Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 3 by thosearemysecret thosearemysecret

What did Lucy send?

Lucy riding Will

"What the fuck?" Jeff says as Will quickly grabs his phone and pockets it. "Will, what was that?"

"Nothing, bro, don't worry about it."

"That was Lucy naked on your lap. Please tell me she's fucking photoshopping you together out of spite."

Will is very quiet for a long moment. His phone chirps again. "Jeff, listen, it was an error in judgment the last time you told me you were going to break up with her."

Jeff takes another big swig and slams his glass down. He holds his hand out. "Give me your phone."

"You aren't thinking straight. It's better to let it go and talk about it in the future. Listen, you're free! That's what matters!"

"Phone. Now."

Will shakes his head and slips his phone out of his pocket. He glances down at it and whispers "oh fuck" before handing it to his friend. Jeff scrolls through the last couple of messages. In addition to Lucy riding him there's an image of Lucy with cum on her face. Underneath it reads "remember this? Get him to call me back or I'm sending it."

"How?"

Will rolls his eyes. "Seriously, you told me you were going to dump her. She could sense it and she came to see me. She threatened to tell Molly about the night at the strip club if I wasn't honest with her. So I told her you were going to dump her that weekend. And that's when she kissed me and told me she always wanted to fuck me and...dude, I thought you were going to dump her."

Jeff listens. Molly was Will's fiance at the time. One weekend Lucy, in one of her 'I need to be with you all the time moments' she prevented Jeff and Will from going to a ball game by offering to take them both to a strip club. Will was hesitant because Molly had made it very clear that he could never go to a strip club. Lucy changed his mind by promising to let him watch one of the strippers give him a lap dance. It was typical Lucy. Everything she did was to keep a tight leash around Jeff and, apparently, his friends. He was processing this revelation.

Will couldn't stand the silence. "Right, so I was caught up in the moment because you know, she's a great fuck, and I let her take those photos. After I unloaded on her face she started laughing. it was scary. She said 'this weekend you better convince Jeff to change his mind or else these photos are going to Molly.'"

"Oh my god," Jeff's jaw drop. "I completely forgot you talked me out of doing it. You showed up for brunch and literally told me I was making a mistake. I was so confused at the time..."

Will releases a long sigh. "I'm so sorry. I meant to tell you after I broke up with Molly, but..."

Jeff starts laughing. She was such a master manipulator. "She's such a psycho." he slaps Will on the shoulder. "And you're a betraying asshole but I get it. She fucked with my head for years, so whatever. Let's say you owe me for putting your dick in my personal pool of crazy."

"Here's to crazy," Will says raising a glass. He takes his phone back and writes back, 'go ahead, he already knows.'

"No! Don't engage!" Jeff says as Will hits send. It's too late. Seconds after the 'read' notice triggers Will's phone is vibrating in his hand. Jeff's CGF flashes on the screen.

Does he answer?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)