Gavin is the first to get naked, prompting new rules

As the bottle slowly came to a stop pointing to Gavin, most of the people in the room held their breaths in anticipation of what would happen, although a few snickers could be heard as well, mainly from Hannah and Heather. Taylor wasn't sure if she felt glad for Gavin, since she tried to encourage him to leave his shyness aside, or if she should feel sorry for him. The poor guy must be terrified.

She wasn't too far from the truth. Shit, shit, shit! Gavin mentally cursed, his eyes wide with panic. I can't pull out my dick, everyone will laugh at me!

Hannah nudged Taylor on the side. "Tay, you might want to get it over with before Gavin faints," she whispered in her best friend's ear.

"Yeah," Taylor agreed before she stood up and walked towards her brother's best male friend, a guy she came to see as some sort of another brother herself. "Gavin, calm down, it'll be over before you know it."

Gavin slowly nodded, trying to control his heavy breathing as his old crush crouched down before him and hooked her fingers on the waistband of his boxers. Taylor's presence was soothing, causing him to realize he could have it a lot worse, aside from Chloe and maybe Victoria, the other girls would probably tease him a lot while doing it. He nodded when the older girl looked up at him as if to ask permission.

"Okay," Taylor mumbled before she pulled down his boxers and an average-sized erection almost hit her in the face. She stared at it while tossing Gavin's boxers on the pile, it wasn't big, but it was far from small either. Just the right size to make someone feel very good, she thought, a warm feeling starting to creep up her body as the tall brunette imagined how wicked she would be if she just took her little brother's friend's cock into her...

"Now what?" Kurt's voice interrupted her.

Taylor looked around and noticed with relief that no one seemed to be looking at her. Victoria and Madison were covering their eyes while the guys focused on Kurt and the other girls stared at the erection she just unveiled to the room. She quietly returned to her spot as Gavin crouched down to hide his dick from view.

"Well, now the next two people who roll Gavin will have to kiss him," Hannah answered.

"On the lips, to be clear," Heather added. "So no one tries to get around the game and kiss him on the cheek or something."

"Everyone's okay with that, right?" Hannah asked, looking around the circle, but focusing more on the other three boys. "We've agreed on this before."

Zack, Kurt and Brandon looked at each other with worry on their faces. Despite the fear of having to interact with each other, the eagerness to see the girls kissing one another trumped that. They might be treading dangerous and unknown territory from now on, but their minds were too focused on the great reward for them to give any other answer. They slowly nodded at the blonde ex-cheerleader.

"And after two people kiss him?" Victoria asked. "He just loses?"

Heather smirked. "We'll get to that, Vicky, dear."

Gavin put a hand over his crotch and tried to cover his erection the best as he could before going over to the bottle and quickly spinning it.