Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 37

What happens when Cindy and Karen return? How do they react to Dexter?

Four too many

“So, what was up with those two?” Asked Dexter. “Are they nudists too?”

“No, I just think they spent a little too much time with Carol.” Groaned Sophie. “It’s actually kind off ironic; out of us four girls, the only one you haven’t seen naked is Carol.”

“You called?” Asked Carol, throwing her clothes on the bed.

Sophie hung her head. “And now you have four of a kind. Carol, could you really not keep your dress on? You’re making Dexter uncomfortable!”

“Oh God, I am so sorry. The last thing I want is to make my sister’s boyfriend uncomfortable.” She ran over to Dexter and hugged him tightly, burying his face in her chest. “Just tell me whenever I make you uncomfortable, and I’ll stop!”

“Wihht naww wuuld be guud.” Spoke Dexter muffled.

“Couple o’ streakers, comin’ right up!” Cheered Cindy as she was holding Karen’s hand as they ran back inside, only to be greeted by a unknown man being hugged by Carol.

“Carol, who is this?”

“Oh, this is Dexter, Sophie’s new boyfriend who just deflowered her.”

“Carol!” Sophie buried her face in her hands.

“When did he get here?” Asked Karen.

“Just as you two ran out off the room for your little streaking session.”

“Oh God.” Blushed Cindy. “Listen Dexter, normally we aren’t like that. But with the excitement of being with Carol and seeing Sophie posing in her Red Sonja costume-“

“Your what?” Asked Dexter in confusion and mild interest, seeing Sophie turning her back towards him.

“It’s a whole story. Anyway, we just… had to do something ourselves, see?”

Dexter tried as hard to hide is erection, when he suddenly felt as if another ‘accident’ will happen within seconds.

“I-I see. C-can I use t-the restroom for a bit?”

Does he make it?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)