Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 35

Do they get interrupted? How far do they go?

Love in an elevator

Sophie felt her tongue wrestling with Dexter's as the latter hovered over her, both sets of hands awkwardly caressing each other's bodies as the two moaned into the kiss.

Dexter suddenly broke the kiss as he stared down into Sophie's face, the two panting heavily as their faces flushed. "W-what's your name, again?"

"S-Sophie."

"I'm Dexter." The young man said, clearing his throat. "Are... Are you sure you want to -"

"YES!" Sophie exclaimed. She then blushed a bit before clearing her throat and saying, "I mean, yeah. Yeah, I'm sure. Are you sure you want your first time to be with someone who looks like me?"

"Would I be giving you my first time if I didn't find you beautiful?"

Sophie wanted to laugh at the cheesy line, but she was too busy being shocked. Had Dexter just called her "beautiful"? Her?! Oh sure, Carol had called her beautiful countless of times before, but that was Carol. But this cute guy with his own insecurities calling her beautiful?

Sophie reached up and brought Dexter's head down to her own, kissing the young man again with an awkward yet fiery passion that the latter returned in kind. And with one thrust of his hips...

The young couple gasped in a mixture of shock and pleasure as Dexter's manhood hit it's mark, Sophie embracing the young man tightly as Dexter began to thrust into her wildly.

"Mmm... Yes." Sophie moaned as Dexter grunted, the former running her fingers through the latter's hair. "Make me feel wanted and loved. Just like we both deserve to be!"

"Sophie!" Dexter moaned into the young woman's neck, "Oh my... Oooh!"


A young woman in the lobby looked up from her phone as she saw the glass elevator walls begin to fog up, raising an eyebrow in confusion.


"Maybe this was a bad idea..." Carol said as she paced the room, looking up at the door.

"You think?" Karen asked sarcastically as she and Cindy sat on their bed, now dressed in towels after finally finishing their skunk bath.

"She should've been back by now." Carol said worriedly. "What if someone grabbed her? What if Margot grabbed her?! I'm going out to find her!"

"Carol?" Cindy asked as she watched the future woman race to the door.

"Yes?"

"Clothes?" Cindy said to the naked Carol, pointing to the clothes Carol had taken off earlier.

"Right..."


Back in the elevator, the naked couple were continuing their awkward yet passionate love making. The two were so caught up in their activity, that neither noticed the elevator come back to life, slowly ascending upwards as it continued it's journey.

"S-Sophie!" Dexter moaned, "I... I... I'm gonna..."

"I know! M-me too!"

"D-Do... Ah! Do y-you want me to pull out?!"

"N-no!" Sophie stammered, wrapping her legs around Dexter's waist. "P-Please don't!"

"B-but, what if I get you pregnant?!"

"You won't! I -" Sophie began, only to stop mid explanation. "What am I going to tell him? That in 2134, a group of scientists made it possible to allow women to choose when they became pregnant so they can have as much 'fun' with their significant others as they wanted without the risk of an accidental pregnancy?!" She thought to herself, "He'd laugh at me at best and think I'm insane at worst! Think, Sophie! Think! What would a woman of the 21st Century say in this situ- Wait! That's right!"

"I... I'm on t-the pill!" Sophie finally finished, coming up with a reasonable excuse. "Just please! Please don't pull out!"

Dexter nodded as he continued to thrust into Sophie. After a few more minutes, and unknowingly reaching the fifth floor, the couple screamed in ecstacy as Dexter blasted his load deep inside Sophie, the two shivering in pleasure as the former landed on top of the latter. The two panted heavily as they stared into each other's eyes with the biggest smiles on their faces.

Sophie actually felt pride in her body. If Dexter was willing to accept her for her and find her attractive - No, beautiful, then maybe... No! Not "maybe". She was beautiful!

Dexter felt the exact same way. A cute girl - No. A beautiful woman thought he was attractive, to the point that she would give herself to him. Perhaps there wasn't anything wrong with his body, after all. Not to mention, the only thing he and his brother had in common was that Frank also still had his virginity. So when his ass of a brother found out the 'wimpy nerd' got laid before him...

"I think I might love you..." Sophie and Dexter said simultaneously, kissing each other again with a gentle passion as Dexter's manhood stopped pumping her with his seed.

"Well, I didn't expect things to work out this good for you, Sophie."

With shocked and embarrassed faces, Sophie and Dexter turned their heads and looked up to see Carol in front of the open doors of the elevator, her eyes sparkling and a wide toothy grin on her face...

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)