One Broken Toy Becomes Two

Liz POV:

My Plan for cute little Kris was coming along quite well, I'd been keeping the poor girl on edge for awhile now.

She was getting needier and needier.

Either she would be so lost in lust and need that she would finally realize she needed Seb more than she wants Alice, in which case I could start on fixing their friendship with less issues for everyone.

Or she would keep being stubborn while wanting what Seb can give her, in which case I'm pretty sure I can maneuver something to workout between all three of them. Worst case FWB.

I had another training session coming up with the slut soon and I planned to break her and force her to confront the issue with Seb falling for her.

I'd let her marinate for long enough, the trips out to enjoy her hobby should have given her enough time to cool down that the whiplash from rubber banding back to being toyed with should be enough to get her right were I want her.

I could see it now, slutty look on the little cuties face as she begs and begs me to let her cum, offering anything and everything.

Convincing her over the weekend that the only person who would let her cum like she had been, the only one that would show a pet that kind of mercy, would be Seb.

That being with Alice would just have her in this needy desperate state at all times because of how much it turns us on. That even if Alice lent her out there would be few if any moments of pleasure allowed to the pet, just enough to give her hope in her desperate state so she stays eager to please.

'I should should know cutie, I taught Alice most of what she knows after all.'

Not the truth but close enough to the truth. Alice wouldn't be that bad, but she would play with a sub like that sometimes, leave them like that as long as possible then take a break from that for awhile, playing other ways in the mean time.

Perfect way to bend the truth to make the situation with Seb come to a head and lay the ground work for FWB.

It was as I was finishing these plans and heading to bed, that the whole thing started to fall apart.

Sadly I wouldn't know that until it was too late to stop the damage.

[Liz can I crash at your place, can't be here right now.]

[Fuck, what happened now? Is it our little project?]

[Dont't wanna talk about it, can I crash?]

[If I get answers come morning, sure. Was going to bed soon, I could use a teddy bear to cuddle.]

[I'll take the couch, not in the mood. ETA 15 min.]

[Fuck, that bad eh? Spare key is in the normal place current combo is same as last time. See you in the morn.]

[k]

'What the fuck happened to piss him off that much? I'll deal with in the morning, he'd have told me if it was time sensitive.'

----------

'I was wrong about that. This fucking guy.' The morning starts with a facepalm as he explains what Kris did and how he reacted.

"So let me get this straight, the girl I've been training with you, and we've lent out for other people to fuck, brings home a hot other submissive for you both to enjoy and you lose you're cool and storm out? Dude, that's... I don't know what to call that because its the most stupid thing I've heard. If you hated the idea of this new girl so much I know Kris would have understood, been sad but understood. There has to be more, there better be more..." I trail of knowing he understood the implied 'or else'.

I don't have enough coffee to deal with this yet, while waiting for him to collect his thoughts I head to refill mine and his cup. I know what ever he says it'll mean a long day for us.

"She didn't just bring home a submissive girl, she broke a girl and brought her home. Because she couldn't just admit she broke you're rules."

"What do you mean by broke? Where did she find this girl, it wasn't one from our club is it?" I need to get to the core of the issue and it seems Seb was more focused on how it made him feel when I let him rant over our first cup of coffee. 'It feels like one of my old psych courses. Interviewing a witness or test subject to find useful answers from laymen.'

"SHE DID TO THIS POOR GIRL WHAT WE'VE BEEN WORKING SO HARD TO AVOID DOING TO KRIS ON ACCIDENT." His shout startles me, Seb's temper is starting to boil again before he gets it under control and is almost talking in a whisper. "She used this girl's trauma to get what she wanted, to get her to fill her role better. Hell I had to order Sarah to think of herself like a person to get her tell me her name, she was only calling herself it and toy. I've never seen someone so thoroughly broken and Kris had the nerve to call it training. And somehow think it would work as a loophole because 'I'm not a person, therefore what Kris did with me that first night wasn't cheating or breaking the rules.' Who the fuck thinks that?!"

"Kris, Kris would think like that. Fucking hell. So it wasn't just another girl, that could have been sorted out, we don't exactly have normal relationships, and we should be used to newbies fucking up. That's what the boring part of training the newbies is about, remember how I had to make sure you remembered some of the safety rules?" I'm not focusing on the worst part yet, I need to hit this from a better angle or all my hard work is for nothing...

Seb blushes and smiles a bit at the memory, its taking his mind of the dark place it was headed. "Yeah, didn't know you could be so 'persuasive'."

"Exactly, So she fucked up and in trying to fix it, fucked up even more. Not the first time a sub has accidentally hurt a willing partner when they try to Dom for the first time either. You forget who you're talking to, if anyone can clean up her mess and instill why it was wrong, its me, and you can help too I guess."

I meant that last part as a joke poking at him still being newer at being a Dom than me. But the look across his face shows how upset he still is. "I don't know if I want to." Its a hushed tone I know means he just admitted something to himself he'd been avoiding.

"What does that mean, this is the girl you told me you were falling in love with, of course you want to work through this, every couple fights and has issues, this is just a big one. Did you think you'd never crash at friend place after a fight?"

"That's just it tho, we aren't a couple, I'm just the guy she needed to help her get who she really wants. Everything we have is fake, hell she doesn't even need me for that anymore!"

"Do you really thing that? She needs you, in more ways than either of you realize. Besides this is all partially my fault."

"Yeah, I do, we would have never got together if he wasn't still chasing Alice, the stubborn fuck. don't try and take the blame either, its more than this latest fuck up, I'm tired of my heart being trampled on while we move heaven and earth to make sure he gets to have a chance with the girl he'll leave me for and forget all about me. Hell he was already getting distant since you told 'em they were ready to get back into a hobby or two. Just the thought of maybe running into Alice did this, how bad when they get together?"

"The fuck is with the 'he' shit dude? That's fucking hypocritical, or should I refer to you as a chick behind your back next time I'm pissed?"

"Oh fuck off, you know he's only done any of this to win over Alice."

"Yeah that's how it started but we both know its more than that now, right? Girls a bit thick headed, but she is a girl. So get you're head out of your ass and don't tell me what I can or can't blame myself for!" Now I'm getting worked up but I need to clear somethings up, before going back to dig for answers. "That's not why she got distant, that shits my fault, something I've been trying to fix but Kris is well Kris."

"Then why."

"Because I told her how you felt and she can't figure out how to handle that, I know she doesn't want to hurt you but doesn't know how to address any of this. She doesn't want to lose you, even if she 'gets' Alice."

"You told him? Wait when was this?!"

"Right when she got distant it would seem, if I knew she was acting that way I would've 'talked' to her."

"So all this time, all the dates and everything we did together, even the stuff that was beyond anything that would make sense for a 'practice' BF or GF, she never realized I actually was falling in love? Why would she be so worried about losing me if she never knew what we had was becoming REAL?!"

At least I finally got him calling her 'her' again. "Because you're girl still sees the world different than most people, even those outside the norm like us."

"Was she ever my girl if she still thought this was all fake right up to now?"

"Yes because I think she loves you too, but can't figure that out. The way she talks about you, cares what you think, tried so hard to fix something that she could have been dismissive about, if you did raise issue with the 'cheating' after the fact. Think about it, if she actually felt it was all fake then she would've acted like it, not freak out about it this way and making a mess."

"Lets say you're right, that just highlights the other issue it always being something with this girl, think she'll act any better when she's with Alice? I'm tired of all this shit Liz. I don't know how you planned to fix any of this, but it wasn't working."

"It was I'll have you know, until it caused this.... where did she find this broken girl anyway, you never answered that one."

"At the game store you sent her to. Wait... was the 'deny and edge' shit that's been going on you're way of fixing things?"

"Of all the places... one in million, fucking hell. Yeah it was, keep her on edge, get her really worked up, wait till she was primed and ready. Make her realize all she needs to be happy is you, that all she has to do is promise to be yours for real then let you fuck her brains out. Should have convinced her to give up on Alice. I still keep my end of the deal by introducing her back to Alice as your GF, let them build a friendship back up so on and so forth."

"AND if THAT doesn't work then what?" He sounds incredulous, but he doesn't understand the psyche of his girl. It was already starting to work. 'Bet I coulda cracked her by next week.'

"Then I use that same time to build the ground work for her to realize she needs you even if she get what she wants. Best case is thruple, worst case FWB."

"I don't want someone that has to be tricked into wanting me, let alone loving me." He whispers this and I can see his resolve solidify.

'He's really going to leave her.' I realize in horror. "Dude we had to trick her and train her just to want to love herself."

This doesn't seem to convince him if anything it made him want to leave even more. "Isn't that worse? Isn't that the core problem? Either way, I'm done, if you want to still help her, go for it. I'm going to ask to have my dorm switched, its not supposed to be co-ed anyway." He gets up to start to leave. "If you want to help her and her new 'toy' I can drop them off but that's the last time I'm helping. I'll just be her dorm-mate after that and only for as long as necessary."

"No, I'm coming over to get them myself, I'll keep them out of you're hair until you've dorm hopped, you're not in the right head space for that ride to go well. I'll be over in an hour or so. Need to clean out enough space for them to crash here." I tell him as he heads to the door, clearly planing to end things with Kris before he loses his nerve. "If this is what you want, I can't make you change your mind, but I still think you're making a mistake."

"The only mistake, was failing in love with her in the first place."

His last words send shivers down my spine and sorrow to find a home deep in the pit of my stomach.

'Time to go salvage this I guess, fuck.'

-------

Its a little more than an hour when I get to their dorm but I've got the couch and an air mattress on stand by if Kris doesn't want to share the bed with me or new girl can't sleep on a couch.

I knock on the door only for it to be opened by a new face instead of Kris or Seb. "Hello, Master Sebastian and Miss Kris are both indisposed. How may I help you."

"Hi, you must be Sarah. I'm Liz, not sure what Seb or Kris told you but I'm here to take you both to my place for now. Let things simmer down as it were."

Her eye immediately dart to the ground, I recognize the training of this type of sub. I was trying to be friendly, not my commanding voice, but either I failed or Kris told her I was one of Kris', and by extension her, Doms. "Yes, ma'am, I am at your disposal."

I'll have to work on this with her but for now I'll use it to get us moving quickly. "You said they were busy, please tell me its with make up sex?"

"Sorry Mistress I can't say that, Master Sebastian is in the shower, Miss Kris is currently ready for travel." She says as she leads me in the dorm and toward Kris's bed and what appears to be more luggage than I thought a collage student would have.

As I step fully into the room I can't see Kris at all, but I do see her collar in the trash as I walk by. 'God damn it Seb, couldn't have let me do that and replace it with one of mine, Kris has got to be distraught.' Still not seeing Kris, "So Sarah I see her luggage but where's Kris?"

Her answer is something I was not ready for.

"Master Sebastian told me to treat her like she trained me to be treated, until you arrived and took control." *Creak*

She opens up what I thought was just luggage, I was wrong, very wrong. "This is going to take more work than I expected." Is my lame reply to seeing something even I'd only seen in extreme fetish porn. A gagged, plugged, bound, un-collared, blindfolded, ear-plugged, and crying Kris.

"Don't worry Mistress I'll be able to move the trunk to your car."

'Completely missing the point Sarah.'