Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 16 by Thronx Thronx

Which items exactly?

Items of interest for everyone

“Come in,” Vi said and grinned at Caitlyn.

Caitlyn didn’t blush, but nonetheless she said “Close the door, please” as soon as Sivir got inside.

“Well, well,” Sivir said surprised, freezing in the doorframe, as she saw Caitlyn half-naked on the bed. “You seem ready, Cait.”

“Close the door,” Caitlyn repeated, a bit more forceful this time.

“Yes, ma’am,” Sivir said with a grin and got inside the room. She had a small bag in her hand and showed it to them as she strolled towards the bed.

“Got anything I could find here,” she said, her brown eyes switching between Vi’s and Caitlyns face.

“Show us, please,” Caitlyn said and pointed at the bed.

“As you wish,” Sivir said calmly and opened the zipper of the bag. “I have washed them naturally…” she pulled out a glass-dildo, maybe 8 inches long. “Mostly I found standard-stuff,” Sivir said as several colourful butt-plugs (some made of glass, some made of rubber), dildos and strap-ons followed the glass-dildo. “I guess you have plenty of those…” Sivir continued. “Nonetheless, I wouldn’t say that you can’t have fun with a good old classic, right?”

“For sure not,” Vi said and eyed Caitlyn, who stared with an unreadable face at Sivir’s collections.

“Anyways, I found this little joker here,” Sivir said and pulled out a enormous purple dildo in the shape of a tentacle. “MF swore to me it feels like Vel’koz,” Sivir said and sneered. “Whatever that means. I don’t wanna picture it. Anyways, fun thing.”

Sivir put the tentacle-sized thing down at the bed and grabbed with her hand inside the bag again. “Two to go,” she said and gave Vi a bright smile. “I think, you’ll like this one.”

It was a strap-on, but not with a single, but two, thick rubber shafts.

“I like this one,” Vi agreed and smirked down at Caitlyn. “You too?”

“I guess, we will find out,” Caitlyn shrugged. “And the last one, Sivir?”

“Nothing too special, but a personal favourite for me,” Sivir said and pulled out the biggest dildo yet. It was a black monster, almost as long as her forearm and with ultra-realistic veins over the shaft. “My baby,” Sivir said and stroked over the rubber with her index finger. “Not gonna lie, I’ll miss him if you would confiscate him.”

“Won’t happen.” Caitlyn still hadn’t show any noticeable reaction. She reached out with her hand and grabbed the double-strap-on. “You can have him. We’ll take this.”

“Permanently?” Sivir asked.

“No. Do you plan to use it yourself?” Caitlyn asked with a raised eyebrow.

“Well…” Sivir said with a grin. “Don’t get me wrong, you can have them. For now. You simply aren’t the only two that asked for me.”

“Wait, seriously?” Vi asked surprised.

“Well, I was surprised myself,” Sivir said cheerfully. “But I am positive surprised. Last year, the two were inseparable…”


An hour before


"Sivir?"Sivir looked up surprised as she heard the commanding voice coming from a small table at the corner of the dining room: Taliyah and Qiyana. Sivir turned around and walked to them. They both wore there usual rift-outfits and while Taliyah looked rather nervous, Qiyana exuded self-confidence. She sat on her simple stool like a throne and eyed Sivir with an imperious look.

“What’s up?” Sivir greeted them, looking at Qiyana rather confused.

“What did these two lovebirds need you for?” Qiyana asked bluntly and pointed at the table with Vi and Caitlyn.

“They…need some from me,” Sivir said slowly. “Why do you care.”

“Is Caitlyn confiscating sex-toys for her and Vi?” Qiyana asked with raised eyebrows.

Taliyah’s toned skin reddened immediately and she looked around hastily, but no one around them seem to noticed it.

“I don’t know if they are confiscating them,” Sivir shrugged composedly. “I think, Vi finally giving Cait a bit space and she wants to experiment a bit.”

“Interesting,” Qiyana nodded and gave Taliyah a strange look. “See?” she said almost reassuringly. “Even Caitlyn wants to experiment.”

Taliyah shot her a daring glance. “Can we not talk about this here?” she asked annoyed.

Qiyana rolled her eyes and turned back to Sivir. “Alright. They want to experiment. We also. Are you involved in that for a longer term?”

“I don’t think so,” Sivir answered, frowning at Qiyana, having a hunch where this conversation leaded. “Do you want to…”

“Yes,” Qiyana said matter-of-factly. “I want to accustom Taliyah on real cocks. Some strap-ons would make sense, I don’t wanna bother her with a real cock right away. So, I thought, you could visit us and bring some strap-ons with you, so we can get started with project ‘Tal-bi-yah’.”

Taliyah next to Qiyana looked like she wanted to disappear into thin air right now. Her eyes were fixated into the distance and her face could probably heating the whole room. Qiyana didn’t show any signs of embarrassment at all, she just snacked a paprika off her plate, dipped it in aioli and ate it, with an amused look to Taliyah. “Don’t look so flustered, or anyone will know, what I have planned,” she grinned.

“They probably already know, because you can’t keep your voice low,” Taliyah hissed angrily, still looking really embarrassed.

“So, you want me to bring some of my toys as well?” Sivir asked Qiyana. She grinned. What a promising day this was.

“Now where you mention it…” Qiyana scrutinized her thoughtfully. “We obviously have enough toys in our room, but maybe a third woman joining us in the bed helps to get her shyness a bit out of the way…”

“I am not…” Taliyah protested.

“And if she gets used to threesomes, she might want to see me getting fucked by a big cock too,” Qiyana continued casually.

Qiyana!” Taliyah hissed desperately. “Please, by the love of god, can you be quieter…”

“And once she sees how much a big, fat cock gives me joy, she wants to get pounded as well in her tight, little pussy,” Qiyana continued mercilessly, yet with a satisfied smile.

Taliyah made a whimper and looked around concerned, if anyone else had heard them. Lucky for them MF and GP just had started a fight and most attention was on them, not on Qiyana causally talking about her and Taliyah’s sex-life.

“Alright, I’ll come over once Vi and Cait let me off their hook,” Sivir said and winked. “If you don’t mind, Taliyah.”

Taliyah didn’t answer, but she also didn’t say no. She just stared on her knees. Qiyana wiggled her eyebrows and licked her lips. “See you later than. My room, Sivir. Ground floor, east-side, the big room at the end of the corridor.”

Please log in to view the image


“So, if you don’t mind,” Sivir concluded and looked from Vi to Caitlyn. “I’ll be going soon. I’ll pick up my stuff later that day, so you better enjoy it while I am gone.”

Vi nodded, eyeing the double-dildo in Caitlyn’s hands. “When does our date start?” she asked to Caitlyn.

“After diner,” Caitlyn answered slowly.

“Enough time to try these out, I believe,” Sivir grinned, who had followed Vi’s gaze. She waved her hand goodbye and strolled off to the door, closing it behind her.

Caitlyn continued to look at the door with an almost impassive face, absently stroking her hand over her thigh. Vi frowned at her before she asked: “You wanted her to stay, right?”

Caitlyn didn’t answer, but she seems to awake from her stasis and looked back at Vi. She cleared her throat and smiled at Vi. “Maybe I thought Sivir would understand my request to bring us some toys also as a request to join in. So maybe I am just a bit surprised, she didn’t want to stay here after all. But I won’t complain.”

“Neither do I,” Vi grinned. She grabbed the double-dildo out of Caitlyn’s hands and gave her a knowing smile. “I am gonna stuff that thing in your holes, cupcake, you can bet on that.”

Caitlyn immediately flushed scarlet-red. Still sitting there just in her lingerie was emphasizing this even more than usual. Vi grinned and pulled Caitlyn’s head to her, to kiss her on the lips. Even with Caitlyn taking the lead in asking other female champions out for a three- or even a foursome, she still got flustered when Vi spoke so directly about the things she would do to her.

“I am gonna make you scream with that, cupcake,” Vi whispered and looked deeply into her girlfriend eyes. “And after you are done orgasming, you better stuff me full with it too.”

“It’ll be hard for you,” Caitlyn muttered, her eyes closed and her mouth half open, ready for another kiss.

“Scared, you don’t know how to use this and give me a proper orgasm?” Vi asked and pulled her shirt over her head.

“No,” Caitlyn said and opened her eyes. “You can’t scream, if your face is getting pressed in the mattress.”

Vi raised her eyebrows. “Feeling dominant today, cupcake?” she asked sweetly. “You better hold, what you promise right now.”

“If you can hold your promise?” Caitlyn replied and took the double-dildo in her hands, handing it over to Vi.

Vi grabbed it and quickly kicked her boots away, removed her trousers and slipped out of her panties. Caitlyn watched her intently as Vi buckled the strap -on around her waist and Vi noticed the slightest glimpse of concern in her eyes.

“Don’t you worry, cupcake,” Vi said, pulling Caitlyn’s head back to hers to kiss her deeply. “It’s not the first strap-on we use…”

Caitlyn nodded, even if it was clear what she might wanted to say. It wasn’t their first strap-on, Vi and Caitlyn used in bed. But A, she hadn’t used any toys since last vacation and B, it was the first dildo Vi could use to penetrate both her holes. And as Caitlyn was lying down on her back on the bed, spreading her legs, so Vi had a good look on her panties, which had the smallest wet spot on them, Vi knew she wanted to use them just for that.

With her thumbs she pulled Caitlyn’s panties from her legs and as she saw the glistening pussy of her girlfriend, Vi felt her own nether regions getting wet really fast. She stuck two fingers into her mouth and moistened them as well, which she used than to stroke over Caitlyn’s pussy lips.

Caitlyn moaned as Vi’s fingers touched her clit and her back arched a little, as her face twisted in pleasure. Vi continued to caress Caitlyn’s pussy lips for a few seconds, before her finger traced down and slipped inside Caitlyn for just a second. Caitlyn yelped adorably as Vi retreated her finger almost immediately. Instead, Vi positioned herself right in front of Caitlyn’s legs and the tip of one of the rubber shafts was hovering right above her wet pussy.

Their eyes met for one second before Vi entered with the strap-on into Caitlyn and Vi noticed that the glimpse of concern was gone now. Instead, she glared at Vi with a look equally full of lust and admiration. Then her eyes rolled back and her mouth opened into a silent scream, as inch after inch of rubber dick slowly penetrated her. It wasn’t the first time, Vi fucked Caitlyn this way and Vi took it slow at the moment, giving Caitlyn time to adjust to the shaft inside her.

So far, so good, Vi thought as Caitlyn managed to get more and more of the strap-on inside her with every thrust of her hips.

What was new still, was that there was a second shaft of the strap-on currently being stroked over Caitlyn’s ass-cheeks. It was hindering Vi to get really going and the more she thrusted inside Caitlyn the more it annoyed her. She wasn’t the only one, though…

“Stop for a second,” Caitlyn groaned and reached out with her hands, stopping Vi at her stomach.

Before Vi could ask her, if anything didn’t feel good or did hurt, Caitlyn already rolled herself over on her arms and legs and presented her butt to Vi. “You wanted to stuff me full with this thing,” she said, looking over her shoulder with a mix of determination and lust. “This way you should keep your promise.”

Vi grinned and now took both of the shafts of the strap-on in her hands, guiding them where they belonged. Caitlyn whimpered as the lower one, penetrated her pussy again, but she made an audible gasp, followed by a deep growl as Vi also shoved the upper shaft of the strap on entered her asshole.

Vi obviously didn’t felt the sensations, Caitlyn felt right now, but the sounds of her moans, the view of her head that rested on the pillow, eye-lids fluttering and eyes rolling back and the fact that Vi managed to get both of the shafts nearly to the hilt inside Caitlyn’s holes, was enough to get her aroused as well. She kept on with her slow thrusts, but with each thrust she felt the urge to go faster. Eventually, Vi leaned over Caitlyn’s back and put her hands on next to Caitlyn, making her moan and gasp more and more as she fucked into her eagerly.

Please log in to view the image

Caitlyn soon was cumming hard, but Vi didn’t backed off and thrusted as hard as before inside her. She first stopped as she felt Caitlyn struggling against Vi. She retreated herself and before she knew it, Caitlyn was pulling her towards her, kissing her passionately on the lips. For the next minute they continued to make out and while Vi was busy to kiss Caitlyn and play with her tits, Caitlyn already unbuckled the strap on from Vi.

“Felt that good, huh?” Vi muttered, as Caitlyn need to break the kiss to get the strap-on around her hips.

“You’ll feel it yourself, babe,” Caitlyn said and pushed Vi with surprising strength on the mattress.

Vi grinned as Caitlyn positioned herself now in the same position as Vi had fucked her before. She felt the wet rubber dicks of the strap-on rubbing over her ass and pussy, lubricating additionally her already slick nether region. Then she felt the two shafts entering first her pussy and then her asshole and Vi groaned out, just like Caitlyn did before.

Vi had been fucked with a strap-on before too. She and Caitlyn had experimented with buttplugs too, so the feeling of getting both her holes filled with something as a replacement for a cock, wasn’t new either. But nevertheless, the feeling of two dicks that intruded her wet folds was something she never had experienced at all.

On top of getting double-penetrated by a strap-on, Caitlyn too wasn’t holding back. She was prone-boning Vi into the mattress and even if she wasn’t as muscular or tall as Vi, she had complete control over Vi’s body, as she grabbed her head and clenched her hands into the pink hair.

Vi was thoroughly enjoying this treatment and the more she gave in to the pleasure, the louder her moans got, until she felt the unpreventable orgasm build up inside her core like an ocean-wave ready to collapse over her.

Please log in to view the imagePlease log in to view the image

As it hit her, Caitlyn didn’t slow down either and continued to thrust inside Vi, maximizing her pleasure to an almost painful degree. Vi’s whole body trembled with the aftershocks of her orgasm, as Caitlyn finally slowed down and pulled the strap-on out of her. Vi needed a moment to think straight again, so she reached out for Caitlyn over her and got her arm.

“You were right, cupcake,” she muttered dizzily. “It was kind of good.”

Vi felt that Caitlyn lay next to her and she opened her eyes. Caitlyn was lying on her back and had her eyes closed a happy smile on her beautiful face. “Told you,” she said. “I am a bit sad, you didn’t scream into the mattress, but I think we both held each other promises at the end.”

“A shame we have to give it back to Sivir,” Vi said with a sigh.

“You’ll get over it,” Caitlyn said and opened her eyes. “And don’t forget all the other toys we have.”

“Are you trying to use them all during vacation?” Vi asked with a curious smile.

“I am trying to have a good time,” Caitlyn responded. “Experiencing something new, while also stick to the classics.”

“I see,” Vi grinned and gave her a kiss. “I’m in for that ride, cupcake.”

“I never doubted that,” Caitlyn said and kissed her back.

What's next?

  • No further chapters
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)