Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 28 by crisdemos crisdemos

How do your girls react to your gift?

Hannah feels hurt.

Your breakfast wasn't exactly special. Some bacon and eggs, some cut fruit, some toast... Black coffee for you, milk for Ashley, and tea for Hannah.

You expected the surprise, which you get from both girls. Ashley and Hannah are surprised to find you up, but even more surprised when she finds you putting breakfast on the table.

"Oh shit…" You look at Ashley curiously, not understanding her curse. Then you hear someone fall to the ground, and you see Hannah on her knees covering her face with her hands. At first you smile at her, assuming she's overcome with astonishment, but you freeze when you hear her sob softly.

"I'm sorry, master. I'm so sorry! I didn't mean to do it, whatever it is!" You look at your other girlfriend in alarm.

"Ashley, what the hell is going on?"

"John, you need to tell her she didn't do anything wrong. Like, right now!"

"Toy, look at me!" You're not just calling her that, you're using your most authoritative voice. Normally you would feel like shit for treating her like this right now, but experience has taught you that when Hannah is overwhelmed with fear, she needs the guidance and authority of a Master.

Your conclusion is proven correct. Instantly, Hannah lifts her head and looks at you. You can see the fear in the poor girl's eyes, and though you don't understand why, you assume you've done something to scare her. You will be able to find out what as her boyfriend, but right now you have to be her master.

"Have you done something to be punished, toy?" Questions in a soft but firm tone.

"I... I marked you last night, master." Hannah shakes visibly. "The first time you took it well, master, but I was clearly warned about being disciplined, and I repeated my mistake once more. I'm sorry, master! I couldn't..."

You can't take it anymore. You fall to your knees in front of her, your eyes filling with tears. You gently lift Hannah's chin and gaze into her eyes for a moment before kissing her firmly. At first she freezes, but soon she is kissing you back just as firmly. You feel her slowly relax in your arms and her sobs subside. Out of the corner of your eye you see Ashley kneel beside you, ready to help you. She can clearly see your own anguish and confusion, because she has wrapped her arm around you and gently strokes your back.

"Hannah, estás mejor ahora, amor?" Tu voz es suave, y ha perdido esa cualidad autoritaria ahora que la chica está relajada.

"Y... Yeah..." Hannah stutters. "S... Sorry, I think I'm beginning to understand. You... You wanted to thank us, right? I'm not being punished?"

You hear the relieved sigh next to you. You yourself let out the air you were holding. The girl in front of you gives you a shaky smile.

"I'd ask for a warning next time, but that would ruin the point of a surprise, uh?" Now Hannah looks more embarrassed than scared, but you can still see something else in her eyes. She looks... Oh god, she looks hurt.

"Hannah, talk to me baby. What's going on? I hurt you, and I don't know why. I didn't mean to hurt you, honey. What's wrong?"

"I don't know if you noticed, John, but even when I make breakfast, she serves it." Ashley chimes in, causing both you and Hannah to jump a little in surprise. She gives you two a soft smile.

Now that you think about it, it's true. The day that Hannah made you that proposal, when you wanted Ashley to forget her love for you, Hannah had served you the breakfast that Ashley had prepared. He did even before kneeling at your feet to suck you off.

"Oh shit! Baby, I never realized… I'm sorry, I just wanted to surprise you girls!"

"It's OK love." Hannah hugs you gently, her pain slowly fading from her expression. "I can appreciate it, I promise. My submissive side felt a bit left out due to the suddenness of the situation, that's all." She smiles sweetly at you now. "Your girlfriend appreciates it very much, though." She ends, kissing you tenderly. It's as much a quest for solace as it is a solace in itself, you realize. Hannah needs to feel like you're there for her, but she also needs to show you that she's there for you, now that she's seen how hurt you feel for hurting her, even if you never meant to.

"Your other girlfriend appreciates it too, honey." {ashley says amused, though you can hear the love in her tone as well. "I know I didn't do much, but can I get a kiss too?" She jokes with a pout.

She didn't specify, so you and Hannah give each other a knowing wink before kissing Ashley at the same time. It seemed to be what she wanted, because she kisses you back with equal commitment, wrapping her free arm around Hannah and making the three of you press together.

"Let's have breakfast before it gets cold." Ashley proposes. By the way, what if you both serve me breakfast, then we serve Hannah, and then we girls serve yours, John? That way no one will feel left out."

You and Hannah look at each other for a moment, in awe of your wonderful shared girlfriend, before kissing her again. She just earned it, right? Also, now that you have her completely, it feels amazing to share these moments with Ashley. The knowing, happy smile that Hannah gives you also helps, because now, in addition to her usual gentleness or submissive adoration that she recently had for you, you can also see the love. Love for you, for Ashley, for your relationship... Above all, you can see the happiness of knowing that she is included and loved by both of you now, not only by her girlfriend.

"I love you, my sweet toy." You tell Hannah, simply because you can. This time you include that nickname because you are reminding her of how much she is to you. Your plaything, your willing ****, your submissive servant… Most of all, she is your girlfriend now, and judging by the loving look she gives you, she knows it.

"Your toy loves you too, master. Your girlfriend is looking forward to trying that breakfast that smells so good." She laughs softly at your half-exasperated expression at the way she's expressing herself.

"By the way, girls. Maybe you two could give me a quick guide after breakfast? I don't want to hurt you by mistake again."

Both girls stop eating for a moment, looking at each other. You see their smiles and wonder what's going on, but you're answered when they get up and lean in to kiss you.

"We'll be fine, John." Hannah tells you tenderly. "You and I need to get used to our new relationship, that's all. Fortunately, our wonderful girlfriend here knows both of us very well." She gives Ashley a soft look. "Anyway, we can fill you in on a few things. Not exactly after breakfast, though." She leans into your ear now. "Your toy needs to be disciplined, master. I also want to mark you a bit more, if that's okay."

"John?" Ashley gently interrupts. "I want to try something too." She gently bites her lip. "Now that I know you don't mind being a little overpowered..."

"Honey, he's not like me. He won't submit."

"I don't want him to submit, I want him to fight back... even I want to be under him..."

You don't understand what she means, but Hannah seems to have, because she looks at her with a mixture of disbelief and apprehension.

"It's optional!" Ashley rushes to clarify. "Hannah, you love that game, so that's enough for me. I just want the three of us to try it together, if he's into it. If he's not, that's fine!"

Assuming you'll find out in time, you continue to have breakfast with your two beauties, still somewhat curious as to what Ashley wants from you. You doubt it's such a bad thing, but Hannah's apprehension about it has you a little nervous. Well, you suppose you can always say no, whatever it is.

Author's Note: The next chapter I'll post on this branch will include pegging. I am aware that it is not for everyone, so I am giving the warning in advance. For those who are enjoying the story but don't enjoy this particular fetish, I'll put a link to the later chapter here so you guys can skip it. There is probably still some reference to what happened, but at least you will have avoided the graphic part of the matter.

Also, any disrespectful comments about that being gay will be ignored. You can have your opinions, and I will read them as long as they are written respectfully. I also inform in advance that my character will not be humiliated or feminized, so those who think that John will submit to girls, I warn you that it will not happen. I have nothing against those fetishes, they just aren't for me. As everyone may have noticed, Ashley clearly stated that she wanted our MC to fight backwards. She doesn't just want to take him, she wants to be taken.

With all this said, I say goodbye for now. See you guys!

Well then. Do you indulge in Ashley's game?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)