Lily invited her boyfriend’s old bully to a surprise threesome. What’s the worst that could happen?

Lily

“Mmm, the look on Craig’s face when he sees you, girl,” Lily giggled while putting the finishing touches on Red’s makeup.

“This eyeliner is going to make those pretty green eyes just pop. I softened the jaw as much as I could with contouring, but the eyes, the curled hair, the cleavage. It all screams woman.”

“If that screams ‘woman,’ I wonder what my dick is screaming,” Red sighed.

“Shush now,” Lily commanded, firmly holding Red’s chin as she applied lipstick, adding volume to her lips.

“Nobody's perfect,” Lily said, making some last second adjustments to Red’s dress. Her breasts needed to be pushed up to make the cleavage look just right. “It’s tucked, and by the time we’re done with the double blow job, he’ll be too impressed by your throat skills to complain. When the time comes, you can bend over so he doesn’t even need to see it.”

Red looked concerned, but didn’t say anything.

Poor girl, still trying to put all her maleness behind her. I’ve done my part erasing any trace of Hank in her appearance, the rest is up to her.

Lily jumped at the knock at the door. She took one last look at her own outfit, a matching slinky cocktail dress. It plunged low to show cleavage, had a slit up the side to reveal thigh, and everywhere else, it clung like a second skin. Hers was ivory to Red’s crimson, and as a pair, they looked devastating.

“Now, just wait for my signal,” she whispered and stepped into her dorm room, closing the bathroom door behind her.

The mood had been set, flickering candles provided ambiance and a light misting of perfume accentuated the warm, feminine space. Lily opened the door to find Craig fiddling with his tie.

He had dressed up himself, wearing a white dress shirt, black dress pants, and a navy blazer. The red tie was a bit much, but overall, Lily thought he looked dashing and appreciated the effort.

“You look spectacular, Angel. What’s the occasion? Don’t tell me I missed an anniversary already,” Craig joked with a smirk.

He has no idea! Lily gushed internally.

“Just something that I’ve had simmering for a while,” she said cryptically.

“That’s a real fancy look. Are we going out to eat or something?”

“No, we’ll be staying in. I just wanted to show off before you tear this dress off me.” Lily pressed her body against his but flitted away before he could put his arms around her.

“Oh, I can’t wait anymore. There’s someone I want you to meet,” Lily squealed, giddy with excitement.

“It’s my honor to introduce the all-new Red!”

The bathroom door opened, revealing Red in all her dressed up glory. She stepped awkwardly in the tight dress and heels, but her face was lit up by a small, hopeful smile.

“It’s me,” she managed to croak out, blushing.

“What’s going on here?” Craig asked, a look of bewilderment on his face. “What is this?”

“It’s your surprise!” Lily answered, her words cascading out of her. “She’s come so far and now she’s ready to lose her virginity! I’ve seen the way you look at her and I knew you’d be the perfect person to be her first. So tonight we’re going to make your dreams come true. You get to have a threesome with two gorgeous twins!”

Craig didn’t respond immediately, he just furrowed his brow in thought.

“You want to have sex with Red?” He asked quietly.

“Who wouldn’t?” Lily asked, trying to keep the mood light.

These two aren’t as excited as I thought they would be. Looks like I’ll have to do the heavy lifting to get this started.

Lily walked over to Red and possessively put a hand on her hip. “Just look how hot she is. She didn’t want you to know, but she’s been aching for sex for weeks. She’s been saving up all that energy and frustration for you, I just gift wrapped her.”

“So this is for me?”

“Yes, this is for you. And for all of us.”

“Lily, if this was for me, you would have told me about it first.”

“But then it wouldn’t be a surprise, silly!”

Lily’s smile faltered at Craig’s expression which was turning into a glower. She turned to Red for support, but her eyes were downcast.

“What’s going on here? This was supposed to be fun and sexy, like the costumes.”

“I don’t think that was as fun as you remember,” Craig replied.

“It was actually kinda stressful,” Red chimed in.

“But this was all for you two.”

Craig sighed. “I’m sure you think that, but the truth is that you’ve been doing all this for yourself.”

“That’s ridiculous,” Lily scoffed. “Red needs this. You both want each other. The only thing stopping you two from being together is the fear I’ll be jealous. But I’m not. I love you both.”

“So you love her now? I see what’s going on. You want to be with her and this is your way to trick me into it,” Craig accused.

“Trick you? This was to fulfill your fantasy. Why would I want to be with Red? We’re both girls,” Lily insisted.

Red groaned and rolled her eyes.

“For fuck’s sake, Lily. You’re feeling me up right now!”

Lily’s hand jerked off Red’s hip like it was a hot stove.

“That wasn’t… I mean… I was just showing you off to Craig,” Lily tried to explain, getting flustered.

“Even when it’s just the two of us, you can’t keep your hands off me,” Red explained gently.

“Lily, I want to be clear,” Craig added, “I’m not mad about your sexuality. Lots of people experiment when they get to college.”

“Guys! I’m not gay,” Lily asserted, trying to laugh it off.

Craig and Red shared an incredulous look.

“Look,” Craig continued, “we’ve established that you're attracted to Red. Red’s a girl. I’m not saying you’re gay. You’re bisexual.”

Lily’s cheeks burned. “I’m not bi… am I?” She felt light-headed and staggered sideways, only for Red to catch her. Red gave her an empathetic smile.

“Sorry you had to find out this way,” Red said, soothingly. “It’ll be okay. I’m sure there are plenty more of us around.”

“Us?”

“I’m bi too.”

But if she likes girls, and I like girls, and we’re both girls… Then all those things we did together…

Lily’s head swam. It was all so much.

“Not to downplay your revelation, but that’s not the issue right now,” Craig continued. “Ever since Red came into our lives, you’ve been spending all your time with her. You two share clothes, you talk to her about me, you’ve been keeping secrets. Hell, you even have inside jokes now.” The muscles of his jaw stood tense and his hands were clenched shut.

“No, she needed me, it wasn’t about you,” Lily tried to explain.

“I guess it never was,” Craig continued, his visage darkening. “All you’ve wanted me for is sex.”

“But that’s all you want when we’re together.”

“Stop telling me what I want!” Craig yelled.

Lily stepped back and brought her hands up as if to shield herself from the **** of Craig’s words. She collided with Red, whose body was tense as a board.

“Ever since you transformed, you’ve been acting different. Whatever you want, you take it. You don’t let anyone stop you. Not even the people you say you love.”

Craig’s cheeks were flushed and a vein was rising on his forehead. He was breathing hard and struggling to contain his emotion.

“I knew you would end up with someone else eventually. You’d figure out you can do better than the lanky loser you knew from high school. But I never imagined it would be her. Even your new girlfriend is manlier than me. I guess Hank was right. She can lift more, I even bet she has a bigger dick. If she can give you that and be your best friend and your new twin sister; what do you need me for at all?”

Craig’s face was scrunched up now. He wouldn’t be able to hold back the tears for much longer. He loosened his tie and unbuttoned his shirt to pull out the shell that still hung on a string around his neck. He dramatically pulled the string over his head and held the shell out between them.

“Craig, don’t,” Red begged. “I never should have come between you. I’ll go. You'll never see me again.”

“Don’t bother. We’re done. I hope you’re happy together.”

Craig opened his hand, dropping the shell. Before it hit the ground, he had turned to leave the room.

Lily let out a wordless wail of despair, but it was only met with the click of the door closing behind Craig. She staggered forward to chase after him, only for Red to slump to the ground. Lily hadn’t realized that Red was holding onto her just to remain standing. Red’s tears were tracking eyeliner down her cheeks.

“I did it again,” Red muttered, her breath ragged. “It wasn’t Hank, it was me the whole time. I’m the fuck up. I ruin everything.”

Lily was frozen. She felt pulled between the now hyperventilating Red and the rapidly escaping Craig.

I thought I could have it all. Now I have nothing. Can I only pick one? Red needs me, but I need Craig.

“This is my fault, Red. Not yours,” Lily insisted while changing out of her heels and into Red’s running shoes. “I’ll be back.”

Lily exploded into the hallway, but Craig was gone. Undeterred, she ran out onto the street in the direction of Craig’s dorm room.

The seashell lay forgotten, gleaming in the candlelight.