More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 46 by fantaghiro

What's next?

One month later

You'd learned to compartmentalize. In Government class, Laura was Miss Card—professional, untouchable, occasionally making eye contact that lasted a millisecond too long. In her apartment, she was Laura, who would kiss you while still wearing cologne from another man's neck.

The art teacher (Marcus) became a recurring presence. You'd see them together at school—the way they'd pass each other in the hallway and exchange a look that said they'd been together recently. Sometimes Laura would mention him casually: "Marcus thinks we should coordinate our units" or "I'm getting dinner with Marcus and some other teachers."

Never "a date." Always casual. Always leaving room for plausible deniability.

What destroyed you most was how normal she was about it. How unbothered.

"You're being weird," she said one night in November, after you'd been inside her for exactly four minutes before she pushed you off her, citing a headache.

"I'm not being weird," you lied, sitting on the edge of her bed while she adjusted her bra. "I'm fine."

"You're not fine," she said. She was already reaching for her phone, scrolling through something. "You're jealous, and you're making this harder than it needs to be."

"I'm not jealous," you said, which was absolutely a lie. "I just don't understand why you need to see other people."

She sighed, actually sighed, like you were a student asking a question she'd already answered in class.

"Because I'm a woman, Tim, and I have needs," she said. "Sexual needs, yes, but also emotional needs. Companionship. Someone I can go to dinner with and not worry about being seen. Someone my own age who understands my life."

"I understand your life."

"You understand the life of my best friend," she corrected. "You don't understand the life of a 29-year-old woman with a career and friends and a social life. And that's okay. That's not a failing on your part. It's just a reality."

"So what am I?" you asked. "Just for sex?"

She looked at you then, and there was real compassion in her eyes. Genuine affection.

"You're my best friend," she said. "And yes, sometimes we have sex. But Tim, you can't be my whole world. That's not fair to either of us."

"It's not about being your whole world. I just—" You didn't finish. What could you say? That you wanted to be her primary partner? That you wanted her to choose you? That you wanted her to wait for you to grow up?

All of it sounded pathetic when you thought it.

"I know," she said softly, and came to sit next to you. She was still half-naked, and that broke your heart too—that you couldn't even enjoy looking at her body because you were too busy being miserable. "And I love you for it. I do. But loving someone doesn't mean you can give them everything they want."

________________________________________

Your mom invited Laura over for dinner in December.

You watched from the kitchen as they hugged in the doorway, as your mom settled Laura on the couch with wine while she finished cooking. They talked like actual friends. Laura asked about your mom's work as a counselor, listened intently, asked follow-up questions. Your mom glowed. She actually glowed.

"She's doing so well," your mom said to you in the kitchen, while Laura was in the living room. "I'm so proud of how she's adapted. Most people would fall apart after what she's been through, but Laura? She's thriving. She's got this whole life now—her career, her social life, friends at school. She told me she's been dating a little, just casually, nothing serious, but I think that's healthy. She's finding herself."

You wanted to throw up.

"Yeah," you said. "She's really something."

"You know, I was worried about you two spending so much time together after the accident," your mom continued. "I thought it might be unhealthy for you to be so focused on helping her adjust. But honestly? It seems to have been good for both of you. She feels like family to me now. And you're being such a good friend to her."

If she only knew.

________________________________________

Marcus asked Laura out properly in January. An actual date—dinner and a movie, the kind of public display of affection that Tim couldn't offer.

You found out because she told you about it, in her apartment, while getting dressed to go meet him.

"He wants to do this properly," she said, fastening her earrings. "Like, actual dating. Not just hookups."

You watched her put on makeup—red lipstick, the kind she never wore to school. She looked devastating.

"Are you going to?" you asked, knowing the answer.

"Yeah," she said. "I think I am. He's kind, Tim. He's smart. He's..." She paused. "He's someone I could actually have a future with."

The words landed like a physical blow.

"What about us?" you asked.

She turned to look at you in the mirror. "What about us?"

"Are you... are we done?"

She was quiet for a moment. "I don't know," she said honestly. "I don't think I'm the kind of person who can do monogamy, even the secret kind. But I don't want to lose you either. Can't you just... let this be what it is? A beautiful thing between us that doesn't have to be defined by relationship parameters?"

"That's not—" you started, but you didn't finish. Because she was already walking toward the door, and you realized you'd say anything to keep her coming back. You'd accept any terms, any arrangement, any crumb of her attention.

"I'll text you," she said, kissing your forehead like you were a child. "Don't wait up."

You sat in her apartment after she left, surrounded by evidence of the life she was building without you. Photos on her walls. Books on her shelves. The lingering scent of her perfume mixing with Marcus's cologne.

And you realized: this is what it feels like to love someone who's moved on. To be left behind. To be the past while she's the future.

The worst part? You texted her three hours later.

You: how's the date

Laura: really good actually. he's so easy to talk to

You: cool. glad you're having fun

Laura: thanks babe. I'll come by tomorrow maybe? miss you

And you knew that "tomorrow maybe" meant she'd probably flake, or show up late, or leave early to do something with Marcus. But you also knew you'd be sitting in your room waiting anyway, hoping she'd text, refreshing her messages like an addict.

Because that's what you'd become. An addict.

And she was your ****.

What's next?

Comments

      Want to support CHYOA?
      Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)