Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 28 by crisdemos crisdemos

So how's the conversation going?

It's difficult, but works.

The three of you get up late the next day.

Yesterday was exhausting, and you still feel quite tired. The girls let you help out a bit, understanding that you need to feel useful, but they keep you from trying too hard.

Ashley and Hannah cook and serve breakfast together. Each of them serves the other, but they work together to serve you. There is no morning blowjob this morning. Actually there is no sexual contact at all. What there is is a lot of love. Both Ashley and Hannah take every opportunity to hug, caress or kiss you, either separately or together. Hannah even takes the opportunity to show you her support for the difficult situation that is coming, letting you know that she will be there for you, and making Ashley promise to listen to everything you have to say before jumping to any conclusions.

"hey, you know me better than that!" Ashley looks a little hurt.

"Of course I do. John too. But right now his mind needs security, baby." Hannah kisses and hugs Ashley affectionately, but she keeps her serious look. The girl seems to get the point, because she kisses back and nods firmly, earning her a soft smile and a loving caress from her girlfriend.

When breakfast is over, the three of you sit in the living room. Hannah, wonderful and sweet Hannah, sits on your lap. She looks at you all the time, caressing and kissing you whenever she feels you need it. Ashley sits on your other leg, telling you that whatever it is, everything will be fine. Both girls firmly but gently encourage you to open up.

So you do.

You tell them about your past memories and feelings. Like you had a crush on Ashley for a long time, but she was just your best lesbian friend. How you hated Hannah for being to Ashley what you could never be.

How confusion overwhelmed you at this new change in reality, not understanding what had happened. How feeling Ashley's love overwhelmed you when you realized she would never be sexually attracted to you.

You finally told Ashley about your time with Hannah. How you hurt her on purpose, trying to take out on the poor, helpless girl all the hate you had for her.

"I felt loved by you. But deep down I knew it would never be enough, because your one-sided love came from this power or whatever, from your absolute belief that you should love me and live to fulfill all my needs. Even the sex despite that you weren't really attracted to me at all."

"I also felt powerful. Hannah, my former love rival, was my willing plaything. She would do anything for me. She enjoyed being hurt, because I enjoyed doing it. She blindly believed in living for my pleasure and needs."

"So the only solution I found was to make you forget." You nod to Ashley. "I wanted you to forget your one-sided love and your belief in fulfilling my every whim. You would go back to being the friend I remembered. Except you would be my friend with benefits, and you would share your submissive girlfriend with me." You look at Hannah this time.

"Then I made my proposal and made it worse." Hannah affirms.

"Something like that. Don't get me wrong, I don't regret accepting it, but..."

"I know baby. But I doubt all this has helped with your emotions. You were already feeling guilty for hating me. Then instead of going with the flow and accepting your proposal, I did the noble thing and proposed that my girlfriend be sexually attracted to you. what is even worse, I gave myself to the possibility of loving you even after how you had treated me." you nod.

"But that's not bad! I mean, I'm sexually attracted to you now, and clearly you and Hannah love each other."

"That's exactly the problem, Ashley." Noticing that Ashley doesn't understand her, Hannah tries to explain. "Hating me was easy for him when you were just his friend and I was your girlfriend. Realizing what he was willing to do to me if I let him was bad enough for him. It probably didn't help the frustration of knowing that even though you loved him, you would only have sex with him because of that weird privilege he has."

"Now that I really think about it, I admit that it's strange that only John has that privilege. It was always like that for us, but the reality that he described to us makes much more sense."

"Exactly my point. Now imagine that your whole reality is turned upside down and add all those feelings to it. Then imagine how you would feel if you realized that you are capable of hurting a person you hate if they are defenseless enough, imagine realize that at the same time you discover that the person you love is not physically attracted to you, but to that other person. So, when you try to make that strange reality go back to what you remember, that person will the one you hurt proposes to be your girlfriend."

{ahsley} looks at you in horror. Hannah looks at you seriously, but her love is still there.

"He almost turned me down last night, Ashley." You look at Hannah in surprise.

"But you two did it, didn't you?"

"Yes. I admit it was amazing, but maybe it would have been better if it hadn't happened." At the surprised look the other girl gives her, Hannah elaborates. "John never got over those feelings for me, he just kept them to himself. That's what prompted him not to reject me, I think." She looks at you and you nod, surprised at how well he is analyzing you.

"Hannah..."

"I know, my love." She interrupts you, kissing you. "so he feels guilty about how he treated me and hated me, so he accepts us making love despite wanting to share that moment with you too. He enjoys it so much, so the mere thought of having almost chosen you again instead of me, even after everything I'm giving him... It adds to everything he's already feeling."

"oh my god..." Ashley is clearly starting to realize how overwhelmed you are. "fuck, that's what happened last night!" She realizes.

"What do you mean?" You ask, unable to assimilate that your friend knows you well enough to have understood the whole thing.

"I've been sending you signs all goddamn week, so I guess that it raised your hope. Having made love to her shouldn't exactly have helped, so I guess you were literally **** to have me last night."

Well, shit... Yes, she knows you that well, then. Even Hannah looks surprised for a moment, before something seems to click into her mind and she looks at Ashley in horror.

"Oh shit. We got home and you weren't there. Then you walk in with a man we don't know..."

"Our conversation indicates the worst posibility. I'm sure even you hesitated there, honey."

"Yes." She admits embarrassed. "At least until you called him dad. But there it is..."

"That's the problem, right? He doubted me, his loved Ashley."

"Then...boom! The containment didn't hold out anymore." Both girls say in unison.

When they look at you, you marvel. There is horror, pity, tenderness and love in his eyes. Even if they don't really know exactly what you're feeling, they clearly have a pretty good idea of what you're going through.

You can only nod, feeling all the emotional Baggage rising to the surface again. You begin to tremble and notice that your breathing quickens. They definitely notice it, because they both hug you at the same time and start talking softly.

"Breathe, love. We're here, baby. You need to let it out slowly. Just breathe easy and let it go, honey. We've got you, love. You're safe..."

Then you cry. You cling to these two human wonders and cry, letting everything out. For their part, the two girls hug you and kiss you carefully, but firmly enough that it is impossible for you not to notice the intensity of their love for you. They cry with you, clearly horrified at what you've been **** to go through on your own. You voluntarily chose not to rely on them, it's true, but emotions rarely make us rational, let alone negative ones. Even if a part of you still believes that you don't deserve the love you are receiving, the rest of you needs it as much as the air right now. So you just hug them and let them support you.

When it's all over, you're exhausted. None of the girls look better. However, you can finally smile. It feels... Liberating, so to speak. You thought it would be impossible to love Ashley more, but you were wrong. The way she showed how well she knew you has made you appreciate her even more. Then there's Hannah. Sweet, wonderful, beautiful and incredible Hannah. You'd make love to her again if you didn't feel like shit, and this time you wouldn't even think about rejection.

"Love you." you tell her. Because you can. Because she deserves it. Because you feel like it, damn it all!

"I know my love." She replies, giving you a tender look. You both smile at each other with a new complicity, born of everything you just shared. Even the negative, you realize. You go to kiss her, and she meets you halfway. You smile again and join your mouths.

For the first time, you don't think about Ashley. She is there and she is still a part of this. But this moment? This moment is just for Hannah and you. You need it, you realize as tears fill your eyes. She too, you notice as she lovingly wipes your tears and you do the same for her. Ashley wait. There is no jealousy. She was always the first in your heart and now she knows it. She will be the second to share such a moment with you this time, and she understands. You and Hannah need this, and she loves you so much she won't get in the way. Never.

Then it's her turn.

The kiss with Hannah was loving and deep. The kiss with Ashley is passionate and full of desire.

Hannah was first your hated rival and then your willing sex toy. You needed to reassure her that you loved her and that your bond had finally deepened.

Ashley was always your beloved best friend, who you were secretly in love with. The only reason she loved you in this twisted reality was because of your power, but even then she rejected the idea of having sex with you. She would if you asked her to, but again, never willingly, but by your power. Although it was that same power that technically caused her attraction to you now, the way it happened made all the difference, because that power was based on your needs. and you needed Ashley to be willingly attracted to you. Your power just made her open to that idea, that was your need.

You and Hannah needed to confirm your new love. You and Ashley needed to confirm their newfound sexual attraction to you. It was certainly there. She loved you too, of course, but she knew what you needed to feel. So she showed you.

Then they kissed. Both of them needed it to some extent after yesterday, but mostly it was for you. You needed them to love and desire each other. You needed to feel like a part of their relationship, not an obstacle. So they proved to you that you weren't, in two different ways. On the one hand, they were kissing like they always did, showing you that their feelings for each other hadn't changed. At the same time they kept clinging to you and kept caressing you and looking at you. You were not part of the kiss, but part of the moment. Because now... At last there were three of you.

Everything was confirmed a moment later. Because now both girls kissed you together. There was love. There was desire. Above all there was... Together.

"Together?" You asked with a smile.

"Always." They responded in unison.

"Always together. Always three now." You said together, kissing again just because. "I love you two." You three ended.

Pothole overcome. Now what?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)