Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 25 by cj24 cj24

What should Robbie do?

Nah...let's wait by Brooke's side.

You decide not to read her journal as even you had boundaries you'd never cross and reading someone's private thoughts was definitely one of those. You stay sitting in a recliner next to Brooke's bed and pull out your phone and just surf social media. A little while later you hear a small yawn and you put your phone away to see Brooke awake. She looks towards you and smiles sadly. You knew she was feeling guilt and after the whole revelation, you wanted her back in your life again. You sit next to her on the bed and immediately wanting things to get over with, you decide to stir a conversation.

"Brooke..."

"Yea, Robbie?"

"I'm sorry."

"For what? It's all my fault... you had every right to be mad with me. I fucking cheated on you."

"But I wish I was there for you more. You told me that you felt lonely all those years ago and Adam took advantage of that. I only wish I could've spent more time with you."

"Robbie, I don't care what you think. I was being selfish and naive and stupidly believed Adam's lies."

"Then how about this. We were both wrong. That leaves us in the same boat."

"Robbie, I..."

"Brooke, all these years, I may have felt heartbroken when you 'cheated' on me. But deep down in my heart, I never stopped loving you. You were more than just a popular chick to me, You gave me a reason to succeed in the future. You were the reason I started working out more so I can physically not just suit your standards but also protect myself. For that I would like to ask you one question."

"Robbie..."

"Brooke would you like to be my girlfriend again so that we can completely start over fresh?"

You saw tears pooling in her eyes and then with a watery smile, she screamed, "YES! I would love to be your girlfriend again. I would love to start everything over again with no stupid backstabbing fuckers to ruin it."

You smiled and smashed your lips on her beautiful ones, which she happily returned. Soon things got steamy and you and Brooke pulled each other clothes off until the both of you were completely naked. Brooke's body only seemed to have gotten sexier and time seemed to have treated her well. Her G-Cup breasts seemed to still defy gravity and her pussy was still pink and inviting while wet with her juices. You start with her breasts and knead them in your hands as she moans at the touch. You then tweak her nipples and place your mouth on them slowly licking them as her moans get even louder. After playing with her tits, you slowly trail kisses down her body all the way to her ripe pink pussy. You start licking it and she is just moaning, "More, More!" You oblige and soon start fingering it and after a few more minutes she screams in pleasure as she orgasms in your face. You lick the juices noticing that it was still sweet as ever and get up. You then line your cock to her hole and you look at her silently asking for permission.

She nods and says, "Please Robbie, fuck me like you did back in high school. This was my greatest dream. To be fucked by your huge cock."

You then insert it in and feel a wave of pleasure at the nostalgia of doing the exact same thing back in the day and you see she feels the exact same way. You start pumping in and out of her and she does the same moving her hips. The two of you slowly go faster and faster and after 10 minutes, you both were resembling rabbits in heat.

"Brooke," you say between thrusts. "You have the greatest pussy and I want to be there for you from now on."

You see Brooke was in tears at your words and says, "Of course, you will always be my greatest love Robbie. I don't want you to leave again."

You also find tears welling up as you hear the sincerity and love behind her words and reply back, "Brooke I will never leave you again. Leaving you was my greatest mistake. I promise I will stay with you to the very end."

With those words, you both explode as your dick shoots glob of cum inside her pussy and her own pussy starts leaking it slightly.

The two of you lay on the bed cuddling each other finding happiness and fall asleep blissfully in each other's arms happy to once again be the happy couple that they wanted to be.

What happens next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)