Who the system points it at next?
Landlady
The receipt was still warm in his pocket when he started lying to himself.
He did it in the checkout line, which was the wrong place for it. The cashier was nineteen and bored and had the particular gift of the bored for making a transaction feel like a medical procedure. Beep. Beep. A hand out for the card. Matt stood in the fluorescent light with his chicken and his canned tomatoes and his bag of rice and built the story he was going to need later: it was a grocery store thing. Grocery-store scope. Some cosmic prank with a very specific jurisdiction, filed under Dairy, closed at checkout. He had a receipt. He had chicken thighs. He was going to go home and put them in the refrigerator like a man.
"Do you have a rewards card?"
"No."
"Want one?"
"No."
She scanned one anyway, because the machine had already decided, and Matt felt a complicated sympathy for the machine.
Above the register, on a little monitor, the security feed showed the front of the store. Matt watched himself buy groceries. He looked completely fine. That was the thing. He kept looking for something in the frame — a smudge, a glitch, a second version of himself standing where he shouldn't be — and there was nothing. The footage was innocent. It showed a tall, tired man with a cart and a face you'd forget, buying food, on a Tuesday.
"Have a good one," the cashier said.
"Yeah," Matt said. "You too."
The receipt said Tuesday, 6:41 p.m., and a total he didn't bother to read. He folded it and put it in his pocket, and it felt like evidence, which was funny, because it wasn't.
It was October, and the light had given up early. He had lived in Coldbrook long enough to know the pattern — summer to winter with about nine days of fall in between, and three of those were rain. Matt walked with a bag in each hand and his collar up and let the case build itself.
Grocery-store scope. He was never going back to that store. There were other stores. There was a whole city of them, and every one sold chicken.
He passed the library on Market with its warm windows and a hand-lettered poster for story hour, and the rec center with its sign for the pool, and a man arguing with a parking meter, and none of it meant anything, which was the point. That was the deal he was making. The world was going to be ordinary, and he was going to meet it halfway.
Hello? he thought at nothing.
Then, because he was alone and it was dark and nobody could see him being ridiculous, he said it out loud. "Hello."
A car went by. A dog answered from a yard. Nothing else.
He felt like an idiot, and underneath the idiot, relief — warm and stupid and immediate. That was the trap. He was already inside it, and it felt like being let out.
Mrs. Schmitt's door opened across the hall.
He heard the dog first — Biscuit, small and loud and personally offended by the existence of hallways, a name Matt knew from three years of hearing it shouted through a wall — and then the door, and then her, holding it open with her hip because both hands were full. Jeans worn soft at the knee. A navy sweater with the sleeves shoved up past the elbow. Bare feet. Reading glasses pushed into her hair like she'd forgotten she was wearing them. A dish towel over one shoulder, flour on one hand, a covered dish in the other.
She looked at his two bags, then at him.
"You're the one who never cooks," she said.
"I cook."
"You reheat."
"I cook and I reheat."
She made a sound that was almost a laugh and not quite. Then she looked at him properly, and whatever she saw, she didn't like. Her face did the thing faces do when they're deciding whether to say something.
"You're gray," she said. Not a compliment.
"I'm fine."
"Mm."
She set the dish down on the little table by her door, because she needed the hand. Then she reached up and put the back of her hand against his forehead.
Matt stood there with a bag of groceries in each fist and no idea what to do with his arms. She was close enough that he could smell chlorine and rosemary and something underneath that was just warm. Her hand was cool and dry and absolutely certain of itself.
"Long day," he said.
"Mm," she said again.
The dog came out around her ankles, sniffed Matt's shoe with enormous suspicion, and then sat down on his foot, which appeared to settle the matter.
"He doesn't like anyone," she said.
"He's got good instincts."
"He's got no instincts at all. He ate a wasp." She looked at him a moment longer. "You look like a man who's been carrying something heavy for a while."
He had called her Mrs. Schmitt for three years. The lease still said G. Schmitt — Gerry's name, on an old form — and he had never asked why. He did not know her first name. It had never come up. In three years he had never needed it.
The hallway went very quiet.
[Subject: Janice Schmitt]
[Address her as Mommy.]
Two lines. The first one was worse. He had her first name now, and he had never seen it written down anywhere, and the system had put it in his head like a label on a jar.
He looked at the ceiling. At the stairwell. At the dog, who had come out to supervise and was not impressed.
He waited for the numbers to fall.
Nothing fell. No counter. No deadline. No two-minute hole in the world with his name on the far side of it. Just the two lines, patient as furniture.
That was worse, and it took him a second to understand why. A countdown was a threat. This was an expectation. Expectations could wait.
He tried to laugh. It came out wrong and died somewhere near his collarbone.
He said goodnight.
Turned to his own door, three feet away, and put the key in the lock. His hand was steady. He noticed that and didn't like it. Steady hands were for people who had decided something.
[Refusal: file released.]
He stopped.
[Incident 1. Public indecency. Location: dairy aisle, 14:22. Witness: female, 70s, soup.]
He read it twice, then a third time, like a man checking a bill.
Fourteen twenty-two. He didn't think in military time. Nobody did. The system used it the way a man in a suit uses a word in Latin — to make a thing sound as if it had already been decided somewhere else.
Witness: female, 70s, soup. The grandmother. The one with the soup, who had nodded at him over a display of yogurts as if a man publicly fondling a stranger were a wholesome Tuesday sight. She was in the file. Of course she was in the file. Something had been taking notes while he was still deciding whether to be horrified.
[Estimated outcome: arrest, 3–5 years, low media interest.]
Low media interest.
He stood in the hall and hated himself for noticing, and then hated himself more, because it was the only part of the sentence that had made him feel anything. Not the arrest. Not the years. The adjective. Somewhere out there, a system had assessed his disgrace and found it mildly newsworthy.
Then his phone went off.
Once. The flat buzz of a message from a number he didn't know, and he looked at it, because looking was free.
It was a photograph. The dairy case, the glass, the rows of yogurt. Him — his own back, his own shoulders, his own hands — and in front of him a gray sweater and a ponytail and a woman reading a label.
The timestamp said 14:23.
The angle was from above. From the ceiling. From a place where there was no camera, and if there had been one, he would have found it, because he had spent the last ten minutes of that evening looking with everything he had.
He looked up. The hallway ceiling was white and ordinary and had nothing in it.
Behind him, Mrs. Schmitt said, "Matt?"
He had a decision to make. He ran it the way he ran everything, in branches, with numbers attached.
Refuse, and the file opened. A photograph, a witness, a charge sheet with his name on it. His life would become a thing that happened in a courtroom, and Lisa Hilt — who had done nothing, who had been buying yogurt — would become a line in somebody's evidence, forever.
Comply, and he said a word to his landlady.
The math was very simple and very bad. It took him less than a second. He was ashamed of how little it took.
[Compliance: this action will not be recorded.]
He read that one slowly.
Not erased. He understood the difference, and hated that he understood it. Nobody was offering to take the photograph off his phone or the grandmother out of the file. The offer was narrower and worse: do this, and there would not be a second page. He could keep his record exactly as dirty as it was, no dirtier, for the price of one word.
He asked the obvious question.
"And the photograph?"
[No.]
"No?"
[No.]
He tried again, differently. What if he did it twice. What if it was quick. What if she didn't hear.
[It is a photograph of a felony.]
He stood in the hallway with his key still in the lock, negotiating with nothing, while a woman watched him from her doorway with a dish towel over one shoulder, and a dog looked on with the flat contempt of the small and loud. Somewhere below, a door closed.
"Fine," he said.
The word cost him something he couldn't name.
He turned around.
"Mommy," he said, and laughed — a bright, false, dying little laugh, the kind you use on a phone call you want to end. "Sorry. Long day. I meant—"
"Mm," said Mrs. Schmitt.
The mm had a shape to it. It was the sound a woman makes when she has decided to be patient, and patience from her was worse than shouting.
"I meant—" He heard himself begin the sentence and had no idea how it ended. "Mom."
She raised an eyebrow. Just the one.
"Mommy."
The second one came out quieter and much worse, because it wasn't a joke anymore, and both of them knew it.
She looked at him. Then she looked past him, down the hall, checking for cameras, which was somehow the most humiliating part of the entire day.
"Well," she said. "Come in before the dog eats you."
He didn't move.
She took both bags off him with one hand — like a woman who had carried heavier things up those stairs — and went inside.
Matt stood in the hallway for one more second with his hand still on the key, and then followed her, because there was nothing else to do with the rest of his life.
The door closed.
Her apartment was warm in a way his wasn't. That was the first thing. Warm, and it smelled like the inside of an oven, and there were books everywhere — not arranged by color, not arranged by anything, stacked on the floor and the windowsill and the arm of the good chair, where the dog had already installed itself.
A photograph on the wall: a man in a fishing hat, half-turned, laughing at something off-frame. Gerry, presumably. Matt looked at it and then looked away, because it felt like being introduced.
"Coat," she said.
He took off his coat.
"Sit."
He sat.
She moved around him like he was a piece of furniture she had decided to keep. She put the plate in his hands — real food, a casserole with a crust on it, green beans, a glass of water she didn't ask about — and then stood there with her arms crossed until he picked up the fork.
It was good. It was very good. He ate the first plate without tasting it, the second plate tasting it, and the third plate with a kind of embarrassment he hadn't felt since he was nine.
"Third," she observed.
"It's good."
"Mm."
The dog put its head on his foot and growled when he moved it.
The kitchen was the size of his bathroom and twice as warm, and she worked in it without seeming to look at anything — reaching for the salt before she needed it, turning the faucet off with her wrist. A magnet on the fridge from Atlantic City. A swimming schedule with three days circled in red. On the sill above the sink, a row of small pots with things growing in them that Matt could not have named.
He had not been a guest in anyone's home in four years, and he had forgotten the specific embarrassment of being looked after.
She stood too close and checked him like a machine that was making a noise.
Back of the hand to his forehead. Then two fingers at his wrist, counting, her eyes on the middle distance. Then a hand under his chin, tilting his face into the light, and he sat there and let her, because what else was he going to do.
"You've lost weight," she said.
"I've been busy."
"You're not sleeping."
"I sleep."
"You've got the shoulders of a man who sleeps in a chair." She turned his hand over, looked at his palm, and put it down. "And your hands are cold. When did you last eat something that wasn't beige?"
"Tonight. Apparently."
"Mm."
She kept hold of his wrist after she'd finished counting, her thumb on the pulse, as though waiting for it to tell her something else. He could feel his own heartbeat arriving in his fingertips, stupidly fast, and hoped she would put it down to the stairs.
Nobody had looked at him this closely since a doctor he had lied to. It was unbearable in a way that had nothing to do with pain. He wanted to get up and he wanted to stay, and the two wants sat in him like a pair of dogs.
She asked questions while she cleared the plates, and he gave her the smallest answers he could get away with, and she took them. That was the thing about her. She took them. She didn't push, and the not-pushing did more than pushing would have.
She talked instead. The library — Tuesdays, Thursdays, Saturdays, story hour at ten thirty, a kid who called her the book lady and would not be corrected. The fix-it clinic, and a toaster that had defeated her in front of an audience.
"Your people local?" she said.
"Not really."
"Mm." She said it the way she said everything, as though it were a complete answer, and let it go.
Gerry came up once, in passing, in the present tense. He likes it when it rains. Then she stopped, corrected it, and went on, and it was the only time all evening that her voice caught.
"My son," she said later, and then changed the subject in the middle of the sentence, and Matt noticed, which was the only thing he was reliably good at.
There was a photograph of a boy on the bookshelf, maybe eight years old, holding a fish. It had been dusted recently. It was the only photograph in the room turned slightly away from the chair.
He almost told her. He had a whole speech about the dairy aisle and it started with I'm not a bad person, which was already a bad start, and he got as far as opening his mouth.
And he did not use her name. He kept it in his pocket all evening, like something stolen.
"I should go," he said, and stood up.
"Sit down."
"I really should—"
"I said sit down," she said, not loudly, and he sat down, and something in him that had been standing up for thirty-five years sat down too.
She took his plate.
She came past him with it and stopped, and did something small and unnecessary: her thumb at the corner of his mouth, wiping away something that wasn't there.
Her thumb stayed maybe one second longer than it needed to. She noticed. He saw her notice. She didn't take it back.
"There," she said, as though she'd fixed something.
Then she went into the kitchen, and the water ran, and Matt sat on her couch with his heart going like a bird in a box.
He went under mid-sentence, without permission and without noticing. He was telling her about the parking meter, and then he was gone.
He woke under a blanket that smelled of her — chlorine, rosemary, laundry — with the lamp on and the dog on his feet and the clock on the shelf saying something unreasonable. Ten past eleven. He had slept for an hour and a half in his landlady's apartment, with his shoes off, and somebody had taken his shoes off.
She was in the good chair with a blanket over her knees and a book open on her chest, reading with her glasses on. The dog had abandoned him at some point and was now a small warm weight against her hip.
"You snore," she said, without looking up.
"Sorry."
"Don't be. It's company."
He didn't know what to do with that, so he looked at the ceiling, which had a water stain in the shape of Portugal.
He put his shoes on at the door like a teenager. He thanked her, badly, twice, and the second time she told him to stop.
"Come by tomorrow," she said. Not a question. "I'll have too much again."
She reached up and straightened his collar, which didn't need straightening, and patted his chest once, flat-handed, as if checking that a door was shut.
He said goodnight.
"Goodnight, Janice."
The word was out before he had decided to say it, and it hung there between them, and she went still.
She looked at him. Not frightened. Curious — the way you'd ask about a noise in the night, before you'd decided whether to be afraid of it.
"How did you know my first name?"
He opened his mouth. Nothing came out. He stood there with his coat half on and his mouth open and let her watch him not have an answer.
"Get some sleep, Matt," she said, and closed the door, gently, the way you close a door on something you've decided not to wake.
His apartment was colder than he'd left it. The radiator ticked. He put the leftovers in the fridge — she'd insisted, and pressed the container into his hands at the door, and it was heavier than it looked.
Her handwriting on the lid, in marker: MATT — 2 DAYS.
She must have written it before he arrived. He stood there with the fridge door open and the cold coming out and understood that, and then decided not to understand it, and put the container on the shelf.
[Incidents on file: 1.]
Still one. He had done the thing, and the number had not moved, and he was grateful.
[Subject: Janice Schmitt]
[Fondness +1]
[Maternal instinct +5]
He had not been a guest. He had been an assessment.
What's next?
- No further chapters
- Add a new chapter
- Customize choices
0 comments
No comments yet
The story has no discussion yet. Leave a note here when a branch gives you something to say.
No chapter comments yet
No one has commented on this branch yet. Add the first note above.