Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 31 by Cheesers123

What has Sarah been dishonest about?

Mirandas punishment is a little different

As Sarah holds your dick she explains herself. "My real punishment for Miranda is a little more interesting." You cock an eyebrow quizzically while Miranda futiley strains against her restraints. "W-what?" The bound girl asks but Sarah ignores her and continues her explanation. "Since she's apparently such a goddamn slut for your cock I figure we should teach her a lesson about sharing." You continue to stare at her blankly , not quite sure where she's going with this. "We're going to fuck and make her watch, got it?" She sighs, exasperated.

With that you finally manage to understand, and you stammer out an affirmative to Sarah. "Great." She replies, getting on her hands and knees on the bed over Miranda, her pussy towards you and her face towards Mirandas. "Now please John, give me that big hard dick of yours." She mewls in her sexiest voice, biting her lip and wiggling her hips to you seductively. You're not going to keep her waiting so you quickly get into position, lining your cock up with her wet slit. As you push your cock into her Sarah gasps theatrically and throws her head back. "Mmmmm oh my god! Miranda this... this cock is so fucking big! Mhmm! And h-hard! I don't know if I can -Mmmhm- handle it." Sarah does an excellent job with her voice, making it sound like your size was truly incredible and she threw her whole body into the performance, her legs shaking and her hands desperately grasping at the sheets to show off to Miranda how your cock was making her feel.

Miranda, for her part is either buying it or spiritedly playing along as she pleads back "Please Sarah, let me help you. I wanna ride that cock again!" While she begs she struggles futilely against her restraints and bucks her hips wildly, as if trying to somehow reach up to your cock. When you fill Sarah completely she moans again, saying "So good! It's ok Miranda, I don't want this monster cock to break your pussy. I'll take care of it." You help her "take care of it", slowly fucking Sarah, enjoying her passionate moans, even though you know they're an exaggeration to tease Miranda they still stroke your ego.

You begin to fuck Sarah harder and faster, your fingers sink into the soft flesh of her ass as you pull her back against you with your every thrust. Her pussy squeezes around you as you fuck her and she keeps up her loud exaggerated moans as your thrusts quicken, her body slapping against yours and your balls bouncing against her clit with each hard thrust. Reaching one hand forward you grab Sarahs supple breast, kneading it tightly and pinching her nipple with your fingers. This prompts another yell of ecstasy as she says between pants "Mmhm Fuck yeah! Play with my tits baby!"

You decide to try something else you suspect Sarah will like, reeling back you deliver a firm smack to her bouncing behind. Sarah crumples instantly, collapsing forward on to Miranda writhing in pleasure. "Damn John." She half whispers between ragged breaths. "I didn't know you had it in you." Now Sarahs upper half is pressed against Miranda, her face resting on her 36C breasts, your thrusting causing them to shake slightly. With Sarah out of the way you get a look at Mirandas face for the first time since you started fucking Sarah.

Her cheeks are flushed and her eyes are full of desperation. When she makes eye contact with you she pleads again. "Please John! I want your cock too, I'm so wet now! Please!" You smirk, finally feeling like you're getting even for what she did with Tom. Without saying a word to Miranda you begin to pound Sarah even harder, jackhammering her pussy even as she squirms atop Miranda.

On shaky arms Sarah forces herself up and moves so that her head is almost level with Mirandas, her lips millimetres from Mirandas earlobe. "This cock is all mine right now, slut." Sarah half whispers, one hand caressing Mirandas thin neck while her lips suck on her earlobe playfully. In this position their buxom chests are pinned together, their sensitive nipples rubbing on each others chests as your forceful thrusts make their breasts bounce.

Suddenly, inspiration strikes you and you grab Sarah under her stomach to lift her up. She looks back at you confused but you just tell her. "Grab the headboard." She does so and you move forward so that Sarahs pussy, with your cock still buried deep inside, is just in front of Mirandas face. Sarah is now squatting over Mirandas face whilst you kneel with one leg on either side of the brown haired girls chest. It's a somewhat awkward angle to thrust at but the tease that comes from it seemed to be worth it. Sarah seems to agree as she taunts Miranda "Enjoying the view?" "Uh-huh." Is the wordless reply.

"Miranda, put that pretty little mouth of yours to good use and kiss my balls!" You order Miranda and, as you expected, she immediately obeys and you feel a pair of small soft lips eagerly kiss your sack. "Did she... do it?" Sarah asks breathlessly.

"Of course she did." You reply. "She's a slut, remember."

"Fuck yeah she is!" Sarah giggles. "Fuck me hard John, I wanna squirt on her stuck-up perfect face." You oblige happily, thrusting hard and fast into Sarah again, Mirandas tongue grazing your balls with every chance she gets. You can feel Sarahs sopping wet pussy oozing girlcum down your shaft, dripping down on to Mirandas waiting face, turning her into a picture of sexual tantalisation. It doesn't take long in this new position before you feel yourself drawing closer to climax, and you can tell by the way Sarahs exaggerated moans have been replaced with real ones that she feels similarly.

Leaning up you cup Sarahs tits with both hands, squeezing them hard whilst kissing her delicate neck. That was enough to send Sarah over the edge and you feel a fresh flow of moisture fall over your cock as her tight hole spasms around you. "Fuck! Mmmhmm!" She moans again, although this time in genuine pleasure. You fuck her through her orgasm, her body shaking against you until she finally regains control of herself. "Where should I come?" you whisper into her ear.

"Wherever you want." She says breathily, "Maybe you should give it to Miranda. She'd make a good cumdump."

Where do you finish?

Comments

      Want to support CHYOA?
      Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)