Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 28 by Mister2814 Mister2814

What do you choose?

No time. Lily speaks up

“Wait,” Lily exclaims. “What’s up?” you ask. “Can I propose another idea?” she asks. You gesture to tell her the floor is hers. “This new plan does depend on how we feel about going back to the Potions lab again.” Ari asks, “Why?” Lily begins to propose her idea. “Well, like Paphia said, if we think about fairness, Michelle here should be given a chance to, not only, take John’s cock but also get knocked up by him. But, like you said, she’s human, and that’s not really going to help out our situation. But … what if she wasn’t?”

Both you and Michelle are lost. The nymph & the pixie seem to be too, but they soon see what the mermaid is suggesting. Paphia asks, “Wait. Are you telling us, you know how to make one of those things?” Lily shakes her head. “But maybe someone here … can do it by chance,” Lily suggests. The three Fae all look at you. “Do what?” you ask, completely lost. Lily explains, “There is a potion that can be made to make humans into Fae. It’s a lot easier to turn a human woman into a Fae woman than it is to turn a human man into a Fae man, which is why we haven’t tried to fix our population issue by making men into Fae men.”

The gears start turning in your head. “I think I now know what you’re suggesting. Much how I happened to make a potion to make Michelle into my bimbo ****, you think I can somehow make a potion to turn her into a Fae?” Lily nods. “Exactly. Then you can have four Fae wombs to fill up as many times as you want,” she says. You still don’t know much about this world, but you at least have more faith in your ability to make that potion than you did in making the potion “Mike” wanted you to make, mostly because you really want to make Michelle into a Fae. “Let’s do it,” you say.

The three Fae all hug Michelle. “You’re going to be one of us very soon, Michelle,” Ari exclaims. “Fae & pregnant,” Paphia adds. You gather all the things they found and make your way back to the Potions lab. Much like before, there are some eyes that look your way and see the four beautiful women behind you. It doesn’t take long before you arrive to the Potions lab. You reach for the door and notice it is still unlock. You chalk it up to someone fortunately forgetting to lock it. The five of you enter the lab. Once in, you close and lock the door. You turn around and bump into Paphia. “What’s wrong?”

Paphia points to the front of the lab. Sitting at the front desk is the elf woman you saw earlier. She waves at you all, then gestures you all to come close. At this point, you figure, it’s too late to try to run, so you, and your four tag-a-longs go see the professor. You nervously wave, “Hello, Professor.” She doesn’t say anything. Instead you puts her laptop in her desk and make it face us. “What do you see?” she asks. You look at the laptop and see security footage from earlier today … when you broke in and made the potion that Michelle how she is right now. You gulp. You know, according to Lily, what you did, even though it was by accident, is illegal and you worry for your future.

“I can explain,” you say. “Explain how you made this woman into this bimbo ****?” the professor asks. “It wasn’t my intention to do that. It’s … it’s kind of a long story,” you respond. “Well then, you better get to explaining. Because I am legally responsible to report this, and all because you’re cute, don’t think I won’t do it.” She thinks you’re cute. That tracks. The amulet may be playing a part in that. Do you explain to her what happened or try to convince her to let you off the hook?

(Author’s note: Feel free to add to any of my chapters.)

What do you do?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)