_playerone: she blushin like she knows dad in the chat

jackedforjesus tipped 666: "use the cross"

You reach offscreen and come back with a smooth, polished wooden cross no longer than a ruler. You kiss the top.

"Bless me, Father, for I am about to sin again."

You lower the cross out of frame, and mimic rocking back and forth on it. It's nowhere near you, but that would destroy the illusion, and you can go longer if you're only pretending, as NaughtyNun69 told you when you started. Suddenly, you receive a message.

[Private Chat Request Incoming: DaddyDeacon420. Accept?]

As per usual you ask NaughtyNun69 her advice.

NaughtyNun69: "You look like you don’t even know what’s happening between your thighs, Cherry. Read John 4:14 for me while you feel it."

Your lips stumble through the verse. "But whoever drinks the water I give them will never thirst again..."

The Joy-Con pulses when you press it. Your gasp slips out before you can swallow it back. The scripture tangles with your breath.

NaughtyNun69: "Now Psalm 38:7. Whisper it like you know what it's doing to your spine."

You bend forward slowly, your breath hitching. "For my loins are filled with a loathsome disease..."

NaughtyNun69: "Good. Good girls read from the body. Not just the book. Now—accept the Deacon."

You click accept.

The private chat window expands slowly, like a confessional curtain drawing back. No video. Just the void-black of silence and anticipation. Then:

DaddyDeacon420: "Cherry. Cherry. Are you soaked in His word tonight? Or just soaked?"

"You want to see me stroke this cross and cry scripture? Then pay up."

DaddyDeacon420: "How much, Cherry?"

You lick your lip and smile.

"Start with 200. Just for the breath I take after the moan. Then 500 if you want me to whisper what’s wet. A thousand if you want to see my knees hit the floor like I'm begging to tithe."

DaddyDeacon420: "Is that how a good girl treats her spiritual leader?"

"No," you purr. "That’s how a good girl makes her spiritual leader go broke. You’re not my shepherd. You’re my wallet with a hard-on."

The first tip lands.

Then the next.

Then a string of alerts so fast it glitches your stream overlay.

You tilt your head and mock a pout. "You paying for every sin you ever thought about, Deacon? Or just the ones I make feel holy?"

DaddyDeacon420: "What would you do if I was in your pew right now, Cherry? Watching your thighs spread under that skirt?"

You rub your fingers together and let the wet sound be your answer.

"I’d pass the collection plate between my legs and make you empty everything just to hear me say Amen."

DaddyDeacon420: "You’re filthy."

"I’m profitable," you hiss. "Now tell me—how filthy can you pay me to be? Every stroke of your key better be lined with guilt and gold. You want to see me whisper sin like it’s scripture? Then tip."

He hesitates.

"No? Then I’ll guess. Ten tokens for every time you imagined me bent over the pews. Fifty for the first time you moaned my name into a pillow. A hundred if you ever came during your own sermon. Now go ahead, Deacon—confess."

The tips start again, slower now, like blood from a bitten lip.

"What thought did that buy?" you ask sweetly.

DaddyDeacon420: "I imagined you licking the chalice clean."

"Not enough. You want me on my knees for that? Double it."

He sends another tip.

"And that one?"

DaddyDeacon420: "Your tights ripped. My hand inside while you prayed."

You moan softly. "Now we're tithing proper. Keep going, wallet. Keep going until the shame’s louder than your holiness."

The screen flickers with another rush of tips. You grin wide.

"You want me to say I’m yours? That I’d let you baptize me in your load? That I’d ride your face until I saw angels? Then prove you can afford my salvation."

DaddyDeacon420: "You’ve drained me."

"Good. Now kneel."

He’s already maxed out his tip limit in private. You see the red flag next to his name: SPENDING PAUSED. You grin. You’ve wrung every cent from his holiness fantasy. And still, he lingers. You’re glistening. Slick. Buzzing. And then, slowly flashing across your screen are the words that NaughtyNun69 told you would ensnare any mark ever.

DaddyDeacon420: "And you'd fuck me no matter who I am?"

You tilt your head, letting the silence stretch until he’s squirming. Then, with a slow smile:

"That question costs two grand."

You watch the cursor blink. Waiting. Smirking. Already knowing the answer.

What's next?

Comments

      More fun
      Want to support CHYOA?
      Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)