Matt

You rise to your feet and walk the few steps to the hat, seeing as everyone's too busy to pass it to you. You feel like you should be pissed off after how badly tonight has gone for you, but for some reason the only thing you feel is the fire of intense arousal and adrenaline coursing through your veins.

Reaching into the hat, you draw your best friend and are immediately disappointed. You wanted Tom or Miranda, so you could try and split them up to give yourself a chance with your crush. You cast your gaze at your best friend and his crush, Matt laying on his back across the couch while Sarah holds his hands above his head dominantly while she rubs her sopping pussy lips along his cock. It's very obvious where they're going to end up soon.

You weigh your options with this dare - after being betrayed and humiliated by Nicole, you really need to curry some favor with the others. You also figure that at this point, any dare other than one where Sarah gets some dick will probably result in her ignoring you and taking Matt up to her room, leaving you here with the other three - something you're not very comfortable with.

"Matt, I got you buddy.." You say, your voice wavering a bit. "I dare you to cum inside Sarah's pussy in front of all of us" you call at the two of them as Sarah continues her teasing of his rock hard cock.

"Mmmmhh.. yeahh.." Sarah moans while turning her head to you. Her red hair is still frosted with half-dried ropes of Matt's cum, which along with the slight glimmer of sweat in her hair, gives her an impossibly slutty allure, turning you on even more.

"What a fantastic idea John" She purrs, winking at you and turning back to Matt.

"I'm on the pill stud, you want to glue my twat together with your cum?" Sarah aggressively demands of Matt.

Matt groans slightly and nods his head, clearly enjoying Sarah taking charge. The position they're in is perfect, so Sarah reaches back with one hand, pulling Matt's cock out from between them, rock hard and gleaming with Sarah's feminine lubricant. She aims Matt's tool and slides back onto it.

"Ohhhhhh.. yeah.. stud... hmm.. give it to--Ahh.. mee.." Sarah moans whorishly. She starts rocking herself back onto his length athletically as she starts ravishing Matt's lips against the couch he's pinned against with hers.

You turn to resume your seat as the dare begins, noticing Nicole still sitting on the other seat of your comfy couch. She's lying back against the cushions with both bare feet planted on the couch's seats either side of her body, her knees fully bent and her thighs spread as she pleasures herself - one hand rubbing her clit while the other sinks two fingers in and out of her dripping pussy in time with Sarah's fucking of Matt. You're startled by your formerly innocent childhood friend so openly advertising the fact her beautiful body is so aroused and lust-filled - her chest and breasts flushed red, her nipples rock hard, and her pussy swollen, red and wet from her own touch.

You stop to gawk at her for a moment, awkwardly standing there, before Nicole turns her gaze from Matt and Sarah to you, her fingers not pausing for a second.