Let the chaos take over

Between Grace now having to take a punishment and Rebecca’s hand now moving further down your body, you felt the need to just sit back and enjoy whatever was about to happen without lifting a finger, wanting to see what would happen if you didn’t intervene.

Rebecca’s hand reached your crotch, only to discover that someone had already beat her to it. She didn’t even think to see who it could have been as she lifted her hands in a moment of panic, meeting the same fate that Grace had just met moments ago. This time however she failed two tasks at once.

“Ah!” she said in her surprise, her hands held up in the air as embarrassment overtook her, eyes now focusing away from Grace and onto her.

You felt Lucy’s hand flinch and she would have likely pulled away if her fingers hadn’t already been wrapped around your shaft. You saw the reaction on her face though, her eyes widened and she tensed quickly realising from Rebecca’s reaction that she was the one to also try to help you out.

“Ah sorry I… Max I…” Rebecca mumbled, trying to come up with an excuse for her outburst and looking to you for help.

Even with her panic, you were sure she was able to get a good look at your crotch to see that Lucy was the one to already be stroking you. Making the two of them now that they had both been caught.

“Sorry I tried to tease you but… well I guess it worked out in my favour” you said with a grin, motioning to her hands no longer touching you or Lucy.

And even with all this, Grace was the one to still be in between making a decision, giving you a chance to address the room.

“So surprisingly that’s two of you out. Grace you still have to take one and Rebecca, that’s two for you” you announced, feeling happy with how things had worked out.

The two gave each other a look while their cheeks were flushed red but you could tell their shared loss was something to help them both out.

“Looks like we’re both stripping” Grace said happily, not bothering to put her bra straps back in place and instead just reaching around to unclasp it completely.

Grace seemed to proudly show herself off at this stage, no longer having the KDK effect cause her to be nervous but still having the dopamine rush in her system from revealing herself out in front of everyone. She almost looked blissful as she straightened up where she was sat, accentuating her chest even more and giving you a great view that was to die for.

Rebecca on the other hand had to fully stand up in order to get out of her dress.

“I would really like to help you get out of that but, you know” you joked, gesturing to your hand still involved in the dare.

Rebecca saw the humour in it and was calmer than before as she moved to unzip the back of her dress.

Everyone’s eyes were still on her and the music lightly playing in the background almost made it look like a striptease in your eyes but Rebecca didn’t seem to hesitate as she stripped it off. She even threw in a wink in your direction when she bent over and once Emma went out of her way to give a few hoots and hollers, Rebecca even playfully blew a kiss in her direction.

You had already seen the lingerie from your visions and the picture Rebecca had sent but seeing it in the flesh felt like another thing entirely. She looked like a goddess in your eyes and you knew she had worn this just for you, adding onto the allure of it all. It almost felt like she was a present you couldn’t wait to unwrap and there was a temptation to take her up to your room and spend what little time you had tonight all alone with her.

Lucy noticed your reaction as she felt your cock twitch in your underwear and she helped with a few more deliberate movements to help keep you aroused.

The next part however was when Rebecca started to hesitate. Everyone was down a few pieces of clothing at this point, apart from you apparently, and while it had been easy to match up with people in their underwear, stripping off the upper part of her lingerie to expose herself was something that didn’t come as easily.

“I umm… Could I do something else as a punishment?” Rebecca asked, cautiously holding her hands together to nervously keep herself from fidgeting.

Ever since the idea of punishments had come up, Rebecca had been keen to find out more. You had given it as an option just in case anyone wasn’t comfortable earlier in the night taking off clothes and wanted an out, but now it felt like you needed to use it to your advantage for each individual and their kink.

“Are you sure? No takebacks” you said, keeping your tone neutral to not influence her decision.

“...Yes” Rebecca replied shyly.

“Alright I’ll…” you responded, about to get up in an attempt to start the punishment before you caught yourself just in time.

Your hand still barely stayed on Lucy’s chest and you were sure you would have let go if not for Lucy’s hand still tucked inside your jeans. You thought briefly on how to fix this but just decided to be open with everyone.

“If I’m gonna be handing out a punishment then I’ll need to be no longer involved in the dare. So do you want me to just excuse myself or should I still play by the rules of the game?” you asked, not wanting to outright ignore the rules just to fit your whims.

As much as you could just decide to do that, it felt more fun to stick with what you had been doing and it felt like no matter the option, you were going to be rewarded anyway.

“Rules are rules” Emma replied with a smirk.

“You just want him to strip” Sarah commented, getting a nudge from Emma in response.

She didn’t comment on that being false however.

“It will mean, Lucy also takes a punishment as she will be letting go of me” you added, making sure the stakes were known.

There was a bit of debate after that, mainly from Lucy who didn’t want to be unfairly punished while everyone else still kept their hands on her.

The final decision was that as you were the one walking away, Lucy shouldn’t be punished but you should, sounding fair to everyone except you. Not that you were going to complain but you would have liked more clothing to be removed if you were to make the choice.

Lucy also reluctantly removed her hand from your underwear and kept it on your leg until she finally had to let go, nobody else seemingly noticing what she had done other than Rebecca.

You took off your shirt and got encouragement from more than just Emma this time, the confidence boost hitting you as you made your way over to Rebbeca, getting yourself prepared to give her the punishment that you felt would match her.