Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 31 by ID: a man ID: a man

What's next?

Numbering Holes

Since Reggie felt like he had to do whatever Miss Rich Bitch told him to do, he was now as nude as Big Moose. No, make that naked. As proud as he was of his star athlete body, it was not as massively muscular as Moose's. And Veronica Lodge seemed to be enjoying rubbing that salt into his wounded male ego. He was made to imitate alongside every body-builder pose the dumb, blond giant did.

The worst came when she had them face each other. His now humiliatingly small dick was nothing compared to his competition for her pussy. His only consolation was - of ALL things! - that Archie's dick was much larger than Mr. All-Muscles No Brains.

"Oh, my!" the only nude girl in the room drawled as she ran her hands from their six pack abs to their growing pricks. "Whichever one shall I choose?"

"Size doesn't matter, you know!" Reggie couldn't believe he was **** to say that. "I'm 1st-string quarterback! I'm the two guard! I'm the 4-hole!" The position between the first and second base. (Kind of like what he was metaphorically being right then.)

"4th hole, you say!"

Reggie was horrified. "No! No!! I will NOT be a 4th hole!"

"Duh, how can Reggie be a 4th hole??" Moose asked.

Veronica's look became even more wicked. "Do you want to find out?"

"Duh...uh, I'd rather find out about your 3rd hole, Veronica," he smiled gently, blushing some.

Reggie held his breath.

"Alright, Moosiekins."

Reggie breathed at last.

"And, you, Reggie, can use my 2nd hole."

"Figures. I get the shit-hole."

"What!?" she said, suddenly eyeing him.

"_I _get the 2nd hole - Better than the 4th hole!" he cried, bending and kissing her bare butt.

"Duh, if Archie were out here, he could use your 3rd hole."

"Oh, heavens, no! He is much too large for me to get my perfect lips around! I couldn't even get my slim hands around his manly member." And she closed her hand around Moose's.

Reggie watched (was she going to prepare his prick, too?!!) and realized she had made a hole of her hands. "So, is that the 4th hole?" (Hurl!! If he was to be the 4th-hole, there was only one way he could see using his.)

His warped imagination started counting on what would be the 5th-hole, 6th-hole, 7th-hole...

This being Riverdale, this was a new idea to him and others no longer protected by the Secret, at around Betty.

Meanwhile, Moose had gotten down on the carpet and easily held Veronica up as he, and she, positioned her most womanly of holes over his cock.

"Hey! Wait for me!!" Reggie cried after they began without him!!

He had to be in the more awkward position and didn't dare lean too much on either Veronica or Moose.

What made his situation even worse was that his cock was too small to reach her butthole!! He had to get what satisfaction he could by pressing her buttcheeks up against his cock and humping their insides!

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)