Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 3 by AlyErotica AlyErotica

Who Should Ally Sleep with?

Jenny

"I'll share a room with Jenny," Ally said. "She's right, we do already room together at school. Plus, I don't know what would happen if we left her and Danny alone together."

"Hey!" Jenny shouted, playfully hitting Ally's arm again. "We can behave ourselves. But I'm so glad you picked me. I was worrying you didn't like me very much."

"What?" Ally asked, opening her own suitcase to pull out some sleepwear, while Kate and Danny went to go pick rooms of their own. "Why would you think that?"

"Oh, you're always rolling your eyes and you're, you know, a little cold to me," Jenny said in a tone like 'whatever.'

"That's just how I am," Ally said. "Sorry. I didn't mean to."

"It's 'kay," Jenny said, giving Ally a quick hug to prove that everything was fine. Ally felt her own breasts pressing against Jenny's, and wondered if Jenny's nipples were always so pronounced, or if it was just cold in here. "Which side of the bed do you like?"

##

The showers in the house still worked as they did when you were a kid -- hot pressurized water turning the small, wooden rooms into miniature saunas, where multiple people could sit and talk, though Ally never did that as a kid. Still, sitting in the sauna, Ally decided it wouldn't hurt to invite Jenny in, and Jenny jumped at the opportunity.

Ally expected her to show up wrapped in a towel, like Ally was, but she entered in naked as the day she was born -- revealing to Ally what she all already knew: Jenny was gorgeous. Her breasts rested perfectly on her chest, with small, pink nipples that Ally couldn't stop staring at; Jenny's stomach was flat with the smallest whisper of abs, visible only when she flexed. Her pussy was completely shaved, and Jenny had no shame about spreading her legs as she lathered herself with soap, letting Ally see every inch of her.

Ally had never necessarily thought herself gay, or even really all that attracted to women, or anyone really, but seeing Jenny here gave her a desire to reach her hand beneath her own towel...

"Is your towel uncomfortable?" Jenny asked her, clearly clocking her confused expression. "You should take it off! It's just us girls in here." Ally smiled awkwardly, slowly stripping the towel down her shoulders, until Jenny's expression changed entirely. "Hold on -- what is that?"

Ally followed Jenny's gaze to a small, black slip of paper resting just behind Ally's head. How had she missed that? Ally pulled the paper from the wall and read the few words written across it in white ink beneath a small, white pill:

Dear Allyson: Eat me.

"Woah," Jenny said, sitting next to Ally to read the letter. "Like Alice in Wonderland. You should eat it!"

"I don't just eat random pills!" Allyson argued back.

"It's not random, it's for you!" Jenny insisted. "Someone clearly wanted you to have this."

"Grandpa did say he would leave me some advantages for the trial tomorrow..." Ally thought aloud.

"I'll be right here, in case something goes wrong," Jenny said, sliding one of her hands into Ally's and squeezing. Allyson bit her lip, trying to ignore the hot, steaming girl, dripping with sauna sweat in the room next to her.

"Okay," Allyson agreed. She placed the pill on her tongue, tilted her head back, and swallowed.

"Well, how do you feel?" Jenny asked, after a minute.

"Mostly the same..." Ally said. What had the pill done? What had it been for? And then Ally felt a small twitching between her thighs. "What the... hell?" Ally pulled her towel off in one swoop, feeling suddenly constrained by it, and looked down at her waist where, in place of her pussy, rested a flaccid, twitching penis.

"What is that!" Jenny asked, pulling away from Ally. "Have you always --"

"No, no!" Ally shouted. "This is... this must be from the pill!"

"It gave you a dick?" Jenny asked, calming down enough to approach Ally again. She tilted her head, examining the new appendage between Ally's legs. "That's so weird. So weird." Her blue eyes seemed transfixed to Ally's new cock. Jenny bit her lip. "Is it... real?"

"I don't know," Ally said, confused but excited by Jenny's new interest.

"Can I...?" Jenny asked, gesturing.

"I... I guess..." Ally said. Jenny's hand lowered to Ally's new appendage, sitting flaccid at around three inches. Jenny's finger stroked slowly across Ally's length, and Ally let out a small moan. Jenny giggled at Ally's noises as she continued to stroke her growing cock, which expanded until it was standing, solid as a rock, at around seven inches.

"Not bad at all," Jenny said, lowering one of her hands to Ally's new, full testicles. Ally gasped at the sudden pleasure of it. "Heehee," Jenny giggled. She extending a middle finger under the midsection of Ally's ballsack, lifting slightly while Ally held her breath. "Do you think you can cum?" Jenny asked. With her free hand, she pressed back Ally's foreskin, rubbing the skin of her cock back and forth faster and faster while Ally's hips bucked into Jenny's palm, letting her fingers tickle the underside of her new scrotum.

"Oh my God, Jenny," Ally said. "Keep going."

"Well, duh," Jenny said, licking her lips. "I want a taste, cutie. I've never drank girl-cum before. Your cock is so pretty. And bigger than Danny's," Jenny said, with another small laugh. Her tongue fell from her mouth and pressed against Ally's tip -- the warm, wet sensation of her touch...

"Jenny! I'm cumming!"

Jenny could only moan along Ally's cock as rope after rope of new, thick cum poured down her throat. The vibrations of her hum twitched around Ally's cock, soaking her length in pleasure as she poured her seed into her college roommate.

"Oh, Jenny," Ally groaned as she came. "Jenny, Jenny, Jenny..."

"You really do like me, huh?" Jenny asked, licking her lips, making sure she swallowed down every last drop of cum. She rose until she was face to face with Ally, and then leaned in, giving her a small, cute peck on the cheek. "I like you too, Ally. Don't tell Danny, of course. But maybe we can have some more fun this week... assuming this new fixture is permanent..."

"I hope it is," Ally said, suddenly. "I want to feel like this, with you, forever."

"You're too cute," Jenny said, leaning her naked body against Ally's until their tits were practically kissing. Ally felt her cock twitch against Jenny's leg. "Let's get cleaned up, lover."

"Okay," Ally agreed.

##

That night, it was hard for Ally to sleep. Literally hard. Jenny cuddled with her, legs intertwined, and with her head resting into Ally's chest. It was the hottest thing Ally had ever experienced -- but it was too hot, uncomfortably hot, and Ally's new hardness wouldn't stop stretching against her little panties.

"Jenny," Ally whispered, slowly lowering her panties to free her new monster. "Jenny," Ally whispered again, pressing the length of her cock beneath Jenny's shirt, rubbing her cock against the flesh of Jenny's stomach. "Is this alright?"

"Hmmm?" Jenny asked, already half asleep. "Of course, Ally," Jenny said. "Fuck my stomach. Your length is so hot, I love having you pressed against me." She lowered a hand to wrap her shirt over the length of Ally's cock, forming a small, tight hole around Ally's length. "Does this feel good, pretty?"

"So good," Ally said. "Can I... kiss you?"

"You're too cute," Jenny said, raising her lips to Ally's.

Her first kiss. And then her second. Jenny's tongue pressed against her lips and she opened her mouth to let Jenny in, and then their tongues danced inside Ally's mouth while Ally's cock thrusted faster and faster in the shirt-pussy across Jenny's stomach. Soon they were moaning into each other's mouths, Jenny's cinnamon breath filling her, Ally's hands running through Jenny's hear, across the smoothness of her cheeks and chin.

"Do you want to cum for me?" Jenny asked. Ally nodded. "I want you to cum for me."

"Oh, who even care about the house," Ally said. "I have you now, what else matters?"

"You're too cute," Jenny repeated. "What if we..."

A sudden scream from down the hallway froze them together. A man's scream. Danny.

Does Ally Check it Out?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)