Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 9 by Throwaway69 Throwaway69

Who's There?

Melissa

It was Melissa standing over us, still wearing the swimsuit thst she was wearing by the pool. She looked upset.

"Is this what you guys think of me? Just some cock crazed slut wanting her own brother?"

Cassidy steps in. "Listen Melissa, we were just fooling around, it didn't mean anything." Cassidy gets away from me, pulls her bikini back together and sits on the bed.

I stammer while trying to pull my shorts back on. "Ya, ye, yeah. We were just joking around. Well we were until it got kinda heavy." Did I really just use a line from an 80s movie? I refocus. "It's just that Cassidy seems to think I have a thing for you."

Melissa seems taken aback."Oh, so that's why all the sibling talk? Then why all the talk about how slutty I am?" She puts her hands on her hips, a stance that demands a response.

Cassidy getting more nervous, she gets up from the bed and puts her arms around Melissa. "We just got carried away, we're really sorry. We know that you're not some cock crazed slut." Cassidy squeezes Melissa while half hugging her. "Are we good?"

Melissa seems unconvinced. "I dunno, that was a lot to take in. I didn't even know Mike had a thing for me, although I shouldn't be surprised." She motions toward her whole body and giggles. "And I didn't leave my underwear out on purpose, I was just always in a rush to get ready in the morning."

I'm just sitting on the bed, not sure what to say that won't make this worse.

Melissa takes Cassidy's hands off of her and turns her attention to me, "Well do you think I'm hot? Do you want to fuck your own sister?" She takes the couple steps before reaching the bed.

Her pussy is pretty much perfectly directly in me sight line, and I can see that she's wet. Deciding to take control of the situation, I say. "Well, you're putting on this front like you're angry but it seems to me like you got off on us." I reach out and lightly rub her moist pussy. "In fact you were watching us for a while. Which means you liked all the **** talk and you loved how rough I was with Cassidy pretending it was you."

Melissa has a shiver down her spine, but she doesn't move my hand away from her. "Well, it was hot watching you two." Melissa uses her left hand and pushes my hand harder into her now soaked pussy.

Cassidy not wanting to be a bystander to all this kisses Melissa on her neck from behind and grabs a big handful of her ass.

Melissa seeing what's happening turns her head and kisses Cassidy on the lips and slips her tongue into her mouth. Melissa's right hand grabs my hard cock over my oversized swim shorts.

I make eye contact with Cassidy and wink, I suddenly pick up Melissa ans throw her onto the bed.

"Oh, I mean this is a little fast guys." Melissa nervously added. She clearly wasn't ok with that or perhaps she was nervous about what's going to happen.

Cassidy soothly replied. "We don't want to pressure you." Cassidy lies down next to her. "If you're not comfortable with this we don't have to do anything."

I got an idea. "While you guys talk I'll be right back." I walk towards the stairs up to the main level. Once I'm out of their view I run up the stairs and out to the car just praying it isn't locked.

I pull on the door handle and the door pops open thank God. I grab the book and the pen I brought and write in it.

What do you write?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)