Nicole

"Sarah? Is that you Sarah?" Sarah heard Nicole's fearful voice. She understood her apprehension of having someone entering unannounced.

"Hey Nicole, it’s me how did-" Sarah started to speak before she gasped "Oh my God!" her hand flew to cover her gaping mouth.

Nicole was wearing John's shirt which reached down to her thigh and her hair was a disheveled mess, but that wasn't what shocked Sarah. Nor was it the love bites on her neck and shoulder. It was the painful grimace on her face and the agonizing way Nicole was limping over to the table.

Sarah dropped the picnic basket on the floor and rushed over to help Nicole reach the table.

"Oh my God, are you alright?! Did he hurt you?! I swear I'll kill the fucker if-" she sputtered.

"-SHH!" Nicole hissed, "Not so loud! John's still asleep."

Sarah nodded and lowered her voice "fine, but are you ok? Did he hurt you? I swear to god I'll kill him if-"

"-No, No, No, He didn't hurt me..." Nicole blushed and weakly smiled "At least I don't think so. I feel... kinda... I feel really sore down there." has she gestured down to her crotch.

"Thank the gods" Sarah sighed in relief and brought over a cushion for Nicole to sit on. Sarah laughed and said "That’s what you get for taking such a big cock for your first time" Sarah teased her with a bright smile on her face. "You probably just over stretched yourself, like when you over work at the gym. You'll be just fine, just take it easy for a few days. Now let me see."

"What?" Nicole asked shocked at what Sarah was implying.

"Geez relax," Sarah said rubbing Nicole's shoulder, "I'm just going to make sure you’re not hurt, don't worry about it." Nicole gulped and slowly spread her legs and lifted the shirt covering her.

Sarah eyes grew wide and she gave a sharp intake of air. "Damm" Sarah whispered.

"Wh-What's wrong?" Nicole's voice came out has worried whisper, tinged with fear.

"Your pussy lips are... it's all really red and swollen" Sarah said in wonder has she peered closer. "but I don't see any blood. Jesus! John did a real number on you." she said with some real admiration. "Don't worry, I got something in my bag that will help you." She got up and start to walk to the couch

"It's not there, we took it to the bedroom, I'll get it." Nicole said has she tried to get up. Sarah just hushed her and pushed her back down on the seat with a stern look that convinced Nicole not to protest. Has Sarah entered to bedroom to pick up her bag she saw John stir and open his eyes. She put her finger to her lips to tell him to keep quiet and winked at him before going back to Nicole.

Has she rummaged through the bag she said with admiration "John did a real number on you. Looks like he fucked the shit out you. You sure he didn't hurt you?". He wasn't too rough?" Nicole just shook her head. "Did you bleed a lot the first time?" she asked

"I don't know. I don't think so." Nicole answered. Sarah head shot up and she looked at Nicole with a raised eyebrow has if to say, 'What do you mean you don't know!?'. Nicole was blushing with embarrassment has she sputtered an answer "I don't think so. John was really sweet and tender and... and he cleaned me up after...after..." Nicole was blushing bright red.

Sarah pulled out some cream "Here, this will help with the swelling and ease the pain. Keep it. Hell keep the whole bag. Who knows what else in there you might want to try out." she said with a mischievous smile and a wink.

Nicole applied the cream to herself "Ahh, that feels better." she sighed at cream's cooling effect.

Don't worry too much about it." Sarah mention has she watched Nicole apply the cream. "Your muscles are just sore from being stretched too far, like when you overwork at the gym. Trust me, just take it easy a few days and you won't have this problem again. It's a good thing you’re taking that gymnastic class, probably saved you from tearing something else down there." Nicole just nodded.

"So, how did it go?" Sarah ask excitedly grinning like the Cheshire Cat when Nicole finished. "Did it hurt? Did he take good care of you?"

"Oh Sarah" Nicole purred, a dreamy look on her face. "It was better than I ever dreamed. So many girls always say it hurts a lot the first time I was a bit scared, and... Gods, John was so tender, so patient... It felt like being pricked by a needle, but only for a few moments," she quickly added and trailed off for a second, remembering the moment. "after that..." she just smiled and her whole self seemed to glow. "It was wonderful...I just wish we had started earlier. You were right. I should have tried to seduce him earlier."

Sarah nodded and smiled at her friend. Relieved that John had taken good care of Nicole and that her first time had worked out really well.

Sarah face then turn a little more serious "Ok... now that I know you’re ok and John took good care of you has he should..." Sarah paused for a moment before continuing. "Just what the hell were you thinking about last night!?"

"WH-What??" Nicole was caught completely off guard.

"What were you thinking about with that stupid game last night! That game is way above you head. Now tell me who put you up to it?"

"I'm not a child! You can't keep treating my like I'm stupid just because I don't spread my legs for every dick that shows up!" Nicole snapped back at her.

Sarah drew her breath and took Nicole's hands in her own. "Nicole, you’re my best friend and I don't want you to get hurt. You know I just like to tease everyone, and I hoped it might help you go after John. Look I never tried to put you down and I'm really glad you got together with John and I hope someday I can find someone like that. But that doesn't change a thing about last night. Now who put you up to it? Whose idea was it and why did you go along with it?"

Nicole was silent has she look down at the table and at Sarah's hand holding her.

Since she didn't answer Sarah continued "I've know you since kindergarten so I know it wasn't your idea, not your style. I didn't put you up to it. You hate Tom so you would never go along with anything he came up with. John would never put you in a situation like that. He didn't stop it earlier because he was too busy thinking with his dick to pay attention. So, who was it? Matt or Miranda?"