Midnight Snack

Alice finished gulping a glass of water to satisfy her thirst. She and Jake had just finished talking about their feelings and what they wanted to try and they had agreed to give it a shot but to take it slowly. She wasn't the kind of girl to do that kind of stuff, Scarlett was supposed to be the wild one, not her. She felt a nervous shiver of anticipation as she remembered the thrill she felt when Duncan and Delilah had both touched her, but it was the look of pure love and admiration in Jake's eyes that had won her over.

Alice froze when she heard a soft noise behind her. She listened to the soft pitter-patter of bare feet approaching her and briefly wondered who it could be as she felt her heart start pounding in her chest. Something told her it wasn't Sharon, not even Scarlett, his approach was confirmed when she sensed the warm breath on her neck just before she felt his hand gently cup her butt.

*

Duncan's eyes fluttered open, and he sat up on the bed he shared with Scarlett trying to determine what had awakened him. He glanced over at Scarlett sleeping next to him and moved the sheets to cover her up again. For a brief moment, he thought about waking her up for some sex but quickly chased away the thought given the way she had told him to stay on his side of the bed when he tried to cuddle with her. He guessed something must be bothering her but he didn't know what. He was sure she had enjoyed their tryst so it couldn't be him, he just didn't have a clue what it could be. Still, he mused, what he really wanted was to repeat what he had done with Alice and Delilah earlier that night and take things further.

Hearing a soft noise coming from the main room he climbed out of bed, wearing only his boxers and a t-shirt, he shuffled over to the main room to see what was up. Entering the main room he caught his breath at the sight before him. Under the moonlight filtering in through the windows, he saw Alice standing in front of the kitchen counter wearing a light pink cropped top with a set of pale boyshorts panties that nicely molded her round ass while still showing off almost half of her ass cheeks.

Duncan slowly crossed the room his eyes roamed over her body, tracing every curve of her body until they settled on her ass cheeks. Reaching her, his hand gently went to her butt cheek and he heard her soft gasp. Her fingers gripped the countertop as he started to rub his hand over her butt. His other hand briefly rested on her hip before moving across to her stomach and sliding up to squeeze her breast.

"Duncan?" Alice asked, her voice wavering uncertainty even as she somehow knew it was him, "What are you doing?" She felt his hands start to caress her butt and grope her tits, the attention he was giving and her own curiosity kept her rooted to the spot as she let him continue to arouse her. She gripped the counter with both hands to try to stop them from shaking.

"Finishing what we started," he whispered, nipping her earlobe making her shiver while he pulled her shirt up exposing her medium-sized breast. "They're so nice," he added tugging at her nipple drawing a short gasp from Alice then ended in a strangled groan.

"Now? Us?" she half moaned half sighed as she looked down and watched his hand grope her exposed tits and felt his thumb brush over the hard nub of her nipple sending another bolt of pleasure through her. His other hand had already pushed her panties up baring both her butt cheeks, the fabric wedging into her butt like a thong, while he rubbed one cheek with his hand and pressed his hardon into the other. Alice felt her excitement grow inside her, 'this feels better than dancing' she thought

"You want to get Delilah?" he said kissing her neck as Alice sighed. He could feel her legs quiver when he dragged her hand to his crotch. Alice quickly started rubbing the bulge in his boxers as she groaned in frustration with her other hand still gripping the counter for support.

"J-Jake," Alice managed to say. She couldn't believe this was going to happen so soon. They hadn't even worked out what they wanted to try first, if they should approach one of their friends or not, but it looked like this night might be the start. In a way, she felt some relief that it was Duncan, someone they both knew and not a stranger.

"He doesn't have to know," Duncan said. He tried to maneuver her hand inside his boxers. Alice's hand instinctively helped him reach inside, her fingers wrapping around his hard dick. Alice's eyes went wide open in surprise when she felt his hard throbbing dick twitching in her hand. Until now Jake's dick had been the only one she had ever known and now she had her second dick in her hand with her boyfriend right upstairs.

"Jake! Not without Jake!" her voice trembled as she turned around, her hand still stroking his dick inside his boxers. Alice glanced down at watched her hand slowly stroking Duncan's dick. She felt her pussy ache to be filled again and almost felt her mouth start to drool in anticipation of tasting his dick. She looked up at Duncan and bit her lips "We can't do this without Jake."

Duncan nodded dumbly and started to follow Alice up the stairs. He really wanted the two girls but he wasn't going to pass up on the chance to fuck Alice, he just didn't know how it would work out with Jake and how far they were willing to go. He had been surprised at first that Alice had even let him touch her while they danced. And even more, surprised when he had gotten bolder with her and neither Alice nor Jake tried to stop him. Catching Jake rubbing himself while he watched Duncan feel up both girls made him think that he was okay with everything. 'Hope he's not into any of that homo-shit' he thought while he stared at Alicia's round ass and decided to take the risk.

Alice also didn't know how it would work out with Jake and Duncan. She had never been one to look at porn much, especially with Grace shutting down Scarlett every time she wanted to show them something, but what little she had seen was mostly couples, and once a clip of a guy with two girls. Hopefully, the guys might have a better idea. 'Maybe just repeat what we just did?' she thought to herself while thinking about how she had fantasized about someone fucking her while she gave Jake a blowjob. She wished she had at least looked up something to know what to expect.

Reaching the landing on the top of the stairs Duncan turned to Charlie's room to make one last attempt to get Alice and Delilah together. Alice shook her head as she grabbed his arm and pulled him to her room.

Jake looked up in surprise when he saw Alice enter followed by Duncan. Alice put her finger to her lips to keep him quiet before she pulled off her top showing him her tits and knelt on the bed. "Can we start like this?" Alice asked hopefully while Jake only nodded, afraid his voice would betray his desire. Alice leaned forward and kissed a stunned Jake, their lips parted as their tongues started to slowly slide against each other, Jake absentmindedly brought one of his hands up to her tits and started to play with it as she sighed into his mouth.

Duncan knelt on the floor behind Alice and squeezed both her butt cheeks, his hands digging into the soft flesh while he start to leave a trail of soft kisses and licks on her as he gradually spiraled closer and closer to her damp panties. When he felt her push back against him he rolled down her panties and went back to licking her dripping pussy as he buried his face in her ass inhaling the sweet scent of arousal from her pussy.

Alice broke her kiss with Jake when Duncan started to peel off her panties and the two stared at each other with bated breaths for a moment, neither one of them daring to look behind at Duncan wondering what he would do. Alice half closed her eyes and whined as she bit her lower lips when she felt Duncan's tongue between her ass cheeks. Jake instantly knew Duncan was doing something to her and he felt his dick get harder than it already was if that was even possible.

Alice closed her eyes and softly moaned in pleasure as she felt both boys caress her body while Duncan's tongue licked her flowing juices or probed his tongue into her pussy. His face rubbing into her ass was a new wonderful sensation to her as she saw Jake watch her with lustful desire written all over his face.

For a few moments, Jake lay there, his gaze frozen on the blissful expression etched on Alice's face as he fondled her tits and pinched her nipples while Duncan ate her pussy from behind. He suddenly felt the urge to pleasure Alice himself. He pulled her onto the bed with him, laying her down in the middle as he hurried to strip.

Alice whimpered when Jake pulled her forward and off the tongue that had been devouring her pussy from behind. She didn't want that to stop but reluctantly let Jake re-position her on the bed and watched as both boys quickly stripped naked and joined her on the bed. In the darkness she could barely see the outline of their dicks standing proud and hard for her, it made her juices flood her pussy and drip onto the bed. She licked her lips in anticipation as her hands reached out to grab both stiff poles in her small hands as they settled down at each side of her.

She slowly stroked both boys as they descended down to devour her tits, they squeezed and sucked her hard nipples sending pleasurable bolts through her as she arched her back as if to push he tits into them while she squeezed and stroked their hard dicks. She gasped in surprise when she suddenly felt two hands spread her legs apart, two hands rubbing and exploring her pussy while two mouths tugged and ad licked at her nipples.

Alice gasped and moaned as she squirmed under the dual **** on her body, She pushed her chest up to them and bucked her hips to their hands. Waves of pleasure rolled through her body but their different rhythms kept her from reaching her peak. "So good, so good" she repeated like a mantra "Please... please..." she begged them to make her cum.

Jake signaled Duncan to head to her pussy as he repositioned himself above Alice's head and started to feed her his dick while Duncan settled down between Alice's legs and renewed his oral **** on her pussy. This time he focused on her clit as he grabbed her hips. Alice place an encouraging hand on Duncan head, guiding him to her clit while she rolled Jake's balls with her fingers.

Alice moaned around Jake's manhood in her mouth as he feed her his dick and fondled her tits while Duncan ate her out. 'This was so much better than doing the 69' Alice briefly thought in a haze of pleasure. Jake's pulsing dick in her mouth felt so much thicker, harder than usual and he seemed to plunge deeper inside her mouth. Duncan's tongue also seemed to go much deeper in her pussy in this position. The 4 hands roaming over her body were driving her wild that she almost lost track of which hand was which, not that she really cared much at this point as long and they didn't stop. She let out a deep guttural moan when she felt her orgasm explode inside her as she tried to stuff Jake's hard dick deeper in her mouth.

Jake watched Alice cum beneath him and cupped her face with his hand keeping himself inside her mouth. He watched in awe as Alice's eyes' bulged wide open when Duncan bent her legs up and forward, bending her in half and slipped his dick into her wet pussy and started to fuck her. Duncan started to furiously fuck her pussy to reach his own pleasure while Jake cradled her head and started to slowly do the same with Alice's mouth. He looked over and watched Duncan fuck his girlfriend, it made Jake's cum churn inside his balls at the same time he felt an uneasy pit in his stomach.

The wet sound of slapping flesh mixed with Alice's moan of pleasure as they fucked her from both ends. Jake watched Alice lick and suck his dick while her tits bounce every time Duncan thrust into her pussy. Alice thrashed on the bed, completely lost in the sensation of being fucked by both boys as she felt another orgasm burst over her body.

"I'm gonna cum Ali!" Duncan warned them as he pushed deeper into her, "Gonna fill your cunt! Gonna fill it up!" he said spewing his hot sperm, flooding her pussy.

"He's coming inside me!" Alice moaned in ecstasy, "Jake! he's..." Her words were cut off when Jake shoved his dick into her mouth and blasted another load into her mouth, filling her mouth as she desperately tried to swallow each thick creamy rope he fired into her. "Take my cum, yeah that's it baby, swallow it, swallow it all!" Jake said has he pumped himself into her mouth.

With their final shot fired, first Duncan and then Jake slowly eased themselves out of Alice and rested on the bed, their hands still roaming over her body. All three teens silently caught their breath as the boys basked in the sight of Alice's limp naked body spread out on the bed. Jake and Alice stared lovingly at each other while he fondled her tits and Duncan ran his hands over her legs.

Duncan was the first to move as he put his clothes back on. He leaned in and gave Alice's breast a gentle squeeze as he rolled her nipple in his fingers and said "That was.... I'll... I'll see you two tomorrow." and then left the naked couple to cuddle together.

****

Has Duncan made his way back to his room he had the feeling that someone was watching him. He paused halfway down the stairs and looked around, hoping that it might be Alice or Jake calling him back for another round. Seeing nobody he turned back and went to the room he was sharing with Scarlett.