Eenie Meenie Miney Mo

With no expectations in your mind you let fate decide and chose at random, Going through the rhyme in your head to make the choice for you. Sarah’s room happened to be where the rhyme ended you off so you made the few quick steps towards the door. Even though you thought Sarah was the one in the shower, and had been for a while considering the time it took to get up here after you heard the first noise, you still give her door a few knocks to make sure your assumption was correct.

You heard nothing from within but as you entered the room, Lucy now in Sarah’s bed, turned to see who had entered.

“Oh it’s you” she said as she sat herself up, “I thought it would be Sarah”

She stretched a little as she rose and you could only assume she had come back here after leaving your room earlier to get some more sleep, her own bed occupied at the time.

“I can leave if you want? I just needed to talk with Sarah” you suggested, your hand still on the doorframe as you got ready to leave.

“No, no it’s fine. Sarah will wanna get ready soon and I’ll have to wake up anyway. She already woke me up earlier when she slammed the bathroom door” Lucy replied, making you hold back a smile when another of your assumptions was correct.

You had barely sat down on Sarah’s bed to chat with Lucy again when you heard the shower stop running, knowing that Sarah would be joining you shortly.

“See, told you so” Lucy joked, bringing her arms behind her in one big final stretch and your attention moving to her chest even with the oversized t-shirt she was wearing.

Lucy opened her mouth to make a comment about your gaze but Sarah’s door interrupted her before she got the chance, Sarah bursting into the room wearing only a towel wrapped around her head, her arms up as she dried it. She stopped in surprise when she saw the two of you in her room but started moving again immediately.

“Oh it’s just you guys” she curtly announced, not seeming to mind her nudity in front of either you or Lucy.

Your attention had solely been on her nude body until that comment, taking a second to see that she wasn’t in the best of moods. You took a second to compose yourself as you had gone from one **** to the other, staring at Lucy’s clothed chest to now being able to openly ogle your other sister’s body.

“You doing okay? And are you sure you don’t wanna cover up in front of Max” Lucy said, asking the first question before you got the chance.

“He’s seen it all before anyway” Sarah replied, ignoring the first question and sitting down with her back to the both of you to start blow drying her hair.

The noise interrupted any further conversation as you couldn’t talk at that volume comfortably while the hair dryer was on. You did turn back to Lucy and shrugged your shoulders regarding both Sarah’s nudity and her mood. With her back to you, you also couldn’t try and get her attention without walking right up to her and Lucy right there, you thought it best to avoid getting close to a nude Sarah if you could help it.

With nobody to talk with, you decided it was best to message Emma instead, texting to make sure she would be ready soon now that Sarah was awake. You briefly considered getting Grace to send you a selfie but you had promised her you would leave her alone and to you, that meant not using any effects even if she wasn’t aware of them.

You got a text back from Emma pretty quickly to say she was having breakfast and could be ready whenever. Another message popped up on your phone as you were reading what Emma had put and saw the sender was Lucy, looking up to see her motion to your phone to read her message.

Lucy: What’s up with Sarah?

You had already shrugged to say you didn’t know but it seemed she wanted a more detailed answer.

Max: I have no idea. She was in a good mood when we left her last night so something must have changed since then. Have you spoken to her this morning?

Lucy: Not a word, she was asleep when I went into my room so I came in here

Mom had only stepped out of her room after you had gone downstairs and you suspected she hadn’t seen or spoken with Sarah either. She would have mentioned it during breakfast if that was the case, even with the headache, so you pondered the most likely causes outside of the 3 of you.

The answer hit you quicker than you suspected when you saw that Sarah didn’t have her phone with her, most likely leaving it in Lucy’s room before she used the bathroom. The girl who had been among her friends who picked her up and had recently confessed her attraction to Sarah had most likely called or text to see how your sister was getting to school but other than that you couldn’t guess at the rest of the conversation.

Max: I’m guessing she heard from her friend who usually picks her up

A look of realisation passed over Lucy’s face after your guess and made you think you were on the right track.

Max: I don’t know what she could have said though. They weren’t on the best of terms yesterday so what could she have done to make things worse?

Nothing was coming to your mind as Sarah continued to dry her hair, unaware of the silent conversation between the two of you behind her back. Lucy however seemed to have a better idea than you, looking down at her phone to type you another message.

Lucy: I have an idea. You should wait outside though. Plus you already got more than enough glances at her body so I don’t want you watching her get changed either.

You wanted to complain about that last comment but your curiosity as to what could have happened was a stronger desire.

Just as you were looking down, Lucy preempted your message before you could even type out your first word.

Lucy: Sarah said not to share what we discussed so I won’t.

She was already motioning to the door when you looked up at her so with a sigh drowned out by the noise in the room, you got up from the bed and made your way to the door. You still hadn’t sorted out your morning plans with Sarah which had been the whole reason you came in here in the first place but to avoid stressing Sarah for the moment, you sent Lucy one last text before you shut the door behind you.

Max: Just make sure to tell her, me and Emma will be waiting for her when she’s ready.