If she'd join

The gleam in Susan’s eyes betrayed her intentions, if somehow her smirk hadn’t first. “Would you join us if we did, Caroline?” She teased, staring down at the redhead.

“Oh, definitely!” She replied with no hesitation, her tone matching the other girl’s. “Why wouldn’t I?”

Susan’s grin widened. “Good! I heard redheads are absolutely wild in bed. Is that true?”

Caroline winked. “Maybe a little.”

Feeling the sexual tension grow by the second, Troy tried to break it by chuckling loudly. “Okay, okay, relax you two. No need to push it.”

Unfortunately for him, it just seemed to direct their teasing to him.

“What’s the matter Troy; don’t you want the both of us?” The twins started giggling at the question.

Susan simply nodded along with every word. “Yeah Troy, can’t you help but picture the three of us fucking each other silly?”

“Yea- No!” He denied while shaking his head to rid himself of the image. It didn’t help. He could still vividly visualize Susan and Caroline naked on their knees before him, ready to be fucked.

Susan took note of how much his cock betrayed him and joined the twins with vigor. Caroline quickly caught on and soon Troy couldn’t help but look away, embarrassed; the four girls laughing at his expense. He would’ve fought back in kind, but Troy knew the teasing was meant in jest. Besides, with them busy, they weren’t as likely to notice how distracted he was with the image in his head.

His friend and study partner calmed down first, her laughter ending with a few deep chuckles. “I never get tired of teasing Troy. I just can’t help it though; he’s just so...”

“Old-fashioned?” Caroline finished. “He needs to realize that it’s all in good fun to be inappropriate outside of dating. Seems he and many other men have difficulties with that.”

“Oh good, it's not just me! They need to learn how thrilling it is to put someone on edge with an embarrassing question. For example,” Susan turned to Sana and Mina, addressing the twins directly. “Since you two are twins, are you really identical in all aspects?”

Susan didn’t know the girls well enough yet to correctly identify who had spoken. “Well, you’d have to be more specific, but I’d have to say yes. As far as I know at least.”

“Same taste in men? Matching o-faces? Identical tasting pussies?”

The other Asian girl silently recited the list in her head, mentally ticking off each one with her thumb. “Yes, yes, and yes. I’d say so.”

“What, have you two fucked each other to find out?”

The one who’d just finished listing suddenly locked her gaze in place, fidgeting embarrassedly as a memory popped into her head. Her twin took the initiative, exposing their guilt. “We…. may have gotten really drunk one night.”

This triggered another eruption from the girls, each spiraling once more. Amidst her giggles, she elbowed Troy, hoping he’s caught in on the fun. “You hear that Troy?”

Her question popped him back to reality. “Huh? Yes, I did!” He assessed the situation and shook his head, her words being the catalyst that helped him in shaking the image of a naked Susan and Caroline from his head. He looked at the four of them, confused.