Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)
Chapter 404
by
Samus1001
What's next?
Dad wants a word
Harold sighed as he processed the details of what happened. He could tell his ex-wife was ready to kill, though her mask hid her raging temper from those that did not know her well. His son was equally angry, and couldn't hide it from anyone. Finally at the end of their tale Harold asked, "Where is Kathy now?"
"I asked Chris to take her to my old bedroom and cuddle her." Caleb informed his father. His fists were clenched tightly, and he had to struggle to open them.
Harold put his hand on his son's shoulder and gave it a squeeze before looking around the room. Then he moved to sit in his recliner. "Sit down son. You need to calm down before you drive yourself crazy. And we need to talk about what happens next." He waved away Cindy when she went to sit on his lap.
"Come on girls. Let's go to the kitchen and leave the men alone." June said to Harold's girlfriends.
Harold held up his hand. "Stay June, you too Mary. It might be better if you both heard what I have to say."
As his girlfriends left the room, Harold looked at April then the Lotus Sister commander that he'd met just a few minutes before and said, "You two stay as well."
Monose waved her hand and the other Lotus Sisters filed out of the room in silence. Meanwhile Mary and June sat on the couch with Caleb between them.
Harold leaned forward and rested his chin on his interlaced fingers. It was a position his family knew well. He was organizing his thoughts before speaking. Caleb prepared himself for a long conversation. His father had taken several psychology courses in college and used that knowledge everyday in his job. It made him an excellent sales representative, and more than once he'd used that knowledge on his family as well, though it made for long lectures.
After a moment Harold raised his head and looked directly at Caleb. "Son, being a Harem Queen hasn't been easy for Kathy. In fact, it's been a lot harder than she lets on. This thing with Jake just made everything worse. April was right though. Kathy can't know what happens to him. But you need to understand what she's going through. I'm pretty sure she is not telling you everything, and you're still a young man yourself."
Caleb nodded, but then said, "I know it hasn't been easy for her, but we've talked through a lot. She knows she can come to me with any problems."
Caleb was thinking back to the day she was shot, and later the conversation in the bomb shelter when she figured out about the watch. Kathy, his mother, and his aunt Lori had all reassured him about his normalities, and talked among themselves often.
June added, "Kathy knows she can come to us with anything she needs. That's why we created the Moms club. All the girls are our daughters now."
Harold huffed, "No doubt that helps. Even so, Kathy still doesn't tell you everything that she's going through. And the reason I know that is because she's been asking my advice ever since she became Caleb's girlfriend. Remember when she came to us about her jealousy?"
He turned to Caleb and explained, "We talked her through it. And ever since that day she's been texting me whenever she needs someone to talk to. Someone that can understand, and no one in your harem can do that for her.
Mary blurted, "Why is she going to you and not me? I'm her mother!"
"The Harem Effect." Harold flatly stated. "She can't talk to you about some things without it coloring your desires. No one in either harem can give her advice on how she feels. Not without it changing that person. I'm in a unique position to advise her because her harem effect doesn't work on men, and we share a common interest that, at the time, no one else had."
Harold's tone turned sorrowful as he added, "I do owe you an apology Mary. After Mark ran off to god knows where, I felt Kathy needed a father figure in her life, and I stepped in to the role. I should have asked you, and I am sorry for not doing so. Kathy didn't want anyone knowing that she needed someone to talk to, so I kept that from all of you."
Looking back at his son he continued, "Your mom told me she informed you about my cuckold fetish. That said, she's never fully understood it. In a nutshell, I love watching my women have sex with other men, and then reclaiming them as mine. Over the years I've watched your grandma have sex with dozens of men, and Pamela and Vivian have indulged me as well. You were the only man I've ever watched your mother have sex with, and that threesome we had was the one and only time she's ever been with two men at once."
June squeezed her son's hand to keep him from speaking. Caleb had no memory of the threesome Harold was talking about. She spoke before he could. "That was the last time your father and I had sex. I felt terrible after we were done, especially since you've never been in my ass, and your father came up my butt that night. I felt like I was cheating on you."
Harold smiled at his ex-wife. "I felt bad too dear. I could see in your eyes you weren't enjoying yourself as much as I'd hoped. Your heart already belonged to our boy, but that night I saw your body did as well."
Back to Caleb he said, "That's one of the reasons why your mom and I stopped having sex. She can't enjoy herself with other men anymore, not even me. It was nice of you to let us continue to be together, but your mother fell in love with you, especially after you put a baby in her belly. But that leads me back to Kathy. Kathy is what is called a cuckquean. It's the female version of a cuckold. That first night I gave her advice, she had been struggling with her jealousy."
Caleb blurted, "If she was jealous she could have said something to me. I love her. I would have stopped being with other women."
With a start Caleb realized what he said was true. Kathy was everything he wanted in a woman, and her happiness was most important to him. If she wanted, he'd use his magic watch to change everything and the two of them be together and alone.
Harold half chuckled half grunted, "Son, shut up and let me talk. Kathy doesn't want it to be just the two of you. She's never wanted that. You see, back when all this began, Kathy had only been your girlfriend for a few months. All of your other girlfriends were women she knew and was already close to. She loved sharing you with them, and she loved them just as much as she did you."
Caleb nearly jumped at the realization that his father was talking about a past Caleb never experienced. His aunt Lori had told him some details, like the fact that he began dating Kathy, Angie, Chris, and Gabbie before he became a Stretcher King. The baby bump his mother sported, and the wedding ring on her finger drove home those changes. He was married to his mother, and impregnated her shortly after becoming her owner.
Harold was still speaking and Caleb refocused on his words. "-just as new to all this Stretcher King stuff as you were. She loves you deeply, but she also has had to watch you heal and breed dozens of women. Hundreds now. Women she didn't know or love. Keep in mind she is very young, and she was a bullied girl that had very low self esteem. So she was jealous, but your mom and I talked her through it."
He smiled briefly at June before returning his attention to his son. "She still gets jealous, but now she doesn't let it bother her. She knows if she asked you, you'd never touch another woman, even your mother. But she never will. Like me with your mother and my girlfriends, Kathy truly enjoys the fact that you have sex with multiple lovers. And that's because she's managed to turn her jealousy into something else. Every time you give a girl a belly bulge, every time you have sex with a tall woman, or one with small breasts, every time you fuck someone in the butt, or hold them up and fuck them in the air, she finds immense pleasure in it. That is the essence of cuckoldry. How much you enjoy other women is directly related to how happy it makes her. You get to do those things because she encourages it. She wants you to be happy because she loves you."
He smiled at Mary and said to her, "You may have noticed that no one in either harem ever gets jealous of how much time Caleb spends with anyone over anyone else. That's Kathy's doing. She's made her Harem Effect work for her. She uses her harem effect to make all of you love each other. At my encouragement, she's used her ability to turn you all into a very tight knit family. Aside from June and Hazel, none of you are ever allowed to feel any jealousy towards anyone in either harem, for any reason. She lets June feel it because June shares in the pleasure her jealousy brings her, enjoying her jealousy just like Kathy does. And Hazel gets jealous because she's immune to Kathy's Harem Effect."
Monose had been silently standing beside April against the wall, paying close attention to every word. She took a small step and exclaimed, "What? No woman is immune to the Harem Effect! Not even a Harem Queen can prevent herself from being changed by it."
Harold had nearly forgotten the old woman was in the room. "My daughter hasn't changed at all. None of her wants and desires have been affected by Kathy, or anyone else in my son's harem. I don't know why, and it doesn't matter for this conversation. Hazel is still the same woman she was when my son took her virginity on their birthday. She still gets just as jealous as she did before any of the crazy Stretcher King stuff began. But like Kathy, she's turned her jealousy into pleasure."
He looked back at Caleb and said, "Your sister has been falling in love with you since you took ownership of your mother, maybe even before that. It was sweet of you to include her in your relationship, but she's always felt a little left out. She's had to watch you take woman after woman as your girlfriends and she can't be one. After you started dating your mom, you began dating Kathy, then Angie, Gabbie, Megumi, and even Chris all got to be your girlfriends. And yet, even though you were making love to her, Hazel couldn't date you. Then you got your mom pregnant, and then married her. That was all very rough on Hazel."
Caleb nodded along, aware that his father was talking about events that must have occurred after his latest normalities. He felt bad that he'd not considered his sister in any of the changes he'd made. "I had no idea she's been having it so rough. She hasn't said anything to me."
"It got a bit worse before it got better. I don't know if you know, but Hazel and Katie got into a fight the day you claimed Katie. Your sister got insanely jealous and worried that this time she would lose you. You were a Stretcher King now, and began building your harem. But like with Kathy, Hazel has turned that around. It helped that all of your girlfriends loved her, and made love to her too. She loves being owned by you, even if she's not in your harem. And she has her own girlfriend now, so it's not all bad. I admit I was a little afraid Tina wasn't going to be a good role model for her, but that turned out pretty well."
Monose interrupted to ask, "Excuse me, but how do you know Hazel isn't affected by Kathy's Harem Effect? How can you be sure?"
Harold snorted a laugh, "I'm sure because Hazel is still able to give me blowjobs and drink my cum. No one in Caleb's harem can do that with any man but him, and Kathy's harem are all steadily losing their desire for other men. All except Hazel and Tina. Hazel has given me a blowjob every time she visits, and her fiancée Tina is still able to have sex with me. Again, I've no idea how or why, but it's true. Kathy thinks it's because Hazel has an affinity for love magic, but even she isn't sure."
Caleb wondered at that. He'd never made a normality specifically for either woman. He didn't mind Tina and his dad having sex. Hazel had been okay with it the first time it happened in the original reality, and he remembered that Hazel had also eaten their father's cum out of Cindy's pussy. Blowing him wasn't that far off from eating his cum out of another woman, especially his dad's girlfriend. As far as he knew, his dad had never had sex with Hazel, but her sucking his dick must be something that began to occur during one of the latest reality shifts.
Ever since the day he took her virginity in the original reality, Caleb considered his sister his property. The thought of any other guy putting their dick in her pussy instantly angered him, much like it did when Jake did it to Kathy. But for some reason the mental image of Hazel sucking their dad's dick did not. Thinking about it he realized that he got a naughty thrill out of the idea. The taboo nature of the act was deliciously dirty.
While he was lost in thought June angrily demanded, "Why are you still having sex with Tina? She's not on birth control, and our son is supposed to be the one that breeds her! And she belongs to Kathy!"
Harold quickly threw up his hands and explained, "Whoa honey! Hazel and Kathy are okay with it. You know I wouldn't touch her if they weren't. And I'm only doing her in the butt. Tina loves anal sex, and Caleb isn't doing here there. Besides, I'm a lot smaller than he is, so it's easier for her to take it."
Caleb began to laugh, which drew every eye to look at him. He was still chuckling as he said, "Tina is Hazel's woman. If she's okay with Dad plowing Tina's ass, you should be too Mom. Although, fair warning Dad, anal sex is starting to grow on me. I did one of my teachers in the butt today, and it was pretty damn good. I might have to give Tina another shot, and Angie told me she'd let me take her there too. Oh, and Chris and I have deal where I get to fuck her ass too, if I want."
June anger rapidly faded at her son's words. Then she giggled, "Okay Sweetie. Just let me or Sonia make sure they are ready for you before you do it. I might even let you in my ass, as a special treat for my new husband."
Caleb felt himself hardening at the mental picture of his women lined up on a couch with their asses pointed at him while he moved from one to the next, plundering their rears.
Caleb shook himself out of his thoughts when his father turned back to him and spoke. "We've gotten way off track. Now, I brought up cuckoldry so you'd understand one of Kathy fetishes. It's a lot like mine, so naturally we can talk about it and understand each other better than anyone else. But Kathy has other fetishes that I don't have, and the two of us have talked about those as well."
Caleb nodded. "I know a few of those. She's really into breastfeeding."
Harold chuckled, "Heh, I don't know that I'd call that a fetish. Most women are into feeding each other their milk, and a lot of guys are into drinking it too. You're probably too young to remember, but your mom breastfed me till you and Hazel were in first grade."
June giggled, "Your dad loved getting handjobs while suckling my tits. And your aunt Lori and I would drain each other everyday before we made love when we were pregnant with you kids." That was another new change to reality, one that June enjoyed immensely. Lori told her she'd been feeding Caleb's girlfriends since the second week of her current pregnancy.
Mary added, "Mark and his wives drank my milk from just after I got pregnant with Cora till Kathy was about seven or eight years old. It's a fairly common practice Caleb. It's not always sexual, but it isn't rare either."
Harold regained his son's attention and said, "The fetishes I'm referring to revolve mostly around you. You see, Kathy has visited some of the wilder sides of the internet, and as a result she's into some of the rarer fetishes. As a dairy herd bull, you've seen how hucows love to be restrained and milked during sex. That's not a natural desire for normies. But Kathy loves hucows, and there was a time that she hoped she was one."
Caleb nodded. He remembered Mary mentioning that once before.
Harold continued, "Then there is also Melissa. She wants to be tied up and dominated, especially by you. She wants you to have your way with her, any way you want. You can even hurt her and it will bring her joy. She loves being degraded and humiliated. Kathy also told me most of your harem loves to be spanked and fucked roughly. And Kathy wants all of those things too. Anything you do to her will bring her pleasure so long as it brings you pleasure too."
"Not exactly. Kat said she doesn't ever want me to try anal with her." Caleb interjected.
Harold shook his head. "That may be so, but if you demanded it, she'd do it. She would do anything to please you. Another fetish she is into is sexual slavery. She told me about her plan for your principal. The idea of bringing a woman to you, naked, crawling, and on a leash, is a huge turn on for her. Her favorite porno has a woman doing exactly that for the male actor. Bringing women to you, giving them as gifts for you to fuck and breed, is something she thinks about every day. But she also wants you to do that to her as well. If you put her on a leash, and treated her like a pet, she'd probably orgasm on the spot. When she says she belongs to you, she means it with every fiber of her being. Heart, body, mind, and soul."
Caleb bit his lip and nodded. Kathy sometimes went overboard in an effort to please him. Her antics at the service party were still fresh in his mind. He also recalled her disappointment when she fisted two of the teachers at school earlier that day and he'd been unenthusiastic about doing it himself.
Harold waited a few moments to allow his son to process what he'd learned, then said, "The reason I'm telling you this is because you need to fully understand what just happened to her. Jake didn't just violate her body. He broke a fundamental part of her self image. She is your queen, and another man has been inside her. Right now, she feels worse than dirty. I'd bet my left nut that is the reason why she beat the crap out of Jake. It wasn't because of what he did to her. Rather, it's how she fears you'll now see her. She was a virgin when you started dating her. You are the only man she's ever felt comfortable around. The only man that she's ever wanted to give herself to. She desperately wants to be the perfect woman in your eyes. And right now, she thinks Jake took that away."
"So what do I do? How do I fix this?" Caleb mumbled. He was thinking of his watch. He'd changed the past before, he could do it again.
Harold sat forward again and said, "Once again I'm going to remind you of my cuckold fetish. For a cuckold like me, it's not just seeing my girlfriends cumming on another man's cock that brings me pleasure. It's also the knowledge that those women are mine, and they return to me. They chose to be with me. That no matter how many men they are with, I am the one that they love."
June put her hand on her son's thigh. "Sweetie, that's the real reason your father and I stopped having sex. I don't belong to him anymore. Oh, he still enjoys hearing about you fucking me. But I belong to you. You are my husband now. You are the man I want to give myself to, forever. Your father understood what it would mean when you became my owner, and he is very happy for us."
Harold smiled and nodded at his ex-wife. "Son. Right now Kathy is feeling like she's been set adrift, and it isn't helping that you're out here and not in your old room with her. What you need to do is go and reclaim your woman. Remind her who owns her. Remind her that you love her. Call her degrading names too. She wants you to do it. But call her things like YOUR slut, and YOUR whore. She needs to hear that she belongs to you and no one else. And fuck her as rough as you like. But above all else, make sure you tell her you love her, and show her. When you reclaim her, she needs to feel your anger, not at her, but at the fact that someone else dared to touch her. She needs to know that you don't blame her, and that no one else is allowed to touch her. That everything she is and everything she has is yours, including her love."
"What about Chris? She's Kathy's girlfriend. And Chloe? They just started dating. Kathy loves her too. She loves every woman in our harems."
Harold barked a laugh. "So? None of that matters to her, or anyone else. Chris and Chloe are women. Don't tell me you actually care if Kathy is in love with other women, because you'd be in a very small minority. Only a super controlling asshole like your uncle Jeff gives two shits about stuff like that."
Caleb grinned, having forgotten that he created a normality that made it so that lesbian sex wasn't considered cheating. "No Dad, what I meant was if I reclaim Kathy like you're suggesting, what becomes of them? If Kathy is mine and mine alone, does that mean Chris can't be her girlfriend anymore?"
Harold pursed his lips and thought a moment before answering. "Okay then... What you need to do is tell her she gets to keep Chris and Chloe, but only because you allow it. Actually, that might make her feel better faster. Chris is here now. Go reclaim Kathy, but order her to be Chris's girlfriend. And Chloe's. And the rest of your harem. Order her around. She loves it when you do. And when you're done, assert your authority with the rest of the harem as well. Order them around too. They all love it because Kathy does."
June patted Caleb on the thigh and said, "He's right honey. Remember the other day when you ordered me and your aunt Lori lick your cum up off the floor? I was so turned on I nearly burst into flames. You need to order us around more, especially sexually. Make us put on shows for you. We know you love it, and we do too."
Mary had an evil grin on her lips as she cackled, "And you can start with Mother Monose. She needs to be punished for invading your privacy. Punish her in front of Kathy and the harem, or better yet, do it where the other Lotus Sisters can see you."
Caleb looked from Mary to the Lotus Mother. He gulped in fear, afraid of how she would react to Mary's words. But Monose gave him a slight nod and a tiny smile.
Thank you for reading. Please leave a comment if there is something you would like to see. If you loved the story please consider buying me a cup of coffee at https://ko-fi.com/samus1001
What's next?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)
The Normality Dial
Changing reality with a word
This story is based off a branch of Murakami's Normality found here. https://chyoa.com/chapter/Introduction.174576 In this story, our hero Caleb Anders, finds a watch that allows him to change reality, with certain rules based on the time the watch is set at. A special thanks to BiBiComte and CrossC for allowing me to reprint their own chapters here. I have credited them for each of their chapters at the start of those chapters. I may have made a few minor changes and grammatical corrections, though I am by no means perfect myself.
Updated on Jun 11, 2026
by Samus1001
Created on Jul 20, 2025
by Samus1001
- All Comments
- Chapter Comments