Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 5 by TuskedCarpenter TuskedCarpenter

Do you do anything with it right then or continue snuggling?

Don't be the main character at someone else's wedding

You grin back, but you've already interrupted the service once, and filled the bride's pussy with cum, so you decide to wait until afterward.

"What are you thinking about?" Brianna whispers to you while you roll her nipple between your fingertips.

"****," you tell her honestly.

She looks startled.

"The first time I fucked Aisha and Tanisha together," you explain hastily.

"Oh, okay. Makes sense," she agrees.

"So I was thinking, it would make me really happy if I fucked Jada, and then you licked my cum out of her pussy. Maybe while I was fucking you in the ass, even." Jada starts breathing very fast.

"That would be wonderful!" Brianna says. She sounds thrilled.

"Has either of you eaten pussy before?"

She closes her eyes for a moment. "Oh, not in a long time," she says. "And I'm sure Jada hasn't either, isn't that right?"

Jada bites her lip, but doesn't answer.

Brianna's eyebrows go up. She looks askance at her daughter. "Jada?! Jada, who -"

"They're starting the vows!" the girl hisses.

You stop asking questions and pay attention to the service. Anton genuinely is your very good friend, and you're genuinely happy for him, even though you fucked his wife-to-be less than an hour ago, you intend to fuck her at least once more before she leaves for her honeymoon, and you're planning a threesome with his mom and his 18-year-old sister, whose virginity you will be taking.

They've gone to the trouble of writing individual vows; to your surprise and delight, they've both mentioned you by name! Anton says that the luckiest day of his life was when you introduced him to Aisha (which is a bit of an exaggeration of your role, but hey), and Aisha promises to forsake all others except for you and anyone you want her to have lesbian sex with.

They glance at you; you smile widely, and give them two energetic thumbs up. The pastor smiles too, and then formally asks them if they're sure this is what they want.

They both say yes.

"Then, by the power vested in me, I now pronounce you, Anton, and you, Aisha, husband and wife. You may kiss the bride."

They kiss passionately. Everyone cheers, including you.

The reception is - well, you were expecting the dinner to be first, but instead they start the music. It's nice music, at least. And you're not actually hungry right now. Horny, yes, but not hungry. So while Anton and Aisha have their very first dance as a married couple, you lead Brianna and Jada off into a quiet corner, where you strip Jada completely naked.

"Isn't she gorgeous, John?" Brianna says proudly. She squeezes Jada's tits and then runs a finger up and down Jada's neatly-trimmed slit. "Look how wet she is! You're going to have such a good time fucking her!"

Jada is smiling, but also trembling. Her dark brown nipples are sticking out stiff with arousal, but she keeps looking past you into the crowd.

"Are you nervous?" you ask her gently.

"Little bit?" she replies, her voice quiet.

You've got a sneaking suspicion about what's going on here.

"Would it help if you had your pussy eaten before I fucked you?" you suggest.

She nods energetically.

"And who do you want to do it? Me? Or your mom?"

She doesn't answer, and is now very obviously looking for someone.

"Jada, what -", Brianna begins, and then Jada's face lights up as another girl - who, like almost everyone here, is black - emerges from the crowd and heads straight for the three of you.

"Bethany!" Jada says, excited, and you recognize the pastor's daughter.

"Jada!" Bethany says, beaming. "I was looking for you!" They clasp each other's hands and look into each other's eyes, and then Bethany's gaze drifts down to Jada's naked tits and pussy, and she licks her lips. Like - you now realize - her girlfriend, Bethany is petite, although maybe an inch taller and a cup size bigger, with bigger glasses, a bigger ass, and braids instead of a hair bun.

She's also just as shy and quiet, and dressed very plainly and uninterestingly, which is why you hadn't really thought about fucking her - not when there are so many women here who are loudly enthusiastic about servicing your cock. But she's definitely cute enough to fuck, and you're looking forward to having her wail your name as you fill her full of semen.

"Ah," Brianna says. "This is why you didn't want to tell me whose pussy you've been eating?"

Both girls blush and nod.

"Does your father know?" Brianna goes on.

Bethany's eyes widen, and she shakes her head firmly.

"I was hoping Bethany could watch when you take my virginity," Jada tells you shyly. "And... and maybe... participate?"

"I'm a virgin too!" Bethany declares, and shows you her purity ring. "... except for, uh, the stuff Jada and I did."

"Were you two hoping that I'd fuck you together so you could claim that being girlfriends was my idea?" you ask, amused.

They glance at each other, and then nod in embarrassment.

Brianna gasps, scandalized. "Jada! John fucking your holes is for his benefit, not yours!"

You chuckle. "It's fine," you reassure Brianna as you begin undressing her and tossing her clothes onto a chair. "I probably would have told them to be girlfriends anyway."

This isn't actually true, but the sheer gratitude that pours off Jada and Bethany when you say this is heart-warming, and also dick-hardening. And now you are going to tell them to be girlfriends, so what difference does it make?

Once Brianna is nude too, you note with approval that her pussy is completely shaved. She realizes where you're looking, and blushes. "I've been shaving my pussy for you ever since Anton told me you were invited to the wedding!"

"Hands and knees," you tell her.

"Anything for you," she assures you, and assumes the position. You step out of your pants, underpants, and socks and shoes again, grab onto her hip with one hand, line your cock up with her pussy with the other, and then sink it into her nice and deep. She's hot as a furnace, and drenched with lust, and honestly tighter than you had expected for a woman who's had two children. She moves in rhythm with you; it's wonderful.

Bethany and Jada are staring in awe as you fuck Brianna. Also, they're masturbating.

Cumming in Aisha earlier will help you last longer this time, so you figure you might as well talk about a few things.

"Incidentally, Brianna," you ask, "I was wondering - whose pussy have you been eating?"

She freezes, which is an odd sensation given that you're still actively fucking her. "I'm going to lick your cum out of Jada's pussy after you fuck her," she says hesitantly. "And I assume I'm going to lick it out of Bethany after you fuck her."

Bethany gasps, and starts fingering herself much faster.

You smile. "That's true," you say to Brianna, "but I was wondering whose pussy you ate a long time ago." She grunts, and squeezes your cock inside herself. "More!" she says. "Harder!" Which is a lovely thing to hear from a woman you're fucking, but not an answer to your question.

You keep one hand on her hip, and reach around with your other hand to rub her clit. She whines happily, but still doesn't answer you.

You're about to tell her that it would make you happy to know, when a loud voice says "Ah! There you are, Bethany! Are you bothering John when he's trying to fuck attractive women?! Come away, now."

To your shock, the pastor walks up to Bethany, grabs her arm as she's masturbating - seriously, her tits are out and everything - and starts trying to drag her away.

"I - I -," she sputters. "But -," Jada tries, but then they both blush and neither of them says anything else. Brianna looks back over her shoulder at you with a 'you're the one making the decisions' expression.

You have no idea how to respond. Sure, you can fuck 95% of the women here and they'll love it, but you were specifically interested in fucking Bethany and Jada together.

(To be absolutely honest, if there was another pair of shy nerdy teenage lesbian girlfriends here for you to have a threeway with, you might feel differently. But there isn't, so you get to feel righteous. Plus, Brianna.)

"I'm so very sorry, John," the pastor says. "Seriously, Bethany, you're nearly nineteen, you should know better than this -"

You step back from Brianna, your erection gone. You close your eyes for a few seconds and resist the urge to clench your fists. He means well, you remind yourself as the pastor rambles on about how his daughter isn't good enough for you, and about the gift of the Holy Spirit and how blessed you are among the children of the Lord and how fortunate they are to have had you come by and blah blah blah.

The pastor trails off with the sudden realization that his apology is making things worse.

"... ah, what's wrong?" he asks nervously.

You take a deep breath. There's no call to yell at him, honestly. "Firstly," you say, "I think you're being terribly unfair to Bethany. She's very pretty, and I've been looking forward to taking her virginity and filling her full of my cum. In fact, it would make me really happy if I could watch her and Jada licking each other out. I might even want them to become girlfriends."

The pastor looks surprised, but hugs Bethany, being careful not to touch her exposed tits. "I'm so proud of you!" he tells her. "Be sure to satisfy John properly, with your whole body! And remember - the Lord will forgive you for whatever it takes to make John happy, even if it's a sin. But you shouldn't take pleasure in it. Oh, and give me your purity ring, you won't need it any more."

With that horrible advice - what, does he expect her to not orgasm? - he takes the ring off her unresisting finger and pockets it, then gives her a gentle kiss on the forehead and an equally gentle push in your direction. "There you go, John! Enjoy her!"

Bethany looks stunned, especially by the loss of the ring, but obediently goes back to where she had been standing next to Jada. After a moment, they hold hands.

It's remarkable - you can still tell that he means well, but now you're getting pissed off at him for how he's treating his daughter. And you really, really don't want to get into an argument with the pastor who did Anton and Aisha's wedding, at their wedding reception.

He looks at you, clearly able to tell that you're still not happy. "What was the second thing?" he asks.

You're boring and you're an asshole to your daughter, you don't say. Instead, you give him a much simpler answer:

"Your timing needs work."

"My...?"

"Pastor," you tell him in as polite a tone as you can manage, "I was in the middle of fucking a woman, balls-deep in her pussy, when you walked up to me and tried to start a conversation."

"Oh!" he says, startled. "I didn't mean to - I mean, Bethany was bothering - I thought - I just wanted to - I'm very sorry, I'll, uh, I'll go talk to some other people! God bless you!", and he scurries off.

In the background, you can hear that the DJ has started a dance mix, which for some godforsaken reason includes the "YMCA" song.

Several other attractive black women, aware of your unhappiness, look in your direction, but you're already with two and a half beautiful naked women - make that three, as Bethany finishes stripping - and the general attitude appears to be "he's got three; if he wants more, he'll ask".

Bethany reaches out with her soft hand and gently strokes your cock. Her fingers are wet and slick with her juices. You stiffen in her grip. "I really liked watching you have sex with Jada's mom," she says quietly. "It made me so horny." "Me too," says Jada.

"So let's try this again," you tell them. "Jada, you said you wanted your pussy eaten before I fuck you. So Brianna's going to eat your pussy while I fuck her, and Bethany's going to make out with you."

You kiss Jada, then Bethany, and then get Brianna back into position. The second attempt at fucking her goes a lot better. You pound away at her while she slurps and licks at her daughter's pussy; Jada's squeals of sexual bliss are muffled by Bethany's tongue in her mouth. After several minutes, Jada has a very loud orgasm, squirting all over Brianna's face; this is so hot that it pushes you into your own climax, and you spurt and spurt and spurt into Brianna's hot fuckhole, and you're not sure whether it's your orgasm or Jada's that triggers Brianna's, but it doesn't matter - what's important is the three orgasms... and Bethany catches up with you, making four with her fingers deep inside herself.

Now the song playing is "Who Let the Dogs Out". Anton and Aisha are good people, and you very much hope that they didn't pick all the songs on this playlist.

You pull out of Brianna and begin pondering whether you want Jada or Bethany to lick her clean, and which of the two you want to fuck first, and if you want to do it missionary or -

... you realize the pastor is standing right next to you. Again.

"John! Hello! I'm sorry to bother you again," the pastor says cheerfully, and you start to wonder if he's doing this on purpose. Well, at least this time he waited until you had cum.

"I really do want to make it up to you for being such a bother earlier," he says. "I saw you were having such a good time with Brianna and Jada together, the whole mother-daughter thing which I understand is very popular these days, and since you're going to be, uh, having sex with Bethany, I thought you'd enjoy having her mother too!"

He presents you with his wife: a woman who looks even more repressed and nervous than Bethany. She's equally pretty, which probably means the pastor doesn't appreciate her either, and looks twenty years younger than her husband. She and Brianna are staring at each other.

"This is -" the pastor begins.

"... Miriam," Brianna finishes in barely a whisper.

Is there any reason for Brianna to be staring at Miriam other than the obvious?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)