Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 5 by norker151 norker151

Choices.....

FUCK her!

Not wanting to lose whatever this dream-like situation was, you grabbed a handful of her hair, pulled her up roughly, bent her over the sink, and began pulling down her yoga pants. Sarah gasped at the suddenness of his movements and was startled by the **** as you were generally a lot meeker.

Once her pants and flimsy underwear were around her ankles, she grabbed the sides of the sink just in time to feel the head of your cockhead starting to nudge its way into her. As the head pushed its way past her lips she gasped loudly as he felt bigger than Carl, who she had thought was the biggest she had ever been with.

She reached between you to rub her clit, as one of your hands reached up to slip under her bra and grasp a breast. She looked into the mirror and saw the lust in your eyes, it immediately made her aroused and think twice about how this was 'just helping him' and a little more like, 'this could be fun for both of us'

His expansive girth still required some gentle persuasion as her muscles relaxed and allowed him to penetrate her. After he worked his length in, she sighed in delight at the fullness, only to feel it edge in just a little more, causing her to gasp suddenly... and then push a bit farther. His dick was in uncharted territory for her and she loved the newness as well as it being him, her Ex who she had dated for two years so when they got into a rhythm it was like second nature.

"And you aren't even making me wear protection?... that's new" You smirk

"Well, it's just easier this way... If it were anyone else, they would have to wear a rubber. But it's you... and you obviously need this more" She rationalized "Also I don't carry condoms around everywhere and I know you don't either"

Pulling your length back until you feel her push back, inviting him back in. She was getting used to the girth, and now you can plow in to the hilt. Causing her to lift her head and gasp as it took her breath away. She pushed her shoulders away from the sink, which caused her back to arch even more giving a beautiful curve down and then back up to her ass. Putting one hand on her lower back and gently pushed her down a bit further. Your other hand continued to hold onto her hip, pulling and pushing her back and forth as you increase your speed and length of thrusting.

"I've never been so full." She said a touch breathless "What are you doing differently?"

"Maybe.... You just didn't know" You answer as you didn't have a clue yet. "Uhh fuck... god you feel amazing"

Sarah smirked lightly "IF this is how you fuck now.... Holy shit... uhhh Im glad I can help you out!"

With a chuckle, you start to really hammer Sarah's pussy. Enjoying the view and the mirror. You briefly let go of her tits to unhook her bra to let her magnificent 38DD tits free.

"Well... Now... Im fucking you... bareback... when... Carl doesn't know... and I'm ... going to cum inside ... your wet cunt!" you grunt out as you pummel her pussy.

"We... oh... we aren't.. fucking...Oh...Oh... I'm just helping you out... I couldn't... I couldn't just walk away without ... Doing something" she panted

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)