Never have I ever...

Perhaps it was Hannah’s rousing speech or maybe they just didn’t feel like arguing with the elder Woodsen, but the three teens came around to the idea of playing ‘Never have I ever’. A nice quick drinking game was sure to lighten the mood and pass the time, by which point the others would return with Victoria in tow and all would be well. It certainly sounded better than fretting for the remainder of the evening.

“I’m probably going to regret this,” Ashley said, sitting up properly in the single seater chair. “But, sure, let’s play.”

“I’m in too,” Chloe announced, not to be outdone by the blonde, and looking for a way to relax. “In the spirit of Spring Break and all. What about you, Gavin?”

“Oh, uh, yeah,” Gavin agreed thoughtfully. While he’d have been more comfortable with a traditional game, this trip was meant to be branching out socially. Besides, Kurt had taught him to seize the opportunities that presented themselves to him. “I’m not going to be the only one to sit it out.”

“Excellent,” Hannah cheered, clapping her hands together. “Well, since it was my idea, I’ll go first and then we can go anti-clockwise around.”

Hannah swung her hand around in a circular motion, pointing from Gavin, past Chloe and around to Ashley, indicating the order of the turns.

“Well, this could take a while,” Ashley said with a frown. “What haven’t you done, Hans?”

“Shut it,” Hannah growled, and then with a finger to her chin and looking upwards, she considered her options. “Let’s see…Never have I ever….um….oh…oh…I got one, never have I ever…had sex with more than two people at once!”

To the surprise of nobody, no one drank. All of the teens had engaged in a threesome, all of them that very day, and all before, but none more than that.

“Geez, going to the big guns right out the gate,” Ashley laughed at the explicitness of Hannah’s reveal.

Hannah just shrugged, while Gavin pursed his lips.

“When you say ‘more than two people’…” Gavin asked hesitantly. “You mean, like a gangbang?”

“Ew, Gavin,” Chloe said, slapping him playfully on the arm.

“I just meant more than a threesome. I’ve never been part of even a foursome or more,” Hannah elaborated for the young, bespectacled man. “But I wouldn’t say no to a gangbang either. What makes you think it’d be gross, Chloe?”

“Just…all those cocks, everywhere, thrusting and pumping all around you,” Chloe put up her hands as if to block an invisible cock being thrust into her face. “It sounds terrifying.”

“Sounds heavenly,” Hannah countered. “I’d love to be worshipped by ten, even twelve, cocks all at once.”

“Worshipped?” Chloe coughed. “More like used.”

“Po-tate-oh, po-tat-oh,” Hannah replied with a smile. “Sometimes, that’s half the fun.”

“Alright, Gavin,” Ashley interjected. “Your turn.”

“Oh, shit, I wasn’t thinking…” Gavin scrambled to think of something he hadn’t done. There were plenty of things he’d never done, although this fortnight was going some length to rectify that, but his mind was blanking on a lot of them right at this moment. Then, after a couple of minutes, he blurted out, “I’ve never fucked a girl in the ass.”

He immediately clasped his hand over his mouth as Chloe and Ashley’s eyes went wide and Hannah burst out laughing. He tried to salvage the situation by saying, “I mean, never have I ever had anal sex with a girl.”

More jaws dropped as Hannah lifted her glass and downed the shot. Ashley looked at her quizzically as her sister refilled her glass.

“You understand it means you fucking another person,” Ashley clarified. “Not you being fucked in the ass.”

“I know, I understood,” Hannah assured her.

“How?” Chloe asked, frowning but sitting on the edge of her seat, ready to hear more.

“Well, I consider myself bi-sexual, and I’ve experimented with women,” Hannah told the three curious teens. “I was with this one girl, and I was trying out a strap-on. We must have lubed it up a little too much because it slipped right past her hole I was trying to angle it into and it pushed into her butt instead. It was surprising at first, but she kinda liked the feeling so I just fucked her ass with it. It was actually pretty good for me too, because the angle of the strap-on in her ass was really grinding against my clit.”

“Too much information,” Ashley recoiled into her chair. “I’m not nearly drunk enough to hear that.”

“That’s easily solved,” Chloe retorted, taking her turn. “Never have I ever cheated on my boyfriend.”

The redhead narrowed her eyes and grinned as Ashley had to take a shot of whiskey, thanks to her fooling around with Zack behind Brandon’s back. But she wasn’t the only one to drink. Again, Hannah downed her own shot glass and proceeded to refill both hers and her sister’s.

Seeing the inquisitive looks of the teens again, Hannah explained, “I was dating a guy but his friend was cute and kept flirting with me. So, I teased him, because I figured he was all talk. We got carried away and wound up actually fucking in my boyfriend’s bed.”

“My sister the role model, everyone,” Ashley jeered.

“Hey, you drank too so I don’t see how you’re any better.” Hannah stuck out her tongue. “Besides, you’ve been pretty wild this week too, so maybe you’ll have trouble coming up with something as well.”

“Nah, it’ll take a lifetime to catch up to you,” Ashley said, before thinking up something she’d never done. With the threesome from earlier still lingering on her mind, a similar revelation came to mind. “Ok, I’ve got one, never have I ever been penetrated by two guys at once.”

By this point, no one was shocked that Hannah knocked back her shot. It was surprising, however, when Chloe tentatively picked up her glass and gulped it down, wincing as the whiskey hit her throat. Gavin blushed, realising that he had been apart of the event that caused her to drink and secretly hoping that no one probed further, lest his involvement was revealed.

Unfortunately, Hannah jumped up, seeing that Chloe had drank too and demanded, “Oh, do tell?!”

Chloe frowned as she asked, “Do I have to?”

“Oh, come on, I did for you,” Hannah pressed her, as she refilled their glasses.

“There’s not much to tell really. I was having sex with a guy when I noticed another guy was watching. The first guy suggested we make it a threesome and I liked the idea, so I gave them the go ahead.” Chloe replied, doing her best to hide the identities of those involved.

“That feeling of two cocks inside you, it’s perfection, right?” Hannah casually discussed with the redhead as if they were talking about a delicious meal or a piece of art.

However, Ashley was squinting at Chloe from her chair. Gavin noticed the blonde’s gaze too, but tried to remain natural. Ashley could guess that one of the guys was probably Kurt. But that only left two guys who could have possibly been involved…Zack and Gavin. Since she believed Zack hadn’t had sex with anyone other than her and Lisa recently, that meant that Gavin was the likely third body, Ashley deduced.

She kept that conclusion to herself…for now.

A record of how many shots each character has had, for anyone interested.

Hannah: 3

Ashley: 1

Chloe: 1

Gavin: 1