Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 403 by Samus1001 Samus1001

What's next?

Live or let Die

"Where the fuck were you?!" Caleb barked at Lu as he held Kathy in his arms.

When he'd arrived and saw the shattered bay window and puddles of blood on his parent's lawn, he immediately thought back to the day Kathy was shot. The information he had was vague. All he knew was his Uncle Jake crashed their orgy and stuck his dick in Kathy.

Fearing the worst, he leaped out of the SUV before it came to a full stop. He stumbled briefly before righting himself and ran for his old front door.

He rushed inside, shoving people out of his way without regard for who they were. He was determined to reach the woman he loved by any means necessary.

Kathy sobbed with her head pressed hard against his chest. Even after the shower Mary and June **** her to take, she still felt unclean.

Lu couldn't meet his gaze as she stammered, "Your Holiness, I-"

"Don't fucking call me that!" Caleb angrily barked.

Lu flinched as if he struck her. Tears slid down her cheeks. She'd failed in the duty he'd given her. Through her negligence a man had violated her Queen's sacred garden.

Kathy sobbed, "It's not her fault. It's mine. I asked her to join us. I was making love to her and..."

"No baby girl." June interrupted. "I'm the one that convinced Lu to join the orgy. Caleb Sweetie, Lu tried to say no. I ordered her to do it. If you're going to be mad at anyone, it should be me."

Caleb felt their love hammering at him through the harem link. His mother was one of the few members of his harem that had learned to manipulate it like Kathy did. He gazed at her face, recognizing her emotional mask. His mother had a poker face a statue would envy, but also a volcanic temper. He'd seen her lose her temper many times in his nearly 19 years of life. She rarely ever got physical, but her voice could strip paint. She was also one of the most loving women he'd ever met. On the rare occasions that her temper was aimed his way, he never once questioned her love for him.

He looked beside June and saw Mary holding his mother's hand. Both of them flooding the harem link with their love. He could feel his anger being battered like waves on a beach. He could tell his mother was furious, but that anger wasn't aimed at him. By contrast, Mary looked afraid of what he might do. He was a little afraid himself.

Finally he sighed. "Fine. Lu, I don't blame you for what happened."

He kissed the top of Kathy's head and sighed, "I don't blame you either Kat."

His girlfriend squeezed him tighter, her sobs quieting a bit.

Looking around he saw that the room was filled with Lotus Sisters, heavily armed as usual. His father's girlfriends were also present but being quiet and shying away from the center of the room where Caleb stood. In the old reality he'd only met Cindy previously. He didn't spend much time looking at his father's girlfriends now. Like Kathy, they wore robes, but he could see hints of the lingerie they wore under them.

I shouldn't be mad at Lu, or anyone else either. This is all my damn fault. If I had just gone ahead and created a normality for Cindy, none of this would have happened. But Mom's plan to train Cindy's cunt sounded sexy as hell. When I found out Cindy wanted me to pump a baby in her, I let my dick think for me. Again. Hell, I didn't even think when I created the normalities that protect my family. I made Kat and the core harem fucking bulletproof, yet I didn't think to prevent someone sticking their dick in her. I didn't think anyone would be dumb enough to try assaulting her. She's a fucking Harem Queen. Just grabbing her tits could earn a man a **** sentence.

Now that I think about it, what the fuck do I do about Uncle Jake? If I do nothing, the Lotus Sisters WILL kill him. But do I even care? He put his dick in my woman. Kathy is MINE! She's a fucking goddess and he made her cry. I'm so mad I could kill him myself. And yet all the bad shit that has happened is all my own damn fault. I created this wonky ass reality. I need to do better at protecting my women. All of my women. As soon as I'm alone I'm gonna-

The sound of a familiar voice as she pushed her way into the house yanked Caleb out of his thoughts. He turned to her and held out an arm, "Chris, get over here!"

To the Lotus Sisters standing in the way he shouted, "Clear a fucking path!"

Chris rushed forward and collided with him and Kathy, her strong muscular arms squeezing tightly around them. Kathy's sobs renewed as she became enveloped in their arms.

But Chris wasn't content to simply hold Kathy. She tilted Kathy's head up and kissed her lightly on the lips. If Caleb wasn't so angry the sight of the two beauties lovingly kissing would have given him a boner. Caleb loved watching two women together. Seeing Kathy and Chris kiss immediately put naughty thoughts in his head, forcing him to struggle to get such dirty thoughts out of his head.

Eventually their loving kiss ended and Chris whispered, "You're safe now Kat."

Kathy buried her face in Chris's tits and sobbed some more. Chris looked over at Lu and growled, "Where the fuck were you?"

June was the one that answered. It took time, but eventually the details of what occurred became known. Through the entire story Kathy kept her face pressed against Chris's big marshmallow squishy boobs.

"I'll fucking kill him. Where is he?" Chris whispered at the end of June's tale.

Caleb had seen Chris mad before. Over the years he'd seen her get in trouble for fighting. She was fiercely protective of the other Denizens, and had the skill to punish the bullies when they went too far. But the way she spoke sent a chill up his spine.

Caleb tightened his arm around her and said, "No, you won't. I can't let you do that for the same reason Mom didn't let Kathy do it. You're not a killer, and it would break our woman's heart if you became one because of her."

Chris opened her mouth to argue, but the reminder that Kathy was both their woman silenced her. Kathy squeezing her arms even tighter around her only reinforced the point. She may be my girlfriend, but Kathy belongs to Caleb. I'm lucky that he even took me into his harem. He didn't have to. Kathy's been falling in love with him since they met four years ago. She was the one that asked him to claim me. He wouldn't have if not for her. Oh sure, I knew he was attracted to me. I may be muscular, but I've got a pretty face and a killer body. And Caleb is a tit man. I've definitely got boobs big enough to draw his eye. But she's the reason I get to be with both of them.

Chris nodded at him and said, "So what do you want to do?"

"Right now, I want you to take Kat to my old bedroom and cuddle her." Caleb said. He gave them both a kiss and watched as Kathy was led from the room.

The room remained silent until Kathy was safely out of earshot.

"I can deal with him, if you'd like, Your Holiness."

Caleb looked over at the speaker. Mother Monose was the commander of the Lotus Sisters. He knew they were more than bodyguards. They were also assassins. Killing the enemies of Stretcher Kings was something they looked forward to.

"You'll kill him is what you mean." Mary said matter-of-factly. Turning to Caleb she pleaded, "You can't let them do that. His blood would be on Kathy's hands. Please. He needs to be punished for what he did, but jail, not a **** sentence. He couldn't possible have known who Kathy was when he..."

Caleb sighed when Mary couldn't finish her sentence. "Don't be naïve Mary. I know what you're thinking. But his **** wouldn't be Kathy's fault. He chose to crash your orgy. He chose to stick his dick in your daughter, without her consent. Do you really think he would survive prison? Remember what happened to Sharon Wallace? The woman that shot Kathy? My uncle is a dead man. The only thing that matters is how he dies."

Seeing her daughter nearly beat Jake to **** had frightened and horrified Mary. Kathy used several different schools of magic to punish him, none of them shadow magic. Her power has grown far beyond anything I thought possible. My baby girl didn't use a single incantation, rune, or spell circle as she attacked Jake. She'd simply called out the names of each spell as she cast them, to brutal effect. I'm worried about her. I can't let that man die or Kathy might blame herself for his ****. Or worse, she may lose her respect for life. Next time something like this happens, she could actually kill someone, and not care that she did. Please Caleb, you can't let that happen.

Mary tried one last time to prevent Jake's ****, worried about what effect it would have on her daughter's mental state. "But he's your uncle. He is family. Doesn't that mean something? Your aunt Susan is staying in your mansion. What is she gonna say?"

Caleb jerked. SHIT! Aunt Susan! I forgot all about her. What the hell do I tell her? I was going to breed her as soon as we got home. I wanted to fuck her brains out in a threesome with Kat. Hell, I was even thinking of creating a normality for her like the one Kathy wanted, where I decide what shape her saggy tits took. Only I was just going to make them even bigger. Susan would look incredible with tits Kathy's size. Huge plump squishy jiggly marshmallow tits. And now I have to tell her that her husband is going to die. Unless I create a normality to prevent it. And right now, I can't think of a single way to do that. I certainly can't do it in front of all these people. These are Lotus Sisters. They are fucking assassins for crying out loud. Damn it Mary! What would you have me do?

He glanced at Monose then at the Lotus Sisters nearby. Finally he looked back at Mary. "I'm sorry Mary. Really, I am. I don't want him to die, but there is literally nothing I can do. The Lotus Sisters aren't going to let him live. Look around you. Not one of them agrees with you. Even if I begged them not to, he would only survive long enough for them to find a way to make his **** look like an accident. And that's if he even survives that long. It wasn't the Lotus Sisters that killed Deanna's mom."

Monose nodded, "The Stretcher King is right. Even if I agreed with you, my sisters would not obey me on this. Your daughter is wildly popular among them. Thanks to her, the ones stationed at the mansion get to eat Stretcher King cum with every meal. His Holiness has bred at least one every day since they entered his service, at your daughter's insistence. Allowing a man that violated her body to live would be anathema to them. He has sinned against a Stretcher King, and for my sisters, the punishment for that is ****."

Mary glared at Monose. "Aren't you supposed to be submitting yourself to Caleb for punishment? You sinned against him as well, didn't you?"

June nudged Mary, her emotional mask cracking. "What Monose did isn't the same. Jake **** our daughter. I don't give a shit that he was only in her for a second. **** is still **** Mary."

Mary released June's hand and muttered, "You too?"

June sighed, "Mary... Kathy has been shot, and three of our daughters have now been ****. You do remember Gemma and Heather, right? They're our daughters now too. I am sick and tired of our family suffering through shit like this. If the Lotus Sisters don't kill my fucking ex brother-in-law, I fucking will. Maybe if word gets around, people will stop trying to violate our children."

April had been quiet through the entire discussion. She stepped forward and put her hand on Mary's shoulder. "Mary. You can't save him. I know why you're doing it. You don't want this to affect Kathy. I sympathize with you. We all want Kathy to keep being the kind and loving person we fell in love with. But your daughter is an adult. And so is Jake. However... There is one thing we can do."

Looking over at Monose, April said, "We can lie. We tell Kathy that Caleb's uncle has been locked up. She isn't going to check on him. Victims rarely do. And we don't need to know the details of how he died. That remains a secret from everyone. You order your Lotus Sisters to keep their mouths shut about this. No one breaths a word."

After Monose nodded, April looked over at Harold's girlfriends. The looks on their faces ranged from horror to fear. "Got it?" April barked.

Cindy looked at her lovers, then back at April. "We won't say anything. Even though Caleb hasn't married her yet, Kathy is our family too. If not for her and her harem effect, I might not have had the strength to resist my attraction to Caleb. And it's thanks to her that Caleb can give us the babies we want and we can still remain loyal to Harold."

"What the fuck happened here?"

Caleb spun around as he heard a masculine voice coming from the foyer. "Dad!"


Thank you for reading. Please leave a comment if there is something you would like to see. If you loved the story please consider buying me a cup of coffee at https://ko-fi.com/samus1001

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)