Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 55 by grimbous grimbous

What's next?

Fuck Me!

Resettling yourself you take a second to reach back and spread your ass as far as it would go. Christ Fiona was big, it felt like a fucking baseball bat pressed up against your hole. You ready yourself once more. Looking down at the wide blue eyes of Zoey you could see she was as nervous and as excited as you were. Each of you were about to feel your first taste of big dick.

You push a bit forward, Fiona pushes a bit forward. You pull a bit back, Fiona pulls a bit back. She was mirroring your motions, following your lead as she said she would. Zoey below and Fiona above, it was a sex sandwich and you were the meat. As the middle child this felt strangely right.

You wanted it…you wanted it so bad…but you were also afraid. She was so big! And gentle she was not.

Fiona seemed to read your mind. Grabbing your hair so hard that it hurt she pulls your head back.

“AH!” You gasp.

“Come on Jesse.” She hisses with renewed passion as her free hand scratches down your back. “Go ahead. I wanna split that virgin ass wide open! I wanna wreck your tight booty hole brother! I wanna tear you in two!”

“Don’t hurt him Fiona.” Elsie whispers.

For the first time you could remember…you wished El would just shut up! She meant well but she couldn’t understand what music Fiona’s words were to your twisted mind. In a fucked up way you wanted to be hurt by her, in just the right ways of course.

Smack! Fiona lays a withering smack across your ass. “Don’t worry El, he can take it.”

“Hunnngh!” You whimper with lust and lean lower to offer yourself up for her even more. You could even feel your hot hungry bussy open up a little. “God! Do it! Fucking do it Fiona! Fuck my ass! Tear me up!”

She lets out an evil laugh and grips your hips once more. “After you little brother.”

Slowly you shift your weight forward and feel Zoey’s petals open up for you, allowing the first few inches into her snug wet penis pocket. “Ohhh wow.” She sighs. “So thick!”

At just that moment the pressure builds at your backdoor as Fiona matches your motion. With all your concentration you try to will your sphincter open but reactively it clenches against the massive invader. That wasn’t about to stop your sister. Keeping the pressure firm and steady she brute forces her way in and forces your tight hole wide open. Yeah, it felt good…but holy hell did it hurt! Your stretched anus is screaming as your sister embeds her whole tip inside you and stops just as you had.

“Fuuck!” You gurgle and cringe as your muscle seize up. “OH FUCK!”

“You’re hurting him!” Elsie says with worry. She wasn’t wrong. Try as you might you couldn’t loosen up enough for the burn to ease.

“He’s fine. He’ll get used to it.” Fiona says with another stinging spank to your butt. “Come on, keep going.”

“Hnnngh!” You whine, your body and mind trapped between two options. “Fuuuck, it’s so big! So fucking big! GNNNGH!”

Zoey reaches up to stroke your grimacing face. “You can do it Jesse.” She whispers. “We can do it, together.”

The mix of El’s worry, Zoey’s encouragement, Fiona’s sadism, and your own out of control lust was an odd combination to say the least. To say nothing about Fiona mimicking your movement in such a way that it was almost like you were penetrating your own ass, in the fucking kitchen of all places. You look down at Zoey and nod your head, nothing was about to stop you now. Summoning your courage you push deeper.

“Ohhhhhhhh!” Zoey’s soft voice moans as you slide three…four…five inches in. “Ohhhh myyyy God!” Her furrowed brow and wide open mouth expressing her own effort in taking a cock that dwarfed any other she’d ever had before. “Geeez!”

You knew it was coming but that did little to prepare you. Four…five…six beefy booty stretching inches fill your ass.

“Owwww!” You groan as you endure the blissful agony. As the pleasure rose so did the pain, both of them nearly unbearable. “Ohhh fuuuuck!”

“Atta boy. Let me hear you.” Fiona says proudly. “Taking it like a fucking champ. I knew you could.”

“Are you okay Jesse?” Elsie comes around to check on you.

Through gritted teeth you nod and wave her away, too overwhelmed to talk right now. “Let me be! I’m…I’m okay. Fuuuuck!”

El then tenderly strokes Zoey’s cheek. “You okay sweet girl?”

Zoey, her own face taut but not as pained, looks over to your little sister with a love as pure as a fresh snow in her bright clear eyes. “I’m okay Elsie. Just…he’s stretching me real good. Ooooo! He’s super big.”

Your little sister smiles then leans in and kisses Zoey’s head before fading off to leave you be.

Huffing and hissing you gaze into Zoey’s eyes…and push another three inches deep into her tight tunnel. “Ohhhhh wow!” Zoey groans as her eyes roll back and her hands clutch to your sides. “Soooo deeeeep!”

A moment later you get to feel it too. “RRRRRRMMMM!” You growl as your sister’s monster anaconda stuffs your guts. The sensation of this huge living shaft of hard flesh filling your bowels and abdomen is excruciating yet sooooooo satisfying.

“Shit babe, you feel fucking incredible! I mean…really incredible.” Fiona sighs. “Fuckin hell you got a good ass baby.”

“Ohhhhh!” Those words sent your heart soaring.

With that you sink into Zoey’s gripping pussy the final bit. “Oooooooo!” She moans, impressively taking all ten girthy inches without complaint. “Ohhhh wow you’re deep! You’re so deep! Ohhhhh wow you’re deep!” She says over and over as her mind could process nothing else. “Sooooo biiig! Sooooo fuuuull! Ohhhh Jesse Bailey!”

You might have said something had your big sister not been going balls deep herself. “AAAHHHHHHH!!!”

“Fuuuuuck yeah!” Fiona exclaims in a tone that could not hide how impressed she was. “You took it all! You did it baby! That’s MY fuckin brother right there! Fuck yeah baby!” She hits you with a celebratory spank.

You even catch Elsie gasp quietly. “Wow!”

Your sphincter was on fire, the whole length of your tunnel feeling like it might burst at the seams, your guts filled to the brim with all thirteen plus inches of Fiona’s bulky lady cock. Your vision wavers as the white hot pain and heady euphoria threatens to overwhelm your consciousness. “AAAAHHHHHHH!!!” You scream in a feral voice somewhere between purgatory and paradise before crying out to the heavens above in exultation. “YESSSSS!!!”

Like a born painter putting brush to canvas for the first time, an innate writer putting words to paper, a natural athlete finding the zone, the moment Fiona’s heavy balls touch yours everything comes into sharp focus. THIS! This right here. This is what you were put on Earth to do.

Panting like a dog in heat you look back to your sister with wild eyes. “YES! Fuck me! Fuck your brother’s virgin ass! FUCK MEEEE!”

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)