Less sexy than you had hoped

You walked inside and closed the door behind you, trying not to look upset when you saw that the both of them were now fully clothed without a trace of your cum still on their bodies. There was still a lingering scent of sex in the air that you would probably need to get rid of to avoid any suspicions but now that you looked a bit more carefully at the two of them sitting opposite each other on your bed, you could see the atmosphere between the two of them wasn’t as good as it was earlier.

“Are you guys okay or do you want me to come back later?” you asked, trying to get a feel for what the issue could be.

“No we…”

“No it’s…” the both of them started, interrupting each other before going sheepishly quiet.

From the reaction the two of them had, you at least knew it wasn’t something they were angry enough about to try and get you on their side and with the both of them going silent it looked like you needed to step in. You now had the choice of who to ask first but as Sarah was the one nervously twiddling with her thumbs and avoiding your gaze, you decided to ask her as the guiltier looking of the two.

“Sarah, what’s the issue. Is it something about what we’ve just done or…” you said, leaving your question unsaid for her to fill in the gaps.

“N-no everything about that was all taken care of. We just… can’t agree about something with you and school” Sarah replied, blushing as she looked up in Emma’s direction and hoped she could explain the rest.

You understood the conversation turning in your direction but the added topic of school was what confused you the most. You had wondered how much they had actually managed to discuss while you were out of the room but for now, you turned to Emma to see if she could continue where Sarah left off.

“...Sarah wanted you to dance with her at prom” Emma hesitantly added, the both of you looking back in Sarah’s direction to see her looking back down at her lap.

It seemed like the topic was completely different from what you expected and you still felt confused as to why the room felt as tense as it did when you first entered.

“I don’t see why I can’t dance with the both of you at prom, we will be there for a while so we should have plenty of time right?” you asked back, trying to see if you had missed anything.

"It was more specifically about the first dance. You know the big opener that's usually a slow dance for couples to have together?” Emma replied, letting her opinion come out as she explained.

“...Nobody said it had to be just couples...” Sarah mumbled defeatedly, making you finally understand what the issue between the two of them actually was.

A smile formed on your face at the fact that two girls were fighting over dancing with you at prom but you **** yourself to make a straight face given that this seemed important to the two of them.

“So you weren’t able to come to a decision yourselves or were you waiting for me to give my opinion?” you questioned, wanting to see what arguments they had already come up with themselves but only being met with silence as they both looked nervous about your decision.

You considered telling them you would need time to think on this but that was bound to cause even more issues further down the line when you picked one person over the other. Getting the decision out of the way before the stakes get higher was the right call in your mind and although you wanted to seem unbiased, you had already made up your mind.

“I’d rather the two of you dance together but If I have to choose, then sorry Sarah I'd have to go with Emma. It’s not something I’m choosing because of what I want but just what everyone else will think, even though that might sound like a cop-out. Emma's the one who everyone sees as my girlfriend currently and if I was to dance with anyone else there might be rumours flying around, especially if we are seen being intimate and double especially because you're my sister”

You could see that Emma looked slightly relieved with the decision but she was probably of the same mind as you that being seen intimately with Sarah in public was a bad idea. You believed that to be the case for now anyway but as you saw Sarah’s expression worsen, you wanted to try and cheer her up.

“That doesn’t mean we can't dance together later on in the night or be together in other ways. And even in the future. Look, I know me and Emma are planning to go to college and at least just say for the sake of argument that you do the same or we help you do the same. We’re gonna be in a new city with practically nobody knowing who we are, we can act however we want and not like a sister. We can all go on dates, live together, whatever we want.” you explained, seeing the light return to Sarah’s eyes and a slightly shocked reaction from Emma that you had already thought about all this.

There was still loads of time until you started college and all the summer holiday to enjoy but with you now effectively having control over the lives of six other people, thoughts like this had popped up now and again. You wanted to live with everyone but with the current funds you had at your disposal, you knew that wasn’t feasible. Your more realistic ideal was to go off to college along with the two of them and start working up from there. For now though, the KDK and your more immediate plans were what took precedent.

“But that's probably a discussion for another time. I did end up speaking with Grace while I was outside and she said she will be on her way home soon.” you said, finishing up getting a nod from both of them before Sarah pushed herself towards the edge of the bed to get up.

“I’m sure the two of you have stuff to talk about alone so I’ll leave you to it” Sarah announced, going over to your mirror to check she looked presentable.

Emma got up as well to see Sarah out and unexpectedly gave her a quick kiss on the lips, bringing a cute smile to Sarah’s face before she turned to leave.

“I’ll speak to you later if you have time” you added, seeing Sarah nod before she walked out into the hallway, closing the door behind her as Emma sat back down next to you.

She flopped back down on the bed next to you and let out a sigh that rivalled one of your own. With the mood being more relaxed, you lay down next to her and the two of you stayed in silence until curiosity got the better of you and made you ask her the question that had been on your mind.

“So, what did Sarah tell you?” You asked, getting a cute smile for Emma as if she expected this question.